Barry Prendergast gone

[Friday 71]

Quit (booted?) and joining Carlscum.

Recruiting chief quits Demons to coach

Honestly not sure how to take this...

Given the arse because he's crap or because it's time?

Why?

The behind the scenes Q that is important.

[7-UP 107]

I don't think Mark Neeld want Barry prendergast in MFC?

and Barry resign because of that.

[beelzebub 23,383]

In MFC I trust . Thanks and good luck Barry.

Obviously things go on out of view. Everything has its season and now this one has ended. So be it.

All a bit odd though ...but hey life goes on.

Remoulding continues

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

Pretty late for a change in recruiting now, seeing as though Barry may have had certain players he was gonna look out for this year but then again another one of many axings?? in the MFC. I wonder who we will pick up, any good recruiters anyone?

[Swampfox 190]

Timing could have been so much better

We could have hired a guy called Scully

Interesting decision none the less

[WhateverItTakes 17]

Would have been hard putting in all the efforts during draft knowing that you were going to leave?

A bit odd, but I agree with belzebub - in MFC I trust.

[Whispering_Jack 30,640]

Apparently, a move has been on the cards for a while.

BBBP following in the footsteps of Ron Barassi, Peter Smith, Greg Wells, Mark Riley, Brock McLean and Chris Johnson and will cover the forward scout position left vacant by Brett Munro's move to Gold Coast.

He's done a very good job at the club but it was probably time to move on. For those posters concerned at the timing, the national draft is in November and any realistic candidate would need to have a working knowledge of the draft pool available so when is it a better time to change the position?

Whatever, I doubt very much whether it's going to change our first pick in November.

[grazman 7,451]

Whatever, I doubt very much whether it's going to change our first pick in November.

I reckon you're right.... Jack Viney come on down.

[Nasher 33,617]

I don't think Mark Neeld want Barry prendergast in MFC?

and Barry resign because of that.

Or because he wants to advance his career?

There's always a million reasons these things could be, I never understand why people always look for the biggest conspiracy theories first when there's usually more simple answers.

[beelzebub 23,383]

I suppose it seems odd, But only in terms of timing. Once the Rookies were in the bag the big job of the recruiters is over for the year. It would have made some sense that Barry packed upand went then as the Caoching caousel seemed still in full rotational mode. So he goes now with a view to coaching... or whatever. It really doesnt matter. Theres still a whole swag of our recruiting in pllace , am sure another more than capable replacement will be sought and got and the world keeps turning.

No club ever keeps everyone.

Go Dees

[monoccular 17,573]

If the guy wants to move on to new challenges, good luck to him.

Good job, well done. Thank you.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,233]

No surprise here. You just had to read between the lines of his interviews during draft time to see he may not have had as much control as previously.Timing on this is probably good for both him and club. I think most of us could have achieved what he did with his top 5 picks but I think over coming years his expertise will get acknlowledged with the development of less conventional picks as Gysberts, Howe and Gawn.

All the best Barry.

[mauriesy 7,353]

Quit (booted?) and joining Carlscum.

Given the arse because he's crap or because it's time?

I don't think Mark Neeld want Barry prendergast in MFC?

and Barry resign because of that.

He's already worked at two other clubs before Melbourne. He's been at Melbourne for four years. What do you expect ... that he'll stay at Melbourne for the rest of his life?

And where is the actual info that he's been "sacked"?

[Lutz 76]

Those questioning the timing... think it might somehow be linked to the timing of the Carlton position becoming available? Just maybe?

[savoydee 6]

Or because he wants to advance his career?

There's always a million reasons these things could be, I never understand why people always look for the biggest conspiracy theories first when there's usually more simple answers.

No doubt BP was peived last draft- Neeld basically took over telling the recruiting staff what to get.BP had put in a lot of work when he deemed it was not necessary.

[Lutz 76]

That too, but I can't blame Neeld for coming in and insisting we select what he saw was needed.

His job isn't to keep BP happy.

That said, BP has been very good for us in the past.

