Chris Dawes on the table

[Macca 16,173]

What we think a player might be worth might be entirely different to how another club might view that player

So ... "Trade him, he's no good" can be associated with "We could get a 2nd rounder for him" ... it's often a buyers and a sellers market.

That "want" often depends on the player involved - it's not an across the board thinking. 2 identical types of players may not be of any interest at all to any club or maybe one will attract interest. Or both might attract interest. Chaos can often rule with these type of things.

We've seen it happen countless times before ... often the "said" player might have had a good game against a certain team and that team's hierarchy remembers that good game. There are other reasons too of course - role player required or such like. Look at the interest that the Tigers suddenly had in Trengove - who saw that coming?

It should also be noted that T-Mac played forward towards the end of the season and Frawley played forward for most of the 2014 season - we might trade or draft for a tall or 2 who can play forward and O-Mac, Frost and even Petracca and vandenBerg can't be ruled out as tall(ish) forward options.

Roos has no doubt got some firm ideas about how he wants to structure our forward line ... we supporters are almost certainly in the dark on those ideas.

[Chris 2,892]

There are several players that will NEVER play in the MFC's next Grand final team, Dawes is one of them.

Given that, what point then does it serve to keep him?

Not much of a team left if that is the list management philosophy.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,876]

I am assuming things in my hypothetical scenarios?

You are surmising he had a frontloaded contract to better the chances he can be traded.

And yes, you can convince me and others that Dawes' has had it, but then don't tell me he has a market.

That dog don't hunt.

When Dawes trade rumour first surfaced last night on the Dawes player review thread, I actually thought it was a joke.

If Freo wants him and the club is happy to move him on they must have someone lined up and we would only be guessing as to who that might be.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Dawes has less value than Melksham.

Melksham is a young experienced mid who will continue to improve worth an early second round pick to most sides looking to build midfield depth. He would be in the starting 22 in most sides.

Dawes is an experienced 2nd forward with a solid workrate, provides a contest and a good kick for goal but is not a goid mark and his body is letting him down so probably has 1-2 seasons of footy left in him. Sides may be interested if they lack a key forward and are looking for a stop gap or protection while they develop their own talent.

Dawes is worth less than Melksham.

I disagree chookrat. if your only thinking physically onfield in terms of stats, then you might be right?

but in a clubs list, that has way too much immaturity, & youth gotten ahead of themselves, or one that's lost its way. Then a mature level head, helping to do a realignment, he would from my point of view, be very helpful.

Melksham helps, as he's in an area we are lacking from tip to toe. & he helps Goodwin as a loyal helper. he bolsters our mid range mids, & helps raise the overall level of our mids. maybe we can improve Melks as well.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

I was hoping this would arise. We won't get far if we continue to play him. Can't carry him for 1 or 2 decent performances per year. Just too slow, out of touch, unfit. If he could mark or ruck he'd be of some value. If he can slot into another team then good on him, find the right environment.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,876]

The big question is who are they bringing in??

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

Perhaps a slight exaggeration in the cool light of day

It's not Fitzpatrick per se, more-so it would signal the club is still making poor decisions.

That said, it won't happen.

We did it with Jetta and it worked out pretty well. Plenty of people on here didn't rate Nev either.

[Nasher 33,047]

We did it with Jetta and it worked out pretty well. Plenty of people on here didn't rate Nev either.

I doubt ProDee needs it explained to him that people get it wrong sometimes. Nonetheless, I don't think we have with Fitz.

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

I doubt ProDee needs it explained to him that people get it wrong sometimes. Nonetheless, I don't think we have with Fitz.

I have a sneaking suspicion that he won't make it to the rookie draft.

[mo64 5,209]

I have a sneaking suspicion that he won't make it to the rookie draft.

Well he can walk to any club as a DFA. Somehow I doubt that any club will waste a spot on their list. Rookie draft or nothing.

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

Well he can walk to any club as a DFA. Somehow I doubt that any club will waste a spot on their list. Rookie draft or nothing.

We shall see.

[monoccular 16,064]

There must be something happening behind the scenes that we're not aware off.

No, surely not :-))

[beelzebub 22,225]

I am assuming things in my hypothetical scenarios?

You are surmising he had a frontloaded contract to better the chances he can be traded.

You are

And

He is

Get over it

Put the bull terrier away he called out. That's all

Both of you are surmising...go get an Ice cream 5 and move on

[Moonshadow 16,168]

I so want Fitzy rookied now.

[jumbo returns 6,488]

I still think Dawes is a required player.

[dee-luded 2,958]

I still think Dawes is a required player.

yes, But the question is where? where is his best fit... we can't afford his luxury.

[jumbo returns 6,488]

yes, But the question is where? where is his best fit... we can't afford his luxury.

Up the ground, d-l....perfect foil for wonder boy...

[dee-luded 2,958]

Up the ground, d-l....perfect foil for wonder boy...

hard hands, soft feet, ummh; & TMac the leadup key forward !!! & with Frosty icing the opposition forwards, & Lil Oscar Mac doing his best star impersonations, down in the pocket... I really don't see CD's place.

I think he better take a new contract elsewhere now, whilst he still can. because after next year, he may be done & gone.

[What 18,810]

I still think Dawes is a required player.

Highly doubtful

[Fat Tony 4,403]

I think Dawes's contract would have been heavily front loaded, and while I don't rate him very highly, I wouldn't be giving him away for a low pick. Maybe we can turn our second rounder plus Dawes into Freo's first round pick.

[chook fowler 18,226]

Apparently Hogan likes playing with him - that's good enough for me.

[CBDees 3,162]

Trade him for Melksham and retain our first two,picks! Essendon may well want an experienced KPP to replace Carlisle.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Apparently Hogan likes playing with him - that's good enough for me.

I bet Hogan likes playing with TMac as well... & that OK with moi.

[praha 10,277]

Trade him for Melksham and retain our first two,picks! Essendon may well want an experienced KPP to replace Carlisle.

Pity Dawes doesn't play like a KPP.

[dpositive 1,547]

Dawes fortunately has more going for him than his goal tally.

He provides a contest and makes space on the ground for Hogan who likes playing with him probably for those reasons.

More importantly he has played in a final series and will add that experience to our squad.

We can make the finals this year and as they say it is a new season. I will be hoping that Dawes is still there to help lift his teammates to that higher level when anything is possible.