Take a look at what Collingwood has, big advantage

 

12 minutes ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Take a look at what Collingwood has, big advantage

 

2 Premierships in 65 years ( 30 plus years in the tougher AFL ) and 13 at ViC Park in the VFL would not suggest the advantage you assert David. 

And their Runners Up record of about twice the flags also might lull them into a false sense of luxury or the fact that they have a habit of being SECOND BEST and perform above their ability. 

7 hours ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Take a look at what Collingwood has, big advantage

 

I feel a little dirty after watching some of that.  I'm off for a full hose down and disinfect

8 hours ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Take a look at what Collingwood has, big advantage

Seemingly, it doesn’t help them in the first 3 quarters.

13 hours ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Take a look at what Collingwood has, big advantage

 

and now check out what Sydney have just moved into

https://www.sydneyswans.com.au/video/1276518/sydney-swans-hq-fly-through?videoId=1276518&modal=true&type=video&publishFrom=1677562086001

12 hours ago, 58er said:

2 Premierships in 65 years ( 30 plus years in the tougher AFL ) and 13 at ViC Park in the VFL would not suggest the advantage you assert David. 

And their Runners Up record of about twice the flags also might lull them into a false sense of luxury or the fact that they have a habit of being SECOND BEST and perform above their ability. 

Correct - Facility link to high performance is a myth. 

Brisbane Lions won the threepeat out of dilapidated facilities in Brisbane. Waverley Park was hardly elite in Hawthorns threepeat era. The Melbourne Storm have won several rugby league titles out of AAMI Park, as have Melbourne Victory.  

15 minutes ago, Dannyz said:

Correct - Facility link to high performance is a myth. 

Brisbane Lions won the threepeat out of dilapidated facilities in Brisbane. Waverley Park was hardly elite in Hawthorns threepeat era. The Melbourne Storm have won several rugby league titles out of AAMI Park, as have Melbourne Victory.  

Then let's move back to what we had at Junction Oval!

I cannot understand those who are satisfied with a public oval for training, a gym shared with multiple other sporting clubs, shared rehab rooms, no lap pool, pokey admin offices a km away, and the list goes on and on...

Whilst we have Casey facilities available that are quite good, we should also have a committed home base like every other AFL club

I'm amazed with our recent success given the hotch-potch facilities we have. I reckon better facilities helps players get better and contributes towards a culture of elite performance

 

13 hours ago, 58er said:

2 Premierships in 65 years

Haven't been at this Olympic Park venue for that long...

Training ground?  What is this thing you speak of!

Max has a pretty positive take on the facilities...

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1322374/podcast-garry-lyon-and-max-gawn

3 hours ago, Timothy Reddan-A'Blew said:

Max has a pretty positive take on the facilities...

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1322374/podcast-garry-lyon-and-max-gawn

Aside from his kicking for goal, we are in great hands with our Captain.

Personally I still don’t understand why we can’t be incorporated into the Southern Stand upgrade. It would surely all fit and we can stay at goschs…..otherwise I’m all in for Caulfield 

18 hours ago, 58er said:

2 Premierships in 65 years ( 30 plus years in the tougher AFL ) and 13 at ViC Park in the VFL would not suggest the advantage you assert David. 

And their Runners Up record of about twice the flags also might lull them into a false sense of luxury or the fact that they have a habit of being SECOND BEST and perform above their ability. 

Sorry I hate the filth. Growing up with my mates at the MCG (or is it The G ?) watching Peter McKenna & the Richardson bros tear us apart. 

God I hate them.

It'll be great to see them as runners up again as they will be this year.

Go Dees

 

36 minutes ago, Roost it far said:

Personally I still don’t understand why we can’t be incorporated into the Southern Stand upgrade. It would surely all fit and we can stay at goschs…..otherwise I’m all in for Caulfield 

Because that’s just too logical for the AFL

31 minutes ago, Hardley Benial said:

Sorry I hate the filth. Growing up with my mates at the MCG (or is it The G ?) watching Peter McKenna & the Richardson bros tear us apart. 

God I hate them.

It'll be great to see them as runners up again as they will be this year.

Go Dees

 

Me too Hardley. They were always on TV, along with Carlton and Richmond, while other clubs playing better were given slow motion replays on World of Sport. They were given their high membership numbers by channel 7 pushing them onto us, which continues to this day. 

I would love to see us beat them on GF day.

But the fact that they swooped on the Olympic pool and running track site, after the MFC passed it up, makes me furious and hate them even more.

 

Can we just do two things

 

1:  get Caulfield tucked away

2: Remind all others the G is OUR Home.. Ours.. all others are transient.  ( by winning )

Ffs..its not that hard a concept....is it .....

36 minutes ago, Demon Disciple said:

Because that’s just too logical for the AFL

I don't think it's the AFL's decision.  They don't control the MCG.

18 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Can we just do two things

 

1:  get Caulfield tucked away

2: Remind all others the G is OUR Home.. Ours.. all others are transient.  ( by winning )

Ffs..its not that hard a concept....is it .....

In the next decade or so, we might have a lean year (like Richmond is having now). I don't want us to be shunted to Marvel in the unlikely event that we aren't winning. The G is our home this year, next, and forever.

The plan for Caulfield racecourse has been released. 

Nothing about MFC, though they indicate there is scope for sporting and cultural developments. 

https://concreteplayground.com/melbourne/travel-leisure/caulfield-racecourse-reserve-looks-set-to-be-revitalised-as-a-public-park-and-recreation-space

23 minutes ago, kev martin said:

The plan for Caulfield racecourse has been released. 

Nothing about MFC, though they indicate there is scope for sporting and cultural developments. 

https://concreteplayground.com/melbourne/travel-leisure/caulfield-racecourse-reserve-looks-set-to-be-revitalised-as-a-public-park-and-recreation-space

given we are on a 10 year austerity budget now, i don't see any state gov money materialising in the near/mid term

we are stuffed i'd say, with respect to a new all in one home

current scenario to continue with only minor improvements

37 minutes ago, kev martin said:

The plan for Caulfield racecourse has been released. 

Nothing about MFC, though they indicate there is scope for sporting and cultural developments. 

https://concreteplayground.com/melbourne/travel-leisure/caulfield-racecourse-reserve-looks-set-to-be-revitalised-as-a-public-park-and-recreation-space

Another boat sailed i suspect.

44 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

given we are on a 10 year austerity budget now, i don't see any state gov money materialising in the near/mid term

What if we provide facilities for drag queen story time events as part of the masterplan? Or headquarters for a certain someone's union mates?

41 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

given we are on a 10 year austerity budget now, i don't see any state gov money materialising in the near/mid term

One problem is that all the apartment development profit goes to Racing Victoria.

We'll need a first class community benefit story to get State/Federal money. Most of those have already been played by the other clubs but there may be one or two left

1 hour ago, kev martin said:

The plan for Caulfield racecourse has been released. 

Nothing about MFC, though they indicate there is scope for sporting and cultural developments. 

https://concreteplayground.com/melbourne/travel-leisure/caulfield-racecourse-reserve-looks-set-to-be-revitalised-as-a-public-park-and-recreation-space

I think this relates to land inside the track? There is both MRC owned land and public land (including an existing Council oval) outside the track on the Western and Southern areas of the complex. I think the western boundary is MRC freehold land that is largely intended for apartment developments but there is still plenty of scope for an MFC facility at the southern (Glen Huntly) end if space on the land inside the track is not feasible due to being used for other purposes. Also they are talking about a 15 year timeframe to develop so current budgetary pressures may not be as much of an issue down the track.

 

Edited May 25, 20231 yr by No. 31
typos

On 5/5/2023 at 6:58 PM, Maldonboy38 said:

Me too Hardley. They were always on TV, along with Carlton and Richmond, while other clubs playing better were given slow motion replays on World of Sport. They were given their high membership numbers by channel 7 pushing them onto us, which continues to this day. 

I would love to see us beat them on GF day.

But the fact that they swooped on the Olympic pool and running track site, after the MFC passed it up, makes me furious and hate them even more.

 

You hate dare,vision and intelligence then?

MFC is responsible for what they have created and the supporters and management they have attracted...and you hate others who have done nothing but succeed where MFC have failed 

Geez.

Now Richmond..  who moved into our ground and the State Govt and VFL who allowed it...they are worthy of disdain .