Ryan Schoenmakers

[Philthy 284]

Out of contract and will probably miss the GF if Gunston is fit. Would be a handy Forward option with Hogan.

[Redleg 40,994]

He refused to leave even when told he would struggle for games and now might play in a GF. Several older players are close to retirement. He will stay a Hawk.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

Overrated IMO. Another of those players that punches above their weight in a really good team but would struggle at the Dee's. Suckling is another.

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

Overrated IMO. Another of those players that punches above their weight in a really good team but would struggle at the Dee's. Suckling is another.

So we should just stick with the same bunch of players that completely suck, rather than go for players that regularly get games in the best sides?

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Any key forward that we look to recruit needs to meet one major section of criteria.

Are they able to provide ruck relief for Gawn while their primary role is to play key forward.

If any potential recruit doesn't meet this criteria, then it's a no for me. And Schoenmakers doesn't meet it. I'd prefer us to go with Pedersen.

Edited September 27, 2015 by AngryAtCasey

[McQueen 17,865]

Has a man-bun.

It's a no, from me.

[boydie 655]

Has a man-bun.

It's a no, from me.

Had a man-bun.

He now has circa 1998 boy band hair.

Edited September 27, 2015 by boydie

[beelzebub 23,380]

What would he cost ?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,079]

He's a pretty decent runner and not a bad kick. Could easily be turned into a rotating HHF/oversized Mid. He's also been plugged in at both ends of the ground over his career and done well. Roos loves the tall versatile players, so it's not beyond belief that we might go for him.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

So we should just stick with the same bunch of players that completely suck, rather than go for players that regularly get games in the best sides?

Yeah, that's exactly what I meant....

FMD

[Adzman 2,154]

Will be 25 at the start of next season, so fits the age profile. I think Hawthorn fringe players might cost overs in the cap given many of them won't leave unless they get more cash.

Would rather spend on a A grader or extend one of our young guns.

[DeeSpencer 25,761]

Will be 25 at the start of next season, so fits the age profile. I think Hawthorn fringe players might cost overs in the cap given many of them won't leave unless they get more cash.

Would rather spend on a A grader or extend one of our young guns.

We can't attract an A grader and we surely have plenty to attract a young gun and bring in someone of Schoenmakers quality.

[DeeSpencer 25,761]

He panics too much as a defender. His best position is forward, whether he's AFL quality or fringe quality I don't know.

He's probably a touch better than Dawes and Pedersen as a 2nd key forward but I don't think he can ruck any better than those 2 can.

Then it's matter of whether we can play 2 rucks and 2 forwards or 1 ruck and 3 genuine tall forwards. Not many clubs do. North and Freo do. Whilst West Coast and Hawthorn usually play Darling and Gunston respectively as those mobile 3rd tall options.

I'd rather surround Hogan with a good 2nd ruck and a good medium sized player. Schoenmakers is neither of those types.

[Middymalt 244]

After the prelim on the weekend we would be crazy to not look at him he's better than half the players on our list.

[P-man 13,366]

Would become the new Demonland whipping boy. As error prone as they come.

Granted he's improved on the calamity he's been in previous years but would still avoid at all costs. Good example of a crap player made to look better being surrounded by stars.

Edited September 28, 2015 by P-man

[poita 3,902]

Clearly people around here haven't learnt from recent history. Byrnes was a premiership player who gave us nothing. Dawes is a premiership player who is giving us next to nothing. Lumumba is a premiership player who is giving us nothing. Now some want to pay (most likely significant overs) for Schoenmakers who can't even get a game in Hawthorn's premiership sides.

You don't become a good side by sifting through the dregs of successful sides, you have to find guys such as Josh Kennedy (Swans) who are seriously under utilised by their current clubs ,or develop your own stars.

Lesson number 1: Elite players make the mediocre players (eg Schoenmakers) around them look much better than they actually are. Remove the elite players and surround them with average players (eg Melbourne's list), and they are shown up for the mediocre players that they truly are.

[Middymalt 244]

Well Clarkson obviously rates him otherwise Langford would've been playing but hey what would Al know

Edited September 28, 2015 by Middymalt

[Return to Glory 8,443]

Well Clarkson obviously rates him otherwise Langford would've been playing but hey what would Al know

Al knows that one has been playing predominantly as a key forward and the other predominantly as a smaller mid. Hey, that's what Al knows.

[Middymalt 244]

Al knows that one has been playing predominantly as a key forward and the other predominantly as a smaller mid. Hey, that's what Al knows.

Yeah look what the small mid did against the swans last year, if he's good enough too stand up in front of that feral crowd last week and produce what he did he's better than half our list, and to be honest I don't think chips played any better than what he has in previous years

[Return to Glory 8,443]

Yeah look what the small mid did against the swans last year, if he's good enough too stand up in front of that feral crowd last week and produce what he did he's better than half our list, and to be honest I don't think chips played any better than what he has in previous years

Are you now suggesting Langford for Frawley?

[spirit of norm smith 16,479]

He will not leave Hawthorn. Full stop.

[ManDee 7,162]

He will not leave Hawthorn. Full stop.

Three full stops!

[daisycutter 29,627]

Three full stops!

well if that's true he's not being very pragmatic

stay at hawthorn, get low pay, probably not get regular game

move, get big pay rise and regular game time, retire with nice nest egg

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Shoenclangers.

[rpfc 28,544]

Three full stops!

You're having an ellipsis fit!