Oscar to debut!

[Forest Demon 4,681]

I didn't see anything to enthuse me. But it's his first game, in a poor team getting a touch up against a quality opposition, so I am holding any judgement until we see more.

[Adam The God 30,696]

His 'chase' after turning the ball over on 50 was concerning, but it was his first game. At least he got involved in the play a bit.

[Nasher 33,642]

  On 30/08/2015 at 11:36, Forest Demon said:

I didn't see anything to enthuse me. But it's his first game, in a poor team getting a touch up against a quality opposition, so I am holding any judgement until we see more.

I'm not sure what could possibly be seen to enthuse anyone with an underdeveloped key defender. It's why I was a tad surprised by his selection.

[Redleg 42,112]

He will learn from every game he plays and meanwhile will develop physically, to a stage where he can compete with hardened footballers.

[picket fence 18,130]

On what basis was he given this game?? Not in best at Casey over a period of weeks, so if you are rewarding form then how did he get a game??

[What 18,810]

  On 30/08/2015 at 11:44, picket fence said:

On what basis was he given this game?? Not in best at Casey over a period of weeks, so if you are rewarding form then how did he get a game??

Its the end of the season, every team not in finals contention promotes kids to give them a taste of AFL footy, whether they are dominating VFL or not

Its happened since forever and will always happen

[Gator 18,051]

I can't believe people are even critiquing a first gamer.

Extraordinary.