I'll give you Lounder but Banik gets unfairly maligned. Was a pretty good player in his first year or two.

Then he got crook. Glandular fever or CFS or something. Never really made it back after that.

I remember Banik as a very average player .....slow , solidly built half back flanker with thighs like the young Jobe Watson . An odd choice for top draft pick .

Richard Tambling....Darren Gaspar???

Lucas Cook by a mile.

People always seem to forget Aaron Fiora.

But at the same time, Fremantle people have admitted they desperately wanted Fiora and were disappointed when they had to settle for Pavlich.

C'mon. The guy played nearly 10 years and almost 150 games, he's no Lucas Cook.

It is not an exact science and we are not robinson crusoe in picking the wrong ones

Chris Egan, Oakley-Nicholls,Kane Tenace, Beau Dowler, Beau Muston,Fergus Watts, Mitch Thorp, Laurence Angwin, Cayden Beetham, Andrew Mcdougall, Ryan Fitzgerald, John Hutton, Riley Dunn

and I am sure we could go on forever

Lucas Cook by a mile.

Maybe add James Cook ... not as bad though

Surely Tom $cully???

Nope - worst trade ever.

Actually, no it isn't - Franklin to the Swans for $10m over 9 seasons wins that one.

And nothing will ever beat it.

Lucas Cook. In the times of 8 recruiting officers, U18 games x6, full medical and physch test, interviews etc etc.

I spoke to him at a function. Shy. Not too keen in AFL. We got it wring in search of a key forward.

I still remember people referring to him as 'The Cookie Monster' after we drafted him. He and Watts were going to be our twin towers, a coupling of beastly forwards better than Franklin and Roughead.

Going through the last 13 drafts there has been quite a few complete duds in the first round and also top ten of every draft. Overly subjective discussion who was worse than who with many variable reasons why they failed. Many were never cursed by the hype of a Number 1 or 2 pick and quietly faded away.

IMO the biggest dud of them all though not through draft was Brian Peake who came to Geelong. Arrived at Kardinia Park like royalty by helicopter and greeted by thousands of cheering fans. Made front page in the newspapers and leading televised news. Made captain after not too many games. At best was a very ordinary sluggish midfileder who never ever remotely lived up to his State of origin heroics.

Edited April 25, 201411 yr by america de cali

Maybe add James Cook ... not as bad though

James Cook was going gang busters - I think maybe leading the Coleman - until about 5 rounds in he injured his ankle (Norm Smith curse again) and was never seen again.

And he perhaps is still currently the highest payed player in AFL history. So glad he was poached. There must be at least a dozen 2nd year midfielders in the game that are far better than him at the moment on base wages.

He isnt the highest paid pa at the moment.

He was in his first year where he was on $2m but sub mill after that. (According to the media)

I laughed at my hawthorn friends when they complained about Franklin and reminded them about $cully and his $2m first year. What a joke. Afl stepped in for Hawthorn and we get robbed by them

Surely Tom $cully???

yep, but the compensation for them stealing our mistake is nice.

James Cook was going gang busters - I think maybe leading the Coleman - until about 5 rounds in he injured his ankle (Norm Smith curse again) and was never seen again.

captain material

hi monocc

James Cook was going gang busters - I think maybe leading the Coleman - until about 5 rounds in he injured his ankle (Norm Smith curse again) and was never seen again.

captain material

hi monocc

Like his namesake, I think he was invited to dinner by some Hawaiian locals and disappeared. Has anyone seen him?

What about all the South Australians that Brisbane picked in the late 80's despite the fact that they had absolutely no interest in joining?