Wellingham will get weeks

[boydie 653]

6 to 8

[binman 39,117]

How times have changed... 80's early 90's that's a classic example of a well executed shirt front, now he'll go for 4weeks

No way, this type of hit was never considered a well executed shirt front. Simpson was in the air marking the ball and Wellingham made no effort to mark or hit the ball away. Gone and would have been in the 80's

[Sir Why You Little 34,979]

No way, this type of hit was never considered a well executed shirt front. Simpson was in the air marking the ball and Wellingham made no effort to mark or hit the ball away. Gone and would have been in the 80's

In the 70's it was play on!!

[mrtwister 650]

In the 70's it was play on!!

In the 70s, Simpson would have got up and played on.

Crazy bastards back then.

[Sir Why You Little 34,979]

In the 70s, Simpson would have got up and played on.

Crazy bastards back then.

Yes anyone who has not seen the 1971 GF. Do it. Your jaw will hit the ground. It was a seriously vicious afternoon. I was there as a kid. Remember it well.

[P-man 13,277]

Worst possible offense as far as the AFL is concerned. Severe, intentional and head high. They'll throw the book at him.

Except for the fact he plays for the filth. That'll shed a week or two off.

[H_T 2,941]

5 reduced to 4 early plea.

[scarlett 247]

if it were the old system where each case was judged, he would be gone for more, but with the MRS i'd say 5 possibly 6 reduced with a early plea, not sure about his previous record.

[titan_uranus 22,827]

What it should be: intentional, severe, head-high - leads to 9 activation points, the highest possible, and then the case goes to the Tribunal where hopefully he gets about 6 weeks.

What I get the feeling it will be: reckless, high, head-high. Just because the MRP is totally inconsistent and ridiculous in its findings. This would lead to 7 activation points, which is a 'level 4 offence', which means 425 points for rough conduct or charging, which means 4 weeks.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,629]

Coll. will miss Wellingham.

They' ve got a lot of hard games between now and the end of the season.

Wouldn't it be dreadful if tonight's loss to Carlton was the beginning of a big slump!

[Sammbo 19]

How times have changed... 80's early 90's that's a classic example of a well executed shirt front, now he'll go for 4weeks

Shirt front? No way. It was an ambush!

Wellingham was airborne and had eyes only for his opponent.

[rolly 149]

Type 'big afl bumps' into YouTube, find the one that's 5.27mins and see the hit at 17seconds...

Collingwood player launches through the front of, I think it is jezza...crazy deja vu

Never said I condoned it, only that it was a lot more commonplace and while not necessarily accepted it was certainly tolerated as part of the game.

*i would have embedded the vid but using an iPad

**attempt to link: youtube.com/watch?v=-BOzQwj4fSE

[Melbournepotter 278]

Sidebottom slammed McLean with a pinned/sling tackle as well, not dissimilar to Trengoves on Dangerfied. It will be interesting to see the adjudication on that.

[DirtyDees DDC 171]

Yes anyone who has not seen the 1971 GF. Do it. Your jaw will hit the ground. It was a seriously vicious afternoon. I was there as a kid. Remember it well.

If you think the 71 GF was bad, check out to replay at Moorabbin in 72. Revenge. Carnage.

[Whispering_Jack 28,095]

Wouldn't it be dreadful if tonight's loss to Carlton was the beginning of a big slump!

Sadly, a highly unlikely scenario since Pendlebury's due back next week and the Pies have great reserve strength. I would put last night down as an aberration.

Still, the way the ladder is ATM, they might fall to fifth at the end of this round if the other favourites get up. Even a minor slump in form involving any of the top six could spell doom to their top four and ultimately, their premiership chances.

I'm sure the AFL would love it if Collingwood finished 5th and Carlton 8th to set up an Elimination Final match up between those two clubs in the first week of the finals.

As for Wellingham - see ya in a month's time.

Magpie on report

[timD 994]

My hope is that wellingham gets 6-8. He'll get 2 or 3 at worst. Hell, I would not be surprised if he gets none.

[Salems Lot 2,392]

Melbourne supporters got roasted for cheering an injured Didak off at the QB. What will the papers say about the filth jeering Simpson off?

[daisycutter 28,704]

Sadly, a highly unlikely scenario since Pendlebury's due back next week and the Pies have great reserve strength. I would put last night down as an aberration.

Still, the way the ladder is ATM, they might fall to fifth at the end of this round if the other favourites get up. Even a minor slump in form involving any of the top six could spell doom to their top four and ultimately, their premiership chances.

I'm sure the AFL would love it if Collingwood finished 5th and Carlton 8th to set up an Elimination Final match up between those two clubs in the first week of the finals.

As for Wellingham - see ya in a month's time.

filth at fifth has a nice ring to it

[mrtwister 650]

Melbourne supporters got roasted for cheering an injured Didak off at the QB. What will the papers say about the filth jeering Simpson off?

The most ridiculous thing about it is that Filth supporters will be up in arms if he gets ANY games for it. They surely consider it 'part of the game.'

They have less of a clue than Carlton supporters.

[pitmaster 3,113]

No way, this type of hit was never considered a well executed shirt front. Simpson was in the air marking the ball and Wellingham made no effort to mark or hit the ball away. Gone and would have been in the 80's

Absolutely not a shirt front. As judged in the 60s and 70s this was a 'charge' (defined by the fact that Wellingham was airborne with both feet off the ground at the time of contact) and was always worthy of suspension if nabbed on it.

[binman 39,117]

Melbourne supporters got roasted for cheering an injured Didak off at the QB. What will the papers say about the filth jeering Simpson off?

Good point. Channel 7 showed a youngish collingwood supporter (about 25 i'd guess) standing and cheering (praising wellingham i think) as Simpson was practically carried from the ground. I assume that's what he was cheering but to fair i'm not 100% sure. If so it would be great to get a still of guy and make him an example of a bastard supporter - nothing makes me more angry than someone (anyone) giving it to someone who is hurt or cheering the player who hurt him

[jnrmac 19,328]

Worst possible offense as far as the AFL is concerned. Severe, intentional and head high. They'll throw the book at him.

Not true. Off the ball is deemed worse.

[Sir Why You Little 34,979]

If you think the 71 GF was bad, check out to replay at Moorabbin in 72. Revenge. Carnage.

Not suprised you say that. The 71 second Semi was even more brutal than the GF, if possible. Those teams genuinely hated each other. Then Jeansy went to Hawthorn!!!

[Left Field 313]

It was a flying elbow to the head with no eyes for the ball against a completely open traget.

Disgraceful and not anything remotely close to a classic shirtfront. Should get 6. Will get 4. Uproar over MRP consistency will rage.

[Lord Travis 10,278]

Does this lower his trade value do we can grab him cheaper? :D