Worst 1st rnd draft pick in history...clue: not Melbourne

[pitchfork 181]

We've made some pretty shocking picks in our past, but nothing tops this for worst ever first round pick.

Stumbled upon this, though I'd share it.

------

Pick #9 1995.

* This player missed the previous season due to serious career threatening injury.

* Was 27 years old at the time.

For the Footscra(z)y Bulldogs, Allen Jakovich.

He was taken from us far too soon, but I can't think of a comparable example.

- Was there any contemporaneous criticism of the pick? Too young at the time to be anything but disappointed by seeing Allen in another teams jumper.

[Nasher 33,617]

Don't see how that one is any worse than any of the many first rounders who didn't manage a single game.

[whatwhat say what 23,479]

Luke Molan.

[JackVineyForPresident 310]

Don't see how that one is any worse than any of the many first rounders who didn't manage a single game.

2002- Nick Smith pick 15

Daniel Bell pick 14 not far behind

There have been some bad ones.

Luke Molan?

[Little Goffy 14,760]

Mitch Thorp for Hawthorn.

C-c-c-c-c-COMBO BREAKER!

[pitchfork 181]

Luke Molan, Nick Smith, Lucas Cook...etc.

Bad outcomes, but the pick is not quite as outrageous as that. Imagine if that was taken today.

[Little Richard 6,265]

Surely Lucas Cook would have to go down as one of the worst picks ever? Pick 12 and never played a single game.

And in this day and age of drafting...

[pitchfork 181]

Ok...I concede I won't win this one.

I'd love to start another thread on this, but too ashamed.

Are people aware that Nathan Jones is so tough he had a wrestler named and modelled after him?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathan_Jones_(wrestler)

[Chelly 844]

Worst thread ever.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,839]

Drafting in those days (1995) was still a work in progress, it had nowhere near the time, resources, staff etc that we have today. And even now we still get errors.

[dee-eee 231]

The Toiges had a couple of ripper number one picks in the late 1980's : Anthony Banik and Richard Lounder.......enough said !

[Earl Hood 6,144]

I checked the records we took Donald Cockatoo Collins at number 11 the same draft!! I think that one gazumped The Jackovich pick, which if you look at that draft may have been inspired if he had regained his fitness. I think I remember we picked Donald that year because his brother was also with us as a promise to his mother. Very good of us but not very professional. Neither of the boys could really play as I remember.

[darkhorse72 1,928]

The

I checked the records we took Donald Cockatoo Collins at number 11 the same draft!! I think that one gazumped The Jackovich pick, which if you look at that draft may have been inspired if he had regained his fitness. I think I remember we picked Donald that year because his brother was also with us as a promise to his mother. Very good of us but not very professional. Neither of the boys could really play as I remember.

I remember the noise we made when they both debut in the same match, round one or two. An early example of pumping up new players.

Jacko was a high risk pick for the doggies who needed a forward. Didn't pay off. They were criticised for it at the time. While Jacko came back overweight from his injury at the start of pre-season there must have been something more to dump him so quick? Anyone know.

[DeeZee 7,445]

Kruezer?

Josh Fraser?

[monoccular 17,653]

Surely Lucas Cook would have to go down as one of the worst picks ever? Pick 12 and never played a single game.

And in this day and age of drafting...

One would have to agree.

And for those who continue to harp on Luke Molan - the poor guy broke his leg IIR pre first season then dislocated shoulders in his come back VFL games.......so how can one possibly asses his worth?? He never had an opportunity to show one way or the other. Should this have all been foreseen?

There are plenty more who struggled in VFL, fully fit, and never made it.

Edited April 25, 2014 by monoccular

[Alcho Dee 269]

Richard Tambling. End thread.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Surely Tom $cully???

[praha 11,253]

Nah.

Dogs took a chance on a proven forward. Played a few good games for them. Far from the worst.

[Little Richard 6,265]

Kruezer?

Josh Fraser?

Josh Fraser might not have been a great ruckman but he still played 218 games. Hardly a failure.

Kruezer has been good and may come good yet.

[John Crow Batty 8,882]

Surely Tom $cully???

And he perhaps is still currently the highest payed player in AFL history. So glad he was poached. There must be at least a dozen 2nd year midfielders in the game that are far better than him at the moment on base wages.

Edited April 25, 2014 by america de cali

[DeeZee 7,445]

Josh Fraser might not have been a great ruckman but he still played 218 games. Hardly a failure.

Kruezer has been good and may come good yet.

Neither played like number one picks.

[Go the Biff 3,457]

The Toiges had a couple of ripper number one picks in the late 1980's : Anthony Banik and Richard Lounder.......enough said !

I'll give you Lounder but Banik gets unfairly maligned. Was a pretty good player in his first year or two.

Then he got crook. Glandular fever or CFS or something. Never really made it back after that.

[Machsy 2,858]

People always seem to forget Aaron Fiora.

But at the same time, Fremantle people have admitted they desperately wanted Fiora and were disappointed when they had to settle for Pavlich.

[P-man 13,366]

Worst thread ever.

In this instance, I tend to agree.

[T-34 409]

Pick 4 1994 - David Strooper St.Kilda, would be up there as well.