Tom McDonald (and Oscar) SIGNS.

[beelzebub 23,254]

14 minutes ago, Dante said:

 

If Tommy wants the big bucks and wants to be one of the best, he needs to work on his faults.

or he can skidaddle off to a club less picky.  GC probably desperate...have the cash.

I trust the club to value Tmac exactly where he ought to be.   Im not sure the club signs all the right people  but they seem to get valuations close to right 

[Lucifers Hero 39,075]

21 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

or he can skidaddle off to a club less picky.  GC probably desperate...have the cash.

I trust the club to value Tmac exactly where he ought to be.   Im not sure the club signs all the right people  but they seem to get valuations close to right 

Yep, I'll take GC's 2016 1st round pick in return...top 5 pick.  Even get back our own 2016 1st rounder we traded away...around pick 10 (allowing for Academy picks)! Ok I'm dreaming!  TMc swap for Prestia.  Ok I'm still dreaming! 

If this is a game of brinkmanship I don't think it will be the club that blinks!  We have become very good poker players!!

Edited June 8, 2016 by Lucifer's Hero

[old dee 23,580]

21 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

or he can skidaddle off to a club less picky.  GC probably desperate...have the cash.

I trust the club to value Tmac exactly where he ought to be.   Im not sure the club signs all the right people  but they seem to get valuations close to right 

And he may do that bb.

GCS are not as bad as this years results suggest they have a long injury list.

 

 

[Jaded No More 68,692]

3 hours ago, praha said:

I guess we know why Roos is pursuing with the likes of Omac, Wagner and Hunt, in the same way he pushed Frawley forward: preparing for the worst.

Ummm no... Frawley was played up forward, TMac is still holding the most important position in our backline every single week. Totally different.

If anything, playing OMac is probably a way to keep TMac engaged and wanting to stay.

[old dee 23,580]

3 minutes ago, Jaded said:

Ummm no... Frawley was played up forward, TMac is still holding the most important position in our backline every single week. Totally different.

If anything, playing OMac is probably a way to keep TMac engaged and wanting to stay.

I seriously hope that is not the reason they are playing OMac.

 

[The Reverend 1,736]

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

or he can skidaddle off to a club less picky.  GC probably desperate...have the cash.

I trust the club to value Tmac exactly where he ought to be.   Im not sure the club signs all the right people  but they seem to get valuations close to right 

Exactly what I'm saying. He's not perfect. Like all of us, he can improve and if he's any sort of professional, that's what he'll be working on. If he thinks he's worth more than we are willing to pay then he should seek greener pastures. The club will do what is best for the club.

My point is that he is far from the worst in the team and he does not deserve some of the bagging he has received on here. I'm all about objectivity. Let's take the emotion out of it and stick to the observable facts. Maybe some of his mistakes may occasionally lead to an opposition goal but this is no worse than mistakes in other parts of the ground. They just appear more costly. I would argue that mistakes like not seeing Jack Watts on his own 20 meters from goal and putting it on top of Hogan's head in a two on one contest is even more costly. Sometimes, it depends on which end of the ground the mistakes happen. 

[Jaded No More 68,692]

1 hour ago, old dee said:

I seriously hope that is not the reason they are playing OMac.

 

Me too, but playing alongside his brother can't hurt his chances of signing. 

[beelzebub 23,254]

11 minutes ago, Jaded said:

Me too, but playing alongside his brother can't hurt his chances of signing. 

just winning !! 

[ArtificialWisdom 4,045]

2 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Yep, I'll take GC's 2016 1st round pick in return...top 5 pick.  Even get back our own 2016 1st rounder we traded away...around pick 10 (allowing for Academy picks)! Ok I'm dreaming!  TMc swap for Prestia.  Ok I'm still dreaming! 

If this is a game of brinkmanship I don't think it will be the club that blinks!  We have become very good poker players!!

Midfielders are a dime a dozen, I would never trade TMac for Prestia. Would have to get a KPD and a 2nd/3rd rounder in return. Ik people keep complaining but he is on of the best rated young defenders going around, he would demand a big trade price. When it comes down to it, trading a mobile, tall, aerobic beast with obvious talent  who is 1-3 years off his peak is just stupid. He has decision making flaws but other than that he is everything you want in a 2nd defender. We just need the first defender and the jobs done. Get the other pieces right and its funny how any players flaws start to get hidden in a good side. Some players just need talent around them Tom is one of those players. 

