POSTMATCH DISCUSSION - Round 11

[rufus 1,162]

Other teams get their run either from half back, or from behind stoppages. They come through at pace and are able to break a line and link up and make their next kick a creative one. We are all stagnant, handball to someone standing still and our next kick is off balance either directly to the opposition or to a contest near the boundary line.

When we take a mark, our players stroll in and out of space. If they actually ran in and out at 100% they would create some opportunities for each other, but they don't.

Our ability to defend opposition kick ins is the worst thing I have ever seen in all my time watching professional sports. I cannot understand how, after 20 odd games in charge, this coaching regime still hasn't managed to teach our players how to ensure there isn't one loose player, usually perched somewhere near the corridor, at every kick in.

Unfortunately it looks like our players are being taught defensive structures (and ordinary ones at that), rather than defensive principles. That's in addition to being taught an offensive style cashes in on momentum with a massive rush of 1 to 3 goals in a quarter.

It even looked like Collingwood felt inconvenienced to be out there today. It was like they were a bit annoyed to have to deal with us.

Worst coached team I have ever seen. I understand our board and CEO are in a sticky situation but unfortunately we need to make a move soon. We will be a 6 to 8 goal better side with decent coaching. Most of our biggest problems can be fixed...but they are not being fixed right now.

[Undeeterred 3,123]

Thank goodness for the voice of reason.

They were bigger, stronger and more experienced but we had a crack. Unfortunately, what worked in the first quarter failed after that. The loss of Dawes affected our forward structure and we simply lapsed into a frenzy of self-inflicted errors of which Collingwood took maximum advantage.

Once we eliminate the errors, these games will be 6 to 8 goal losses. Get a few of those injured blokes back and we won't be far away from winning games against our fellow cellar dwellers.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Sadly, that was about par. I think the effort has been far better the last two weeks, which makes it possibly even sadder that we still have had 90 and 80 something point losses in those games. We just butcher it and once the other team apply the pressure we do got back into our shells. I counted at least 4 or 5 times we had simple goals butchered by basic skill errors, only for Collingwood to sweep the length of the field and goal. 12 point f@#k ups I like to call them.

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

[hardtack 10,514]

How is the reality bus going for you

The wheels on this bus are square not round, they don't go round, they're square not round...

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

they've been saying that for weeks now.

[Devil In Disguise 2,278]

Our percentage has now dropped below that of the GWS. A pathetic 49.8%. Next coach please.

[Undeeterred 3,123]

Jon Ralph is in the business of drumming up frenzy and calling it news.

Of course he is under the pump.

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

[monoccular 17,413]

WTH is the latest on Dawes.

Not an excuse for a thrashing, but we would be easier to benchmark us if we had three of our key spine fit and playing - Frawley, (McDonald just back), Dawes and Clark.

[Little Richard 6,262]

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

Come on, did you just copy and paste from last weeks post match discussion?

[Carrot Top 947]

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

Brave call. Ralphie has really gone out on a limb there.

[Bang Bang Bang 5,802]

I think there’s enough to work with next year, I really do. Dawes if he can stay fit will be a good pickup, last week and the first quarter today he was immense, such a presence. I never thought much of him at Collingwood but he’s winning me over. Clark and Hogan in 2014 can hopefully string some games together too. Normally you wouldn’t pin your hopes on an 18 y/o but Hogan’s a different specimen. Throw in Jack Viney, another pre-season into Toumpas (a way to go but kicking skills elite), the Jones boys, Kent plays like a kent and has talent (great pick at 48 it would seem)… Frawley and Garland down back. We really should be playing better than we are. I’m resigned to Neeld seeing out the year but get a better football department in next year and a classy ball-user at pick 2 and we may start getting some confidence back. Probably still 2 good mids short of being anything but bottom 4 but we should at least go up from here!!!

[mjt 640]

They were bigger, stronger and more experienced but we had a crack. Unfortunately, what worked in the first quarter failed after that. The loss of Dawes affected our forward structure and we simply lapsed into a frenzy of self-inflicted errors of which Collingwood took maximum advantage.

