All about Mitch Clark

[Carlos Danger 380]

Or we could have kept both picks to draft 2 "ready to go in 2013" 18 year olds.

Even if it meant risking the services of Dawes: "Toumpas, Wines, Grundy, Viney" looked a lot better than "Hogan, Toumpas, Barry, Viney".

And it still does now.

Edited March 27, 2014 by Carlos Danger

[stuie 7,374]

Or we could have kept both picks to draft 2 "ready to go in 2013" 18 year olds.

Even if it meant risking the services of Dawes: "Toumpas, Wines, Grundy, Viney" looked a lot better than "Hogan, Toumpas, Barry, Viney".

And it still does now.

How were we able to get Wines AND Toumpas tho?

[Carlos Danger 380]

We had picks 3 and 4.

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

How were we able to get Wines AND Toumpas tho?

the only way would be to not get Hogan and hope GWS didn't bid on Viney or take Toumpas or Wines

[olisik 4,060]

the only way would be to not get Hogan and hope GWS didn't bid on Viney or take Toumpas or Wines

I would also have been happy with Mayes or Macrae

[Craig Drinker 179]

How about we focus on what is, instead of what might have been?

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

I would also have been happy with Mayes or Macrae

I am still really confident Hogan and Toumpas will both be guns

[Demoneyes 562]

How about we focus on what is, instead of what might have been?

Fair call! Should-a could-a would-a doesn't get us anywhere. We have a plethora of mids, we are getting our hands on the ball more. The rest is elementary.

[Gorgoroth 12,955]

How about we focus on what is, instead of what might have been?

Can't whine enough when you do that tho.

[old dee 23,792]

I reckon we should close this thread it has all been said multiple times.

The guy is a physical and mental wreck.

Open it again in 2015 if there is something new to discuss.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

I am still really confident Hogan and Toumpas will both be guns

Only time will tell Sassy.

Lets get Hogan on the track and fully fit first. And not just that, we need to be able to deliver the ball to his advantage or into his lead much more efficiently than we've done in the last 7 years if we're to see him become that dominating forward we're all hoping for. What a relief it will be to see him running around and fit.

Toumpas is a WIP. He just seems a half yard behind AFL pace (both across the the ground and speed of disposal) at this stage. However, we wont really see his likely potential i believe until he has 60 to 80 games under his belt. He is showing glimpses of real class though which is a great sign. Being a long suffering supporter ive seen many early bloomers in the past fall by the wayside. Along with many other youngsters in our team he'll need to take many steps up from here over the next 2 or 3 seasons to compete effectively at AFL level week in and out against the very best.

Edited March 27, 2014 by Rusty Nails

[KingDingAling 3,758]

I reckon we should close this thread it has all been said multiple times.

The guy is a physical and mental wreck.

Open it again in 2015 if there is something new to discuss.

Plus 1.

[angrydee 842]

^^^^

make that +2

[jackaub 1,402]

To all those ^^ posters who say we should have kept the pick we used for Dawes: wasn't his injury problem at Collingwood related to his hand, not his knee of calf?

And had we kept the pick, we have had such a fabulous record of using our high picks (or at least perhaps in "developing" them) who knows who we would have picked and what would have become of them?

Melbourne IMO should continue to trade until they learn how to use the high draft picks

Its an apalling record We need ready made players not skinny kids or bean poles who take 10 years

[Demonsone 2,037]

Early picks are only as good as the development & culture a club provides....

How many of our failed picks from the last 6 yrs would be still playing in other clubs.. Eg haw, Sydney, Coll

Morton was not even in the top 10 in running @ WC but was a top 5 for us!

Edited March 27, 2014 by Hogan2014

[Machsy 2,858]

Or we could have kept both picks to draft 2 "ready to go in 2013" 18 year olds.

Even if it meant risking the services of Dawes: "Toumpas, Wines, Grundy, Viney" looked a lot better than "Hogan, Toumpas, Barry, Viney".

And it still does now.

Despite the fact we weren't able to get Grundy. Maybe if you said "Toumpas, Wines, Broomhead and Viney."

Even then, there's a very high chance GWS would have been happy to use one of their top 3 picks on Viney, and made the bid.

And Hogan v Wines is far from decided, especially when blue chip forwards are much harder to find than mids.

Overall, a poor appraisal.

I would also have been happy with Mayes or Macrae

Yes, hindsight is 20/20, and it would seem simultaneously premature.

Well done.

[Carlos Danger 380]

I was referring to the Scully compensation picks.

Pick 14 comes before pick 18 in a draft.

That's how "Toumpas, Wines, Grundy, Viney" would have happened.

If you need me to simplify it any further let me know.

[beelzebub 23,377]

who's this Clark fellow...

[olisik 4,060]

Despite the fact we weren't able to get Grundy. Maybe if you said "Toumpas, Wines, Broomhead and Viney."

Even then, there's a very high chance GWS would have been happy to use one of their top 3 picks on Viney, and made the bid.

And Hogan v Wines is far from decided, especially when blue chip forwards are much harder to find than mids.

Overall, a poor appraisal.

Yes, hindsight is 20/20, and it would seem simultaneously premature.

Well done.

We had pick 13, Grundy was taken about 17. How were we unable to get him?

[rjay 24,928]

We had pick 13, Grundy was taken about 17. How were we unable to get him?

It may have been part of the Hogan/Viney deal...all things are not always as they seem.

[olisik 4,060]

It may have been part of the Hogan/Viney deal...all things are not always as they seem.

Thats rubbish imo. Viney was not worth a top 2 pick. Shoot me down but clubs did not rate him that high.

[rpfc 28,433]

Thats rubbish imo. Viney was not worth a top 2 pick. Shoot me down but clubs did not rate him that high.

It's not that they didn't rate him, it's what they knew we were willing to pay.

We would have paid with Pick 3, but thankfully we got into the Hogan deal which got us a bookend and secured Viney.

[Sambo06 222]

Only time will tell Sassy.

Lets get Hogan on the track and fully fit first. And not just that, we need to be able to deliver the ball to his advantage or into his lead much more efficiently than we've done in the last 7 years if we're to see him become that dominating forward we're all hoping for. What a relief it will be to see him running around and fit.

Toumpas is a WIP. He just seems a half yard behind AFL pace (both across the the ground and speed of disposal) at this stage. However, we wont really see his likely potential i believe until he has 60 to 80 games under his belt. He is showing glimpses of real class though which is a great sign. Being a long suffering supporter ive seen many early bloomers in the past fall by the wayside. Along with many other youngsters in our team he'll need to take many steps up from here over the next 2 or 3 seasons to compete effectively at AFL level week in and out against the very best.

Oh no, here we go again. The knowledge our supporters possess is unbelievable. How you don't get a gig running your own AFL Club is amazing.

[Lordweaver 235]

clark got stynes number hmmmmmm

[monoccular 17,431]

clark got stynes number hmmmmmm

maybe it was Laurie Mithen's ??