Changes vs Gold Coast

[McQueen 17,867]

Out: ANB

In: Salem

Seriously, If ANB holds his spot I’ll be amazed. What a turnover merchant and just made some terrible decisions today.

If Viney is right then I’d look at Harmes but he wasn’t too bad today so it’ll be tough.

Edited May 6, 2018 by McQueen

[M_9 2,123]

Harmes will hold his spot.

[What 18,810]

In - Viney, Salem

Out - ANB,  Vince (rest )

Bernie played well but he has played 3 games in 11 days, hes 32 and its a long season. We need  players fresh for the back half of the season when things really heat up.

[Return to Glory 8,453]

I know he's taken on the whipping boy role (after Watts left) but amongst his stuff ups there were some signs that a turn around in form wasn't a million miles away. Rose coloured glasses my friends, you've gotta get a pair.

[Pennant St Dee 13,389]

No to JV for mine let him get touch and game fitness in the VFL. 1 week or 2 and bring him back in firing on all cylinders 

[chook fowler 19,694]

In: Viney and Salem

Out: ANB and Hunt

[jackaub 1,402]

17 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

In: Viney and Salem

Out: ANB and Hunt

YEP!

[Wiseblood 24,637]

19 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

In: Viney and Salem

Out: ANB and Hunt

This might end up being it, chook.  Viney coming in is 50/50 for me as they may make him wait another week to be sure. 

[Jibroni 5,035]

Agree Jack has not played for a long while and coming back through the VFL wont hurt him.

ANB for anyone is fine.

Edited May 6, 2018 by Jibroni

[brendan 3,444]

Toughest selection week coming up for the year if viney is right to go, might see someone like Spargo making way not that he deserves to be dropped but he is a young fella will get his chance, I’m also wondering how Garlett finds his way back in 

[McQueen 17,867]

34 minutes ago, Pennant St Dee said:

No to JV for mine let him get touch and game fitness in the VFL. 1 week or 2 and bring him back in firing on all cylinders 

Listening to Goodwin talk about the high performance staff “getting players AFL ready” makes me think that he’ll cone straight in and impact the game.

The last thing we want is some VFL clown looking for 15 minutes of fame by ironing Jack out and possibly further delaying his return.

[monoccular 17,642]

15 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

Agree Jack has not played for a long while and coming back through the VFL wont hurt him.

ANB for anyone is fine.

ANB out should be a certainty: for Salem or Viney.  

Anyone else would be stiff but if both are fit but it is a nice problem for the selectors.  

A concern is that the last time (I recall) that JV played VFL some thug from Geelong broke his jaw (and got an effective one week penalty for it). 

Edited May 6, 2018 by monoccular

[bing181 9,421]

Agree on Viney straight in. Even going at 70% he'd earn his spot. Whether next week is the one, only the fitness staff would know.

The other in for me is Garlett. He did OK at Casey, and we miss his crumbing capabilities and instinct for the goals - as long as he brings them of course. 

[Demons11 7,096]

22 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

Agree Jack has not played for a long while and coming back through the VFL wont hurt him.

ANB for anyone is fine.

No point wasting Viney at VFL level. 

 

[Demons11 7,096]

44 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

In: Viney and Salem

Out: ANB and Hunt

Hunt has to stay in.  His pace is desperately needed.  I know he needs to improve his disposal but he stays in for mine. 

I don’t think Salem will be ready this week.  Viney for ANB. 

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

In Salem

Out ANB

Give Viney 3/4 at Casey, love the guy, but reckon he needs a practise run after being out so long

[chook fowler 19,694]

9 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

Hunt has to stay in.  His pace is desperately needed.  I know he needs to improve his disposal but he stays in for mine. 

I don’t think Salem will be ready this week.  Viney for ANB. 

He doesn’t get enough of it, runs into trouble and turns it over. 

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,285]

Amazed that no one has Weid out. Was serviceable and is coming along nicely but unless we are completely wedded to the three tall forwards then it's Weid and ANB (or possibly Hunt but I don't think so) for Viney and Salem. Fritsch and Harmes will just play more forward time with Viney in the guts and Salem back. 

Edited May 6, 2018 by big_red_fire_engine

[DeeSpencer 26,272]

Viney in. But leave the midfield as is and just let him run around half forward and pressure and compete. Put him in ANB's spot. Maybe some swapping on ball with Harmes if needed.

I doubt Salem will overcome a thumb in 1 week. If he does then it's a matter of whether Vince or Lewis need a rest, if they drop Tyson or probably I'd go Lewis back to the wing, Fritsch to half forward and go smaller up forward to get more pressure, in which case Weeds is unlucky and misses out. With Hannan, Fritsch, Petracca and Melksham all strong overhead I don't think we need 3 tall forwards, we're only playing the 3 because we lack the midfield/half back options as is.

Regardless of Salem's health it's probably a week to consider if we need to get a 2nd genuine tall defender a run because there's other teams coming up that have 3 big guys

[Diamond_Jim 12,687]

1 minute ago, Rod Grinter Riot Squad said:

In Salem

Out ANB

Give Viney 3/4 at Casey, love the guy, but reckon he needs a practise run after being out so long

Agree and listening to Viney being interviewed pre game it's a real possibility.

Add his length out of the game with the fact that it is a road trip to play in what I thought would be warm conditions  but I see the forecast is only for 22 ... my head says return for the Carlton game.

With next week being a road game and a short turn around there may be an argument to rest someone and return Garlett. Wagner might also bob up...

Interesting but good problems for the selection committee this week

 

[DaveyJones'sLocker 647]

If nick nat can play less than 70% game time almost every week why can’t we take Viney in and do the same ?

[bush demon 2,162]

55 minutes ago, Jibroni said:

Agree Jack has not played for a long while and coming back through the VFL wont hurt him.

ANB for anyone is fine.

It did the day Wodjinski (sp) wacked him.

[whatwhat say what 23,424]

 ANB is the logical out for Viney

It all comes down to whether or not Salem can return from a broken thumb after only missing one game - if he can, they may drop Hunt, give Vince a rest, or see Spargo or Hannan come out

No way does Weid go out for mine

[Duh 109]

ANB out for Viney. Wouldnt be against Viney playing as a small forward next week - ease his way into it as almost a pressure forward.

Salem for Hannan. Tough call

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,615]

In. Salem. Out. Anb