Jurrah Hurt!

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,234]

And everyone on this forum berated me for suggesting me an error in not selecting Bradshaw.

Well the only egg in our basket has just broken..

Get well LJ!

Is that Bradshaw who has played not played a game for his new club and is out for at least another month?

[The Chazz 4,077]

Is that Bradshaw who has played not played a game for his new club and is out for at least another month?

I agree that we should have gone for Bradshaw. Give him 2 years to be our main target - let's face it, he WILL get through 2 years. Gives Watts, Jurrah, etc to get a bit older/stronger/smarter, but still gives us a forward target.

Yeah sure, he went to the club that he nominated, but we chased Ball to some extent didn't we?

Isn't Bradshaw meant to be right for Round 1?

[Je Roos Salem 661]

No LJ for 2010, get over it. Morton is a bigger loss - not taking anything away from LJ.

I just hope everyone, including Bailey, believe me when I say he is NOT our key forward.

Were you sleeping through Jurrah's nine games last year? This guy is a freak, explosive pace, freakish goal kicking ability, don't just compare him to other aboriginal players. Jurrah is an icon of the club, he sells memberships, he is a big loss

[The Chazz 4,077]

Were you sleeping through Jurrah's nine games last year? This guy is a freak, explosive pace, freakish goal kicking ability, don't just compare him to other aboriginal players. Jurrah is an icon of the club, he sells memberships, he is a big loss

Not at all was I sleeping. I was standing prouder as the next Melbourne supporter. Since the end of 2009, I have been a realist in regards to LJ. Look at Aussie, he was an icon of our Club at the end of 2008 - how much did we cheer for him in 2009?

I have had too much disappointment in my life (as a Demon supporter) to hang my entire season on 1 player, and thank god I didn't get sucked in again.

[Kiss of Death 755]

I'd rather his shoulder is rock solid going forwards, so even if he's lost 60% of this year, he'll be able to consolidate towards the end of the year confidently and go forwards.

There's some guy who had a fair bit of work done on his shoulders a few years back, didn't get selected at #1 possibly as a result, who now collects his pay via brown recyclable paper bags, he goes alright these days.

Some guy who took Travis Johnstone's number's first season was pretty much a write off - he goes okay these days.

Some other kid who liked hanging out with Colling@#!#$^ players in bars who had a real suspect groin and wasn't able to complete a pre-season for more than a couple of years, he went alright last year i thought. Deserved all 3 of those votes against Hawthorn last year, and can't wait to see him kick off again this year.

Most importantly all 3 they'll be fit and firing when we're pressing for finals in the next few years.

I'm sure Liam and Cale will both be busy in the gyms and beefing up, itching to get back out on the park. Liam's already many opposition supporter's favourite Melbourne player, and many of our own regard him that way too. He burst onto the scene so brightly in a handful of games last year, after we all stood at Etihad watching him soar. Gods, the feeling in the dome at that moment... the roar... every supporter on their feet, Essendon and Melbourne alike.

He's shown a whole lot of promise, and he has a career ahead of him to live up to that taste we got last year. Very disappointing turn of events on the weekend, but we're not heading into a finals series with Liam kicking bags of 6-8 on a regular basis. Get right soon Liam, we'll all be waiting.

Cheers.

[The Red Fox 216]

Alright team, no more arguing with Billy or we lock the thread.

As for Liam. 16 weeks sees him playing footy again in Round 13... just in time for our finals charge.

And we get one more look at 'Juice' before his contract expires as seasons end.

It's a terrible break for a valuable player (as is the Morton injury), but better now then 2011 or beyond.

[Deeoldfart 8,065]

Extremely disappointing for LJ, the Melbourne Footy Club and all of us Members and supporters .... but as his mate RudeBoy said in another thread, LJ will be back "stronger and hungrier than ever". And when it really counts, from 2011 onwards, he will be just one cog in a forward set-up that will be the envy of most if not all teams.

[Batemania 4]

Anyway, Jurrah's injury broke my heart as I was waiting for Wana, Watts and Jurrah working off each other in the forward line. I guess we just have to wait a little longer!! Let's just hope it occurs later this year.

[DemonDan... 77]

Still think we've lost our best forward in LJ and we're stuffed for it..

Bradshaw definately wasnt the answer.. would just have kept robbo if that was the road they wanted to take.

Guess we have to continue the wait for Watts to get up to speed and Martin to find forward line form.

[Hellaintabadplacetobe 4,294]

Alright team, no more arguing with Billy or we lock the thread.

As for Liam. 16 weeks sees him playing footy again in Round 13... just in time for our finals charge.

And we get one more look at 'Juice' before his contract expires as seasons end.

It's a terrible break for a valuable player (as is the Morton injury), but better now then 2011 or beyond.

I think it`s been said he won`t be back until round 16, not 16 weeks! It would barely be worth risking him playing this year you`d think. I`m gutted for him, and I think it`s a big loss for the club membership drive and gate receipts because that`s what blokes like this do for a club. Only positive is that someone else gets a chance to step up and prove themselves. I wonder if this will be a `lightbulb` moment for Juice?? Surely not.

[Redleg 41,469]

Better this year than next

You have summed up my only positive out of this.

[Bay Riffin 1,480]

It is disappointing as he was probably the most watchable player of late, but the real factor for me is the amount of injuries.

Late last year, despite all the tanking talk we had 20 plus injuries and when young blokes like Blease and Strauss were ready to take advantage of opportunities they went down as well. Surprisingly we didn't seem to drop off and stayed competitive with half the list down, albeit in some lower intensity games towards the end.

I still think we will have depth in the qaulity of youngsters across the board, most of who will get a chance, as long as we can stop long term injuries happening to say 10 plus players.

For instance we hear Garland is back next week for his first game, Wonna and Bate are back to playing again, with Watts a week or two away (like a mirage isn't it). In reality they are some quality youngsters to come back. My hope is they can play 15-20 games.

In reality I am disappointed but I would need a few more than just Jurrah to go down to take away the enthusiasm for 2010. love Jurrah but we shouldn't be relying on 1 pre-season draft pick for success. We usually do well with rookie and pre-season picks, but time has come to develop the high graft picks and create some A-graders, and 1 or 2 elite players.

As for the forward line, I believe if we can get as many forward 50 entries as our opponents get this year, our forward line can convert and win games.

[Sir Why You Little 37,134]

Still think we've lost our best forward in LJ and we're stuffed for it..

Bradshaw definately wasnt the answer.. would just have kept robbo if that was the road they wanted to take.

Guess we have to continue the wait for Watts to get up to speed and Martin to find forward line form.

i really hope Ricky Petterd stands up out of all this-along with Matty Bate we can still kick goals.

Watts is far from ready-he still has growing pains.

[rusty_kingswood 0]

Its gut wrenching, theres no doubt about it at all.

Hasn't our mate Juicy just been thrown the biggest lifeline of his career however.......

[TopCorner 103]

Long-term rehab can't be much fun, especially for a bloke who's a long way from home. Do players always do rehab at the club, or do they ever head home for a while?

[The Red Fox 216]

I think it`s been said he won`t be back until round 16, not 16 weeks! It would barely be worth risking him playing this year you`d think.

Help me here, why wouldn't you play him for the last several rounds, even if we were out of finals contention? He only played 9 games at the tail of last year and it was hugely beneficial for both club and player.

[w00dy 146]

Its gut wrenching, theres no doubt about it at all.

Hasn't our mate Juicy just been thrown the biggest lifeline of his career however.......

Will the real Michael Newton please stand up?

Juice is the obvious choice to come off the rookie list... I want to see the club give him the first 6 matches, let him settle in the side and see if he can offer us something... I'm backing with the confidence of the coaching staff behind him that he will... If he offers nothing, well then he's been given every opportunity... But I can't help but feel that he hasn't been given the opportunities he has deserved thus far, and the one positive I'm taking out of this injury is that we might find something in a player we were ready to discard...

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Help me here, why wouldn't you play him for the last several rounds, even if we were out of finals contention? He only played 9 games at the tail of last year and it was hugely beneficial for both club and player.

Common sense here.

Will the real Michael Newton please stand up?

Juice is the obvious choice to come off the rookie list... I want to see the club give him the first 6 matches, let him settle in the side and see if he can offer us something... I'm backing with the confidence of the coaching staff behind him that he will... If he offers nothing, well then he's been given every opportunity... But I can't help but feel that he hasn't been given the opportunities he has deserved thus far, and the one positive I'm taking out of this injury is that we might find something in a player we were ready to discard...

Any chance that Newton actually earn a spot in the team. He is now in his 6th year and has been given more opportunities than his performances deserve. The ball is in his court to justify his spot on the list. In fact its been that way for the past 3 years. Newton just has not worked that out. Even more surprising given we are crying out for a capable forward. I struggle to see what has held him back beyond....Michael Newton.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Any chance that Newton actually earn a spot in the team. He is now in his 6th year and has been given more opportunities than his performances deserve. The ball is in his court to justify his spot on the list. In fact its been that way for the past 3 years. Newton just has not worked that out. Even more surprising given we are crying out for a capable forward. I struggle to see what has held him back beyond....Michael Newton.

Sums it up. Newton is the only guy in the way of Newton. If he doesn't take this opportunity, there will be exactly zero people on his side.

What would be MORE interesting is if he pops up and kicks 30+ this year. What then?!!!

[Inner Demon 1]

Common sense here.

Any chance that Newton actually earn a spot in the team. He is now in his 6th year and has been given more opportunities than his performances deserve. The ball is in his court to justify his spot on the list. In fact its been that way for the past 3 years. Newton just has not worked that out. Even more surprising given we are crying out for a capable forward. I struggle to see what has held him back beyond....Michael Newton.

If this presents an extra opportunity for anyone, I'd pick Jack Fitzpatrick over Michael Newton.

[H_T 3,049]

If this presents an extra opportunity for anyone, I'd pick Jack Fitzpatrick over Michael Newton.

I'm of the same view.

[Roost It 1,434]

Its gut wrenching, theres no doubt about it at all.

Hasn't our mate Juicy just been thrown the biggest lifeline of his career however.......

I'm in the Jack Fitzpatrick camp as well. When oh when are you all going to realise that Newton isn't upto it. 6 years on the list is enough of an opportunity. I say leave him on the rookie list until he proves himself at casey. He has to be made to earn his spot back on the list. I'm betting he won't.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

God I hate Adelaide.

[Diablo Deemon 220]

Plenty of passion on the boards which is good to see. Couple of things I'll clear up.

First: My passion for this club runs deep my support unwavering my commitment absolute for over 30 years.

Secondly: Majority of this site claimed MFC would only win 6-8 wins hardly a successful year

Thirdly: If Jurrah was going to be the absolute difference this year your deluded. He's gifted,

talented could quite possibly rival Buddy in 3 years but even Buddy can't win a game when he is the only

one playing. He misses 16 weeks of development on field but if he's hungry and comitted enough he'll

develop himself in other areas. For example endurance, strength, bulk.

Fourthly: Injuries suck BUT I absolutely refuse to run around like a chook

with it's head cut off spreading doom and gloom when I've been through this kind of thing before(Schwarz).

We as supporters as a side as the red and blue will be stronger for the bad times and when the good times

come they'll be so much sweeter.

Absolute unwavering support it's not a choice.

[rusty_kingswood 0]

I'm in the Jack Fitzpatrick camp as well. When oh when are you all going to realise that Newton isn't upto it. 6 years on the list is enough of an opportunity. I say leave him on the rookie list until he proves himself at casey. He has to be made to earn his spot back on the list. I'm betting he won't.

I dont think anyone is on the Newton band wagon are they?

Fitzpatrick isn't exactly game day ready.