We were able to secure some decent players late in every draft he oversaw.

[Striker475 696]

All the best BP, thanks for the brilliant rookies (Jordie!!!!!!)

[DeeSpencer 26,080]

A senior coach relies on 2 people the most - Recruiter and fitness man. I actually called this many months ago in trade week when I said our list decisions so far have reflected Neeld being very conservative with draft picks and not giving Prendergast too much to work with. That was reflected in the national draft and rookie draft. Maybe that is still reading too much into it but I think this would be a pretty mutual decision by both parties.

I'm not sure who the number 2 recruiter at Collingwood behind Hind is but I wouldn't be surprised to see him appointed pretty shortly. Oh and the timing is perfect, this is a recruiters quietest time in the year. There are no games to watch or draft camps or drafts for months. If Neeld axed him before the drafts this year then that would have been crazy.

[daisycutter 29,737]

I have this mental picture of all recruiting staff at all clubs busily downloading all their files to their home computers....lol

[Lutz 76]

A senior coach relies on 2 people the most - Recruiter and fitness man. I actually called this many months ago in trade week when I said our list decisions so far have reflected Neeld being very conservative with draft picks and not giving Prendergast too much to work with. That was reflected in the national draft and rookie draft. Maybe that is still reading too much into it but I think this would be a pretty mutual decision by both parties.

I'm not sure who the number 2 recruiter at Collingwood behind Hind is but I wouldn't be surprised to see him appointed pretty shortly. Oh and the timing is perfect, this is a recruiters quietest time in the year. There are no games to watch or draft camps or drafts for months. If Neeld axed him before the drafts this year then that would have been crazy.

Spot on.

And I thought the "Conspiracy theory" thread was stupidity / madness at the time, but you were bang on with that too.

[PaulRB 6,411]

Whatever, I doubt very much whether it's going to change our first pick in November.

If we activate our compo picks and finish in the 8, would not our first pick be the mid round compo pick that we don't have to use to acquire Jack Viney? i.e. we could get Jack with our regulation first round pick..?

[dee-luded 2,959]

Those questioning the timing... think it might somehow be linked to the timing of the Carlton position becoming available? Just maybe?

I think it's more that everyone's Christmas dinner is well & truly digested, the new year has begun and we've recalled players from summer holidays to begin the New Season.

The timing is very good for us IF there is a good time, but they say change is Inevitable, just like climbing a ladder, changing feet one @ a time.

Ed it: Oops, unless you unfortunately a Saint supporter, where they try to climb moving only one foot. They don't like to change U see. LoL.

Edited January 15, 2012 by dee-luded

[deefan12 3]

Whatever the reasons for his departure, he must go with the "thanks and job well done" tag. Agreed you don't have to be Einstein to pick great players when you have very early picks (some clubs have still stuffed this up!)but his legacy will be the astute selections later on in the draft and in particular some cracking rookie selections. As the club moves towards its 13th premiership and players such as Bail, Howe, Fitzpatrick, Jurrah, Nicholson, Tom Mcdonald, Evans, Davis, Gawn, Taggert, Tynan and Sheehan come to the fore, Barry's name will resurface and people will want to shake his hand!

[rpfc 28,769]

I made the point that Taggert and Tynan were the only players chosen by Prendergast at the last draft. The other 6 players plus Clark were recruited by the FD and Neeld.

I am not saying it is right or wrong, but I am saying that it would leave a taste in the mouth that would warrant a career rethink.

My personal opinion on how we drafted this year is that it should be done like that in the future: stop picking speculative kids at around 50 in the ND and go for proven older players at state leagues or recycled players from then on.

But this is a different argument to the news today...

I still don't believe he left because Neeld 'forced him out' but I do think that the leash he was on in November and December contributed to his departure.

[Bonkers 994]

It would be great if the club could poach Stephen Wells from the cats. He has a great track record with picks from early & late in the draft. Hes also been great at spotting great footballing talent opposed to what you might call athletic types or project players.