Tim Membrey

[MadAsHell 4,089]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/tim-membrey-puts-contract-talks-on-hold-amid-sydneys-loaded-forward-line/story-fni5fan7-1227064471118

Worth a look? Put contract talks on hold. 188cm KPF in the Jack Darling mould. Could be a handy pick up. As we saw this year, without Hogan & Clark, apart from Pedersen we didn't really have anyone else to fill that 3rd tall forward spot.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/tim-membrey-puts-contract-talks-on-hold-amid-sydneys-loaded-forward-line/story-fni5fan7-1227064471118

Worth a look? Put contract talks on hold. 188cm KPF in the Jack Darling mould. Could be a handy pick up. As we saw this year, without Hogan & Clark, apart from Pedersen we didn't really have anyone else to fill that 3rd tall forward spot.

I was amazed he was drafted as late as he was. Was never going to get a chance while the Swans had all their tall forwards.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Yes please. As it stands the only tall forwards on our list that I rate of AFL standard are Hogan, Dawes and Pedersen.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,526]

I don't think he'd be high on our list but you never know. I have not seen him play and truthfully carving it up in the NEAFL makes it hard to judge.

[rjay 24,217]

Yes please. As it stands the only tall forwards on our list that I rate of AFL standard are Hogan, Dawes and Pedersen.

At 188cm he hardly rates as a tall forward, in fact he is just an average size mid.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

At 188cm he hardly rates as a tall forward, in fact he is just an average size mid.

Okay, call him a medium forward. Whatever way you slice it, our forward line is lacking.

[Dockett 32 1,213]

The 200+ blokes are the ones that are hard to match up on and cause the trouble.

[dazzledavey36 50,026]

The 200+ blokes are the ones that are hard to match up on and cause the trouble.

Thats where I hope Fitzpatrick finally becomes an established player for us.

200cm super quick forwards don't grow on trees.

Edited September 20, 2014 by dazzledavey36

[Redleg 38,819]

Thats where I hope Fitzpatrick fjnally becomes an established player for us.

200cm super quick forwards don't grow on trees.

Agree. I reckon Fitzy lacks confidence in his ability. A breakout game could change everything.

[Webber 10,195]

Thats where I hope Fitzpatrick finally becomes an established player for us.

200cm super quick forwards don't grow on trees.

This. So far, he's been a classic MFC tease. If all his planets align, Jack Fitzpatrick could be a more than valuable regular. If not, he's just part of the frustration heap.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Thats where I hope Fitzpatrick finally becomes an established player for us.

200cm super quick forwards don't grow on trees.

Agile and speedy tall athletes do grow on trees and that's exactly what Fitzy is.

He is not a natural footballer.

I've never rated him, I don't believe he will become a consistent AFL footballer and quite frankly I think he was another very speculative late pick by the same recruiting staff that got so many picks wrong.

He'll be gone within a year or two.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Agile and speedy tall athletes do grow on trees and that's exactly what Fitzy is.

He is not a natural footballer.

I've never rated him, I don't believe he will become a consistent AFL footballer and quite frankly I think he was another very speculative late pick by the same recruiting staff that got so many picks wrong.

He'll be gone within a year or two.

Couldn't agree more. Kicked a couple of goals at the end of the year when the heat was off to blind some supporters to his ability, but early in the season when the heat was on against opposition who were having far more of a crack the bloke looked lost. His height is keeping him on the list at the minute, doesn't bring much else to the table.

Membrey is worth a look but there are a few other clubs down here who lack a target up forward as well.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

As for Membrey, I fully endorse targeting a highly talented forward who can't get a gig in what is easily the most potent forward line in the AFL.

[Deez 298]

definitely worth a look

Edited September 20, 2014 by Deez

[jabberwocky 2,301]

As for Membrey, I fully endorse targeting a highly talented forward who can't get a gig in what is easily the most potent forward line in the AFL.

and probably midfield

and defence.

I think most clubs would be looking at Sydney and seeing if any of thier second tier juniors will be seeking more opportunity and dollars.

[chook fowler 18,690]

Could be worth a look. All our recruiting focus seems biased towards midfielders however we desperately need forwards, tall and small.

[Vince Vega 40]

I've never seen him play, so my only opinion of him is that he has some of the worst tattoos I've ever seen.

[spirit of norm smith 13,680]

Worth a look depending on other trades. Prefer Sam Frost to help the defence if Frawley goes.

[Machsy 2,858]

Mid-sized leading forward dominating in the weakest secondary competition.

Meh.

For his role, you need to cover an exceptional amount of ground, like a Robbie Grey and have exceptional skills, or else you're just a tweeter trying to play taller than you are and usually doing a pretty bad job of it.

Can't see what value he'd bring to the dees.

He'd get dominated by a tall defender, and he's simply not a good high half forward, like you'd want him to be.

[Beats 190]

Re: Membrey, not sure what he brings to the table at AFL level. Was a highly talented junior (and captained Vic Metro?) but was always a man child, was very good as an undersized KPF (being able to dominate physically smaller opponents) and had some decent spells through the midfield. Unfortunately he's not tall enough to play as a regular KPF at AFL level, but has decent skills and a good footy brain.

Agile and speedy tall athletes do grow on trees and that's exactly what Fitzy is.
He is not a natural footballer.
I've never rated him, I don't believe he will become a consistent AFL footballer and quite frankly I think he was another very speculative late pick by the same recruiting staff that got so many picks wrong.
He'll be gone within a year or two.

Going to respectfully disagree with this - you can't kick a centimetre perfect banana from 50m out on the boundary without having some form of football skills.

In his underage year at TAC cup level after a number of impressive performances (incl. for Vic Metro in the grand final) he was being talked up as a top 5 pick. In his top age year he was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes and he didn't show any of his under age form after that. I believe that he was managing chronic fatigue on top of diabetes for the majority of this year. I'm unsure if he'll ever make it due to his health concerns, but he definitely has the talent.

FWIW - although their recuriting with early picks was terrible, BP's team did manage to take Howe, Mcdonald, Gawn, Jetta, Jurrah, Wona and Bail with 'speculative late picks'.

[Gippsland Dee 367]

Re: Membrey, not sure what he brings to the table at AFL level. Was a highly talented junior (and captained Vic Metro?) but was always a man child, was very good as an undersized KPF (being able to dominate physically smaller opponents) and had some decent spells through the midfield. Unfortunately he's not tall enough to play as a regular KPF at AFL level, but has decent skills and a good footy brain.

Brad green was 184cm, and tim membrey is 188cm. Brad green, while not being a dominant forward was still able to hold his own and kick a couple of goals a game for us as well as moving through the middle a bit, and I think membrey could be similar for us as green was.

[SaberFang 7,141]

Has requested a trade to St Kilda so I can only assume we were never interested.

[Demon Disciple 11,256]

Said he was impressed with facilities at Seaford. One of the few at the Saints who would be. Has anyone told him they're leaving that dump?

[SaberFang 7,141]

I'm thinking they just offered him the fattest paycheck.

Can't begrudge a guy from leaving the grand finalists for wooden spooners though, but surely there isn't much upside to go to the Saints right now. Once Roo retires they're buggered.

[daisycutter 28,733]

Said he was impressed with facilities at Seaford. One of the few at the Saints who would be. Has anyone told him they're leaving that dump?

seaford? LOL that's priceless

a future sports journo that one