Once we eliminate the errors, these games will be 6 to 8 goal losses. Get a few of those injured blokes back and we won't be far away from winning games against our fellow cellar dwellers.

Cant wait for 6 to 8 goal losses, thanks Coach , thanks for the progress , FMD what a a [censored] disgraceful progress, what happen to the hardest team to play against , [censored] off MN , next please.

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,593]

Watching the game in the cold the only positives are that the game ended. I am now convinced that the players aren't trying. They run hardest coming off the ground. The girl with the drinks also performed admirably.

Dawes was subbed off from shame.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

I'll let Jake Niall respond for me.

Jon Ralph just said that Neeld will come under the heat now and possible chance he still could be sacked withing next couple of weeks.

We in the media have a strong vested interest in seeing the coach sacked or the leader toppled. It’s big news that attracts large audiences and unleashes our competitive juices.

[Mickey "O" 32]

Our percentage has now dropped below that of the GWS. A pathetic 49.8%. Next coach please.

Was already below them...

[Jaded No More 68,867]

I just wish Neeld could come up with a plan to get the ball out of the defensive 50.

Also I wish we were not so epically garbage.

[Little Goffy 14,462]

Well, that was painful, getting all excited about the great standard set in the first quarter, then watching as bit by bit the wheels came off. Dawes subbed out basically ended the game as a contest, since we had no forward line at all. Our inside 50s were already spluttering out before then, though, and Collingwood just killed us over and over with rebounds which clearly broke out confidence. Before long they were cutting far too easily through the wings and getting quality attacks through that even the stalwart efforts of Colin Garland couldn't do much about.

Having multiple absolutely core players in terms of role, quality and leadership missing continues to leave a question mark on just where we are at - how much difference would they make, would things look respectable with them there?

Before anyone gets too antsy about 'Collingwood's kids killed out kids', remember the layers and how they work. Our kids out there are equivalent to the ones that the Pies would have out there if they suddenly lost all of Swan, Pendlebury, Cloke and Shaw. Our kids are fine, the trouble is that we simply do not have the numbers of quality players to provide a core for kids to work around.

Sigh. Feeling let down, again. Feeling annoyed about what will be another week or two of unhelpful people sniping from the sidelines and stirring up all the media noise they can. David Schwartz isn't the only moron out there hoping for sustained disaster, just so they can claim a mandate to become the new Kings.

Bit like people over the years who hoped for a recession so that it will help cause a change of government, Not helpful, even bordering on 'unwell' hatred and personification of problems.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

A huge proportion of their goals when the game was there to be won were from burning ball going inside 50. We took the game on and looked really good, then turned it over in the corridor so that everybody (usually Garland) got caned on the way back. Once they cut those skill errors out we'll be right in games for much longer.

This exactly. The turnovers just kill us each week.

[DemonOX 8,787]

It really is a nothing season again and that's what I feel nothing.

I am so over finding these pizz ant positives out of each Match.

Would be nice to play more than one quarter of footy too.

It seems like this will never end.

[Demon SeaMan 108]

Shattered 1st time I've left b4 last siren (due to depression- 25mins last qtr)

[Goodvibes 3,596]

Get a few of those injured blokes back and we won't be far away from winning games against our fellow cellar dwellers.

Whoo hoooo. I might crack that Robbie Flower Special Edition Port I've been saving up for a special occasion!

[RalphiusMaximus 6,024]

It's the same thing every week. We have a crack and look ok fighting for the ball, but every time we look like scoring some muppet kicks the ball behind their target, or sends a high floater into the forward 50 and hopes the forward can somehow mark it anyway, then the quick turnaround while we're out of position and a score at the other end. Why do our opponents get so much run out of defence? Because they know we can't hit our forward targets properly and they will in all probability have the chance to get back and contest if they play a little loose on their man. If we can teach our mids to kick low, hard and AHEAD of their target so the player can run on to the ball, we'll be more than half way there.

[beelzebub 23,313]

Any positives?

Nupp

[dazzledavey36 54,285]

Come on, did you just copy and paste from last weeks post match discussion?

Nah since the Essendon game