'Scully talks'

[Samsara 65]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/melbourne-president-jim-stynes-urges-gun-midfielder-tom-scully-to-come-clean/story-e6frf9jf-1226055848465

Still doesn't say much, apart from Stynes urging Scully to be honest with the club, to which he continues to maintain that he has not been approached.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

Says enough...i believe him. Would be very hard to look Stynesy in the eye and lie.

Happy Birthday Tom.

[beelzebub 23,352]

Would have thought that Stynes even has to broach the subject ought to raise eyebrows ?

Im not convinced of anything yet....too much dancing around words for my real liking.

[Beetle 4,652]

Not sure why he would want to stay anyway to be honest...

Why would you with the culture we produce?

I love the MFC but it's the most painful relationship I've ever been involved in..

[dee-luded 2,959]

Would have thought that Stynes even has to broach the subject ought to raise eyebrows ?

Im not convinced of anything yet....too much dancing around words for my real liking.

Alistair Lynch was down the other week, was he Not? What happened? Nothing yet?

Remember the unsettling nature of what happened last year to Geelong, with the Ablett thing, and the Bomba thing.

Not good for the players, and the team.

[Sir Why You Little 37,034]

Not sure why he would want to stay anyway to be honest...

Why would you with the culture we produce?

I love the MFC but it's the most painful relationship I've ever been involved in..

That's exactly why he needs to stay...The "Handbags" got their culture sorted, as we will.

[Arrow 1,257]

If i was Scully I'd leave. At the moment we are playing like GWS with half the payroll

[John Crow Batty 8,863]

Homework for this sick week.

Re-read the Scully statement below a 100 times. When you are finished tell us how many "ins" and how many "outs" there are to find.

http://www.velocitysports.com.au/default.asp?PageID=1585

[Redleg 40,902]

If i was Scully I'd leave.

Glad you are not him.

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

If i was Scully I'd leave. At the moment we are playing like GWS with half the payroll

On ya bike then. It's one less bunch of posts about our club heading for an apocalypse that we have to sift through. Barrack for Collingwood, they seem to be winning most weeks.

[Guest watts04]

why hasnt he signed.....he has been injured.

whats the excuse...to concentrate on his footy?

i said last year when campbell brown did his PCL that if he doesnt sign now he never will

scully has the same smell........

[Samsara 65]

I hope he isn't basing his final decision on our progress

[Guest 36DD]

Stating the bleeding obvious, but we absolutely must sign Scully. He is the type of player to sort out our culture issues.

Seems to do whatever it takes to get the best out of himself, hell he decided when he was 14 that he wasn't going to drink, these are the type of players we need at the club.

[rpfc 28,390]

Yes, this season has had its terribly disappointing moments but...

The ease with which Melbourne fans become pathetic, hand-wringers continues to astonish me.

We are not a big club, not at the moment. But you don't become a big club with the defeatist, pathetic attitude some on here show at the first sign of some gloom.

Success isn't linear and we coming from a ways back.

We will get to the summit. We might get there later rather than sooner, with different faces in different places, but we will get there.

[Salems Lot 2,529]

Yes, this season has had its terribly disappointing moments but...

The ease with which Melbourne fans become pathetic, hand-wringers continues to astonish me.

We are not a big club, not at the moment. But you don't become a big club with the defeatist, pathetic attitude some on here show at the first sign of some gloom.

Success isn't linear and we coming from a ways back.

We will get to the summit. We might get there later rather than sooner, with different faces in different places, but we will get there.

Oh hear, hear to you, it is becoming hard to read the forum at the moment for the level of depressive malaise that hangs over it. Lighten up, please.

[Salems Lot 2,529]

Clearly my request for levity was not directed at you RPFC,

[darkhorse72 1,916]

Nothing in that article, the journo obviously needed to meet a deadline for weekend money so printed a nothing article.

Jimmy is honest and from the article was simply answering a question along the line of "what did you say to scully" and jimmy obviously replied.

"just be honest" and that is Jimmy's way, no playing games. Be honest up front and then he know where he stands and know what he has to work with.

If scully told him on confidence he was thinking or leaving etc, jimmy would have accepted the answer but also start working to retain him.

Since that hasn't happened I believe scully has not a decision to leave and simply doing what he said he was going to do at the start of the season.

[Samsara 65]

Yes, this season has had its terribly disappointing moments but...

The ease with which Melbourne fans become pathetic, hand-wringers continues to astonish me.

We are not a big club, not at the moment. But you don't become a big club with the defeatist, pathetic attitude some on here show at the first sign of some gloom.

Success isn't linear and we coming from a ways back.

We will get to the summit. We might get there later rather than sooner, with different faces in different places, but we will get there.

Here's hoping. I am certain the biggest problem this season is that expectations were set too high. 2012 is starting to look more like the season where we will see the start of some big improvements.

[Roost It 1,434]

Scully's re-signing is the club's most important issue. Without him we're in strife.

[Demonic Ascent 0]

Here's hoping. I am certain the biggest problem this season is that expectations were set too high. 2012 is starting to look more like the season where we will see the start of some big improvements.

And then next year more excuses will be rolled out and it will be "oh we were getting ahead of ourselves, it's 2013 we should be focussing on." Where does it end with this club?

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

Yes, this season has had its terribly disappointing moments but...

The ease with which Melbourne fans become pathetic, hand-wringers continues to astonish me.

We are not a big club, not at the moment. But you don't become a big club with the defeatist, pathetic attitude some on here show at the first sign of some gloom.

Success isn't linear and we coming from a ways back.

We will get to the summit. We might get there later rather than sooner, with different faces in different places, but we will get there.

Well said.

[reynolds46 1,237]

Not sure why he would want to stay anyway to be honest...

Why would you with the culture we produce?

I love the MFC but it's the most painful relationship I've ever been involved in..

if culture is his driving motivation going to GWS should be his last choice. Unlikely to have any sort of culture to speak of for the duartion of Scullys career

[Demonic Ascent 0]

if culture is his driving motivation going to GWS should be his last choice. Unlikely to have any sort of culture to speak of for the duartion of Scullys career

Everyone's worried about GWS but what if other clubs have been in his (or his managers) ear? What if Richmond or Collingwood for example have made queries? It's not unthinkable and you would think he would seriously consider an offer from either of these clubs.

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

Here's hoping. I am certain the biggest problem this season is that expectations were set too high. 2012 is starting to look more like the season where we will see the start of some big improvements.

Yep, lets set our sights somewhere near the bottom or below average every year. That way at least we'll never disappoint ourselves and usually end up somewhere thereabouts. Also pick up more and more early draft picks once they come back on line so we can rebuild on our earlier years of rebuilding

Edited May 15, 2011 by Rusty Nails

[Samsara 65]

Yep, lets set our sights somewhere near the bottom or below average every year. That way at least we'll never disappoint ourselves and usually end up somewhere thereabouts. Also pick up more and more early draft picks once they come back on line so we can rebuild on our earlier years of rebuilding

I was referring to expectations of top 4 material and 'the next superpower'. Everybody has different expectations of course, but some were ridiculous. I for one - considering the draw - would have expected about 10 wins at least. We have 3.5 so far, so certainly not out of the question. We have played poorly in our losses though, so I agree that we shouldn't be looking for excuses. Bailey will no doubt be booted as the coach is always the first to cop the fallout.