Watching Goodys press conference, Viney is still 2 weeks off, appears he has had a small setback. Might not play till after the bye is my gut feel. 

I'd like to know when Viney's 2 weeks actually starts. It was originally 2 weeks duration when it happened 3 weeks ago and hasn't shifted since.

I also reckon these Injury Reports should be taken with a grain of salt. Jacko's broken finger wasn't reported in the R9 Injury Report at all - even though it was evident prior from both post R8 game images vs Swans as well as it was also being reported on DL that he'd miss. 

 

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Jackson ready to come back in this week ahead of schedule.

Viney also available for selection.

Scans have cleared Jake Bowey of any serious injury and he is available this week too.

I'm confused. 

Viney available for selection.

In two weeks?

I"m not sure we can fully trust those graphics. Glad to hear Bowey escaped serious injury and will play this week. Also pleasing to hear Laurie will get back into training, presumably non-contact, and will be fit for VFL in the second half of the season. 

5 minutes ago, binman said:

I'm confused. 

Viney available for selection.

In two weeks?

hmmm......does 2 weeks mean until the dogs game?

40 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

hmmm......does 2 weeks mean until the dogs game?

Goody has said he is doubtful for the Dogs game 

Injury List: Round 10

Jake Bowey (ankle) — Available 

Luke Jackson (finger) — Available 

Nathan Jones (hamstring) — Available 

Aaron vandenBerg (quad) — 2 Weeks

Jack Viney (toe) — 2 Weeks

Joel Smith (knee) — 5 Weeks

Bailey Laurie (eye socket) — 5 Weeks

Marty Hore (knee) — 10 to 12 Weeks

Aaron Nietschke (knee) — Season

Adam Tomlinson (knee) — Season

Jake Bowey has made a miraculous recovery 

Edited May 19, 20214 yr by chook fowler

3 hours ago, SPC said:

Watching Goodys press conference, Viney is still 2 weeks off, appears he has had a small setback. Might not play till after the bye is my gut feel. 

****. I wonder whether that was an increase in load to try to get him right for this week. 

58 minutes ago, Pates said:

****. I wonder whether that was an increase in load to try to get him right for this week. 

Yep. Thank god it flared up at training and not during a game. 
Seriously his feet are never not going to be a problem. That he can’t get thru training is a major worry. 

2 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Jake Bowey has made a miraculous recovery 

There is a picture of him kicking at training. Looks fit. 
 

https://m.facebook.com/pg/MELBOURNEfc/photos/?ref=page_internal&mt_nav=0#!/MELBOURNEfc/photos/a.10151939167012317/10159230472302317/?type=3&source=54&ref=page_internal

3 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Jake Bowey has made a miraculous recovery 

Maybe not. Maybe it was just a minor injury in the first place.

man the injury report is a dogs breakfast. I thought Hore was out for the season. he’s now down at 10-12. i get that’s close to seasons end but that difference may be important if we get injuries close to finals. 

What is it?

Anyone know anything, including likely return this week?

Groin.

The club love keeping their supporters in the dark regarding injuries. 

1 minute ago, JimmyGadson said:

The club love keeping their supporters in the dark regarding injuries. 

Dare I say that the club isn’t keeping the supporters in the dark.

Instead they aren’t letting every opposition club know what’s wrong with one of our most important players, and therefore how to target him.

How do oppositions target 'a groin'?

And back to the subject, why was Goodwin so notably unforthcoming, when asked about the injury in his post-game?

2 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Groin.

 

1 hour ago, JimmyGadson said:

The club love keeping their supporters in the dark regarding injuries. 

1 hour ago, The heart beats true said:

Dare I say that the club isn’t keeping the supporters in the dark.

Instead they aren’t letting every opposition club know what’s wrong with one of our most important players, and therefore how to target him.

It's interesting...the rumour/inside gos has been it's a groin.

...but if true there would seem little advantage in keeping it secret, it would be doubtful that he would play & no one to target.

Although it may keep the dogs guessing & having to plan even though he mightn't play. So may make sense.

However if it were a shoulder problem, or maybe a facial injury I could understand not telegraphing that to opponents.

Let's just hope he plays...

 

Edited May 24, 20214 yr by rjay

7 hours ago, The heart beats true said:

Dare I say that the club isn’t keeping the supporters in the dark.

Instead they aren’t letting every opposition club know what’s wrong with one of our most important players, and therefore how to target him.

Target a groin? 

Rightio. 

Cripps has been playing with a sore back which every club has known about since round 1. Haven't seen anyone target his back. 

Jack Viney's foot? 

Not sure your view adds up. 

Maybe it’s a slight strain and the club are not sure if he’ll get up so can’t say confidently either way until Wednesday training. 
 

i believe he is sore between the big toes.

Sometimes imo these things are used to cover up something they'd prefer not to go public, for example a personal situation, breakup in a relationship for example. it's a good way to keep the media from digging into it and buy the player a bit of space. 

Not saying that's the case with Christian but potentially it could be given the situation.

10 hours ago, JimmyGadson said:

The club love keeping their supporters in the dark regarding injuries. 

Seriously, what do you care?

There may be 100 reasons why they don't want others to know about a players injury.

Let them do their job.

Club had a light run yesterday and were doing ball skills etc.

Salem was restricted to jogging laps it seems.