My 3 word player analysis V StKilda

[stuie 7,374]

25 minutes ago, joeboy said:

Jones - always the warrior

Hogan - our only winner

Gawn - failed to dominate

Viney - never left wondering

Vince - was rarely sighted

Kennedy - looked painfully slow

Bugg - selection defies logic

Petracca - some sublime touches

Tyson - consistently wrong options

Watts - continued impressive form

McDonald - disappears when beaten

Wagner - played amateur football

Lumumba - was embarrassingly bad

Dunn - inhibited by fatness

Harmes - a poor game

Garlett - couldn't find ball

Salem - poor before injury

Kent - probably wasn't playing

Frost - not of standard

Pedersen - see Dunn above

Hunt - out of depth

Jetta - slow and loose

Usually agree with most of yours joe, but there's a bunch that seem way off today, did you go to the game?

 

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

28 minutes ago, joeboy said:

Bugg - selection defies logic

21 disposals at 86% Efficiency...

Selection justified if you ask me...

Tried his guts out all day and if he gets dropped after that I would be pi55ed

[Demon Disciple 12,453]

18 minutes ago, Roger Mellie said:

Harmes - looked for frees

This is a major component of his game that needs to be stamped out very quickly, he does like to sook doesn't he!

Maybe if his performance warranted paying attention to, then he might have got some (back to Casey for him).

 

As for Tom McDonald - Showed true self.

He is massively overrated - on here, by the footy department and by himself. A brainless one-legged man would be a better kick and decision maker than him. We desperately need to find a quality KPD if our backline is to improve. Try and entice Hurley across to be the linchpin of our defence. McDonald would be a much improved player as 2nd/3rd KPD.

[Demon Disciple 12,453]

15 minutes ago, picket fence said:

OLIVER   POOR NON SELECTION 

I'm sorry fence, but i doubt a 4 game, first-year player would've made any difference.

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

Etihad - F***ing Stupid Stadium

[Maple Demon 449]

The team as a whole - Be more consistent

[#11-TonyAnderson 860]

Most ... weak as

[SaberFang 7,151]

If I owned a demolition business I would demolish that [censored] shithole of a stadium tonight.

[Maldonboy38 6,406]

Midfield - learn defensive spread.

Defensive coach Rawlings - poor defensive instructions

Half back line - annihilated by pace.

Harmes - an absolute shocker

Hunt - fumbly and weak

Wagner - flaws on display

Lamumba - just so poor

 

[DemonLad5 1,642]

any chance Daisy Pearce plays next week?

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Coaches - given football lesson

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

Joeboy - prefer your lists

 

3Dee - nice try but ...

3Dee - ... it's joeboy's turf

[BAMF 4,450]

2 hours ago, Roger Mellie said:

Harmes - looked for frees

Frost - yuck x 3

Dunn - Agree with above

TMac - Timid, tired play

Gawn - met his match

MFC - ahead of themselves 

God that was a bad look. Most of the time he was fairly bumped off the ball too.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

6 minutes ago, Night Crawler said:

God that was a bad look. Most of the time he was fairly bumped off the ball too.

It wasn't as bad as when McDonald got bumped in the third quarter near the boundary line.

[Demonetta13 95]

Harmes - needs a spray

[Buzzy 992]

4 hours ago, joeboy said:

Jones - always the warrior

Hogan - our only winner

Gawn - failed to dominate

Viney - never left wondering

Vince - was rarely sighted

Kennedy - looked painfully slow

Bugg - selection defies logic

Petracca - some sublime touches

Tyson - consistently wrong options

Watts - continued impressive form

McDonald - disappears when beaten

Wagner - played amateur football

Lumumba - was embarrassingly bad

Dunn - inhibited by fatness

Harmes - a poor game

Garlett - couldn't find ball

Salem - poor before injury

Kent - probably wasn't playing

Frost - not of standard

Pedersen - see Dunn above

Hunt - out of depth

Jetta - slow and loose

Agree with most of this - but Watts was average and Kennedy was ok.. didn't think he looked slow at all?

Hogan, Viney and Jones are the only ones who can hold their head ups after today's performance.

 

[McQueen 17,867]

Hickey dominated Gawn in the NAB game as well.

I had a feeling Gawn was in for a poor game.

[dave 183]

7 hours ago, KrazyJay said:

21 disposals at 86% Efficiency...

Selection justified if you ask me...

Tried his guts out all day and if he gets dropped after that I would be pi55ed

take 80% said on these forums as shyte, some 'supporters' like to kick the same players week after week, Bugg was ok today

[Gator 17,972]

7 hours ago, McQueen said:

Hickey dominated Gawn in the NAB game as well.

I had a feeling Gawn was in for a poor game.

They broke even.

And Joeboy, Watts was hopeless.  He was back to the non-competitive version.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Supporters disappointed............................again!!

[DeeZone 10,413]

What a miserable effort after the last 3 weeks playing good tough footy, they outrun us, out marked us, worked harder and played smarter?? a number of their faster types can run flat out and still deliver the ball accurately? We lacked speed and footy smarts!!

[Melbournepotter 383]

Riewoldt - Leave him free

[whatwhat say what 23,474]

hogan - he's a freak

nathan jones - played like cotchin

salem - absent, then concussed

watts - excellent second efforts

petracca - started very nervously

viney - the new sellwood

lumumba - offers no leadership

gawn - beaten around ground

tyson - good last quarter

dunn - offered little coverage

kent - a barry crocker

frost - where'd he go?

pedersen - embarrassing and inept

vince - on media street

tom mcdonald - looked very slow

hunt - overwhelmed and exposed

bugg - no celebrations again

kennedy - ineffectual and underwhelming

garlett - chocolates to carab

jetta - exposed too often

wagner - can't defend individually

harmes - was he playing?

Edited May 1, 2016 by DemonAndrew
forgot harmes

[Gator 17,972]

2 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

hogan - he's a freak

nathan jones - played like cotchin

salem - absent, then concussed

watts - excellent second efforts

petracca - started very nervously

viney - the new sellwood

lumumba - offers no leadership

gawn - beaten around ground

tyson - good last quarter

dunn - offered little coverage

kent - a barry crocker

frost - where'd he go?

pedersen - embarrassing and inept

vince - on media street

tom mcdonald - looked very slow

hunt - overwhelmed and exposed

bugg - no celebrations again

kennedy - ineffectual and underwhelming

garlett - chocolates to carab

jetta - exposed too often

wagner - can't defend individually

 

Who beat Gawn around the ground ?  Hickey took one mark for the day. 

[whatwhat say what 23,474]

watching from level 3, hickey was very effective around the ground i thought. didn't mark it but also didn't allow gawn to impact the way he has in recent weeks.

 

hickey drew even with him i thought.