[Lucifers Hero 39,075]

4 minutes ago, ArtificialWisdom said:

Midfielders are a dime a dozen, I would never trade TMac for Prestia. Would have to get a KPD and a 2nd/3rd rounder in return. Ik people keep complaining but he is on of the best rated young defenders going around, he would demand a big trade price. When it comes down to it, trading a mobile, tall, aerobic beast with obvious talent  who is 1-3 years off his peak is just stupid. He has decision making flaws but other than that he is everything you want in a 2nd defender. We just need the first defender and the jobs done. Get the other pieces right and its funny how any players flaws start to get hidden in a good side. Some players just need talent around them Tom is one of those players. 

Agreed.  My post was somewhat tongue-in-cheek saying that if TMc goes chasing big coin and mfc just say:  take it or leave it and he declines to accept our offer.  Then we have to make the most of the inevitable trade.

[Sir Why You Little 36,774]

4 minutes ago, ArtificialWisdom said:

Midfielders are a dime a dozen, I would never trade TMac for Prestia. Would have to get a KPD and a 2nd/3rd rounder in return. Ik people keep complaining but he is on of the best rated young defenders going around, he would demand a big trade price. When it comes down to it, trading a mobile, tall, aerobic beast with obvious talent  who is 1-3 years off his peak is just stupid. He has decision making flaws but other than that he is everything you want in a 2nd defender. We just need the first defender and the jobs done. Get the other pieces right and its funny how any players flaws start to get hidden in a good side. Some players just need talent around them Tom is one of those players. 

You are being to Logical AW

Right now our senior list has some talent. Is still learning how to get a killer instinct. (We lost that somewhere 50 years ago)

But the most pressing partvis the list is not balanced. 

Grimes is done. Lynden is also finished. 

Recruiting Melksham was just plain stupid. TMac for all his flaws must be retained or if not must be replaced with an en experienced key defender

[Undeeterred 3,101]

16 hours ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I don't like to buy into crap like "contract negotiations/uncertainty are becoming a distraction" but how many times do we hear "the players didn't come to play" or "they're not on today". How hard can it be....

Whatever the reason he isn't replicating his early form from last year.

They're not robots mate.

Are you telling me you've never had an off day at work? Never, for example, woke up feeling sore, had a slight cold, had family troubles on your mind, worried about your job security or been angry at your colleagues or boss?

It shows a complete lack of understanding of human nature to just expect footballers to be different to everybody else, and perform at 100% efficiency every time they play a game.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,226]

17 hours ago, Undeeterred said:

They're not robots mate.

Are you telling me you've never had an off day at work? Never, for example, woke up feeling sore, had a slight cold, had family troubles on your mind, worried about your job security or been angry at your colleagues or boss?

It shows a complete lack of understanding of human nature to just expect footballers to be different to everybody else, and perform at 100% efficiency every time they play a game.

We've all had bad days, but with footballers, especially within our club it seems every second weekend they're having a bad day. At some stage considering the money they're on they need to become accountable.

[Copuchas 758]

TMac's contract was also discussed on the Fox Footy mid season review last night.  Jed Healy made a thinly veiled reference to the deal getting done now that McDonald had sorted out his management.   Who manages Tom?  Reading between the lines it looks like a classic case of manager overreach that has required an expectations realignment process to take place.  The club will have been quietly undertaking the exercise behind the scenes.

[beelzebub 23,254]

Just now, Copuchas said:

TMac's contract was also discussed on the Fox Footy mid season review last night.  Jed Healy made a thinly veiled reference to the deal getting done now that McDonald had sorted out his management.   Who manages Tom?  Reading between the lines it looks like a classic case of manager overreach that has required an expectations realignment process to take place.  The club will have been quietly undertaking the exercise behind the scenes.

can you elaborate ?  ta

[Copuchas 758]

2 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

can you elaborate ?  ta

not really because Healy didn't.  But the clear inference was that McDonald has been getting bad advice from his manager but things are well down the path to being put back on track and will culminate in a signature shortly...

[beelzebub 23,254]

Tom maybe not so silly after all. Possibly the nudge from Roo's had him thinking. For all his faults he has a role there to play, for mine as #2 Back Should he stay I hope he's in good company

Thanks Copuchas for the update

[jnrmac 19,949]

18 minutes ago, Copuchas said:

not really because Healy didn't.  But the clear inference was that McDonald has been getting bad advice from his manager but things are well down the path to being put back on track and will culminate in a signature shortly...

Maybe he deals with Pickering and is waiting for the legal case to settle. You can't make assumptions about his management. That is simply overreach.

[beelzebub 23,254]

Who does manage Tom ?

[Copuchas 758]

46 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Maybe he deals with Pickering and is waiting for the legal case to settle. You can't make assumptions about his management. That is simply overreach.

There's no assumption, not even an assertion.  I was relating directly comments made by Healy on the Fox Footy round table for the benefit of those who may not have access.  Go and listen if you wish / have a subscription.  The arrogance of some on here is truly breathtaking.....

[ManDee 7,124]

1 hour ago, Copuchas said:

TMac's contract was also discussed on the Fox Footy mid season review last night.  Jed Healy made a thinly veiled reference to the deal getting done now that McDonald had sorted out his management.   Who manages Tom?  Reading between the lines it looks like a classic case of manager overreach that has required an expectations realignment process to take place.  The club will have been quietly undertaking the exercise behind the scenes.

 

13 minutes ago, Copuchas said:

There's no assumption, not even an assertion.  I was relating directly comments made by Healy on the Fox Footy round table for the benefit of those who may not have access.  Go and listen if you wish / have a subscription.  The arrogance of some on here is truly breathtaking.....

 

 

Assumption :- noun

 

1. 1.

   a thing that is accepted as true or as certain to happen, without proof.

   "they made certain assumptions about the market"

   synonyms:

   supposition, presupposition, presumption, premise, belief, expectation, conjecture,speculation, surmise, guess, theory, hypothesis, postulation, conclusion, deduction,inference, thought, suspicion, notion, impression, fancy;

    

    

   Copuchas, you read between the lines and yet you claim to not make an assumption, you cannot have it both ways, however I agree the arrogance of some here is truly breathtaking.

    

[Copuchas 758]

4 hours ago, ManDee said:

ManDee, let me make it simple for you, lest you have cause to resort to a dictionary....

The verbatim quote from Gerard Healy was: "and I think we'll see Tom McDonald sign in the near future...I think he's ...er...just having management issues at the present time.  He's an important signing".

No assumption, no assertion.  Just factual.

97% for HSC English my side....trust you fared as well or better.

 

 

 

Assumption :- noun

 

1. 1.

   a thing that is accepted as true or as certain to happen, without proof.

   "they made certain assumptions about the market"

   synonyms:

   supposition, presupposition, presumption, premise, belief, expectation, conjecture,speculation, surmise, guess, theory, hypothesis, postulation, conclusion, deduction,inference, thought, suspicion, notion, impression, fancy;

    

    

   Copuchas, you read between the lines and yet you claim to not make an assumption, you cannot have it both ways, however I agree the arrogance of some here is truly breathtaking.

    

 

Edited June 9, 2016 by Copuchas

[ManDee 7,124]

3 minutes ago, Copuchas said:

ManDee, let me make it simple for you, lest you have cause to resort to a dictionary....

The verbatim quote from Gerard Healy was: "and I think we'll see Tom McDonald sign in the near future...I think he's ...er...just having management issues at the present time.  He's an important signing".

No assumption, no assertion.  Just factual.

97% for HSC English my side....trust you fared as well or better.

 

5 hours ago, Copuchas said:

TMac's contract was also discussed on the Fox Footy mid season review last night.  Jed Healy made a thinly veiled reference to the deal getting done now that McDonald had sorted out his management.   Who manages Tom?  Reading between the lines it looks like a classic case of manager overreach that has required an expectations realignment process to take place.  The club will have been quietly undertaking the exercise behind the scenes.

You said "reading between the lines" and then you made two assumptions.

1 "it looks like a classic case of manager overreach"

2 "that has required an expectations realignment process to take place."

Must have been an easy English examination that year.

 

[Little Richard 6,220]

4 hours ago, ManDee said:

 

 

 

Assumption :- noun

 

1. 1.

   a thing that is accepted as true or as certain to happen, without proof.

   "they made certain assumptions about the market"

   synonyms:

   supposition, presupposition, presumption, premise, belief, expectation, conjecture,speculation, surmise, guess, theory, hypothesis, postulation, conclusion, deduction,inference, thought, suspicion, notion, impression, fancy;

    

    

   Copuchas, you read between the lines and yet you claim to not make an assumption, you cannot have it both ways, however I agree the arrogance of some here is truly breathtaking.

    

When people are quoting dictionary meanings, it's time to leave the thread.

[beelzebub 23,254]

Meanwhile someone managed Tom...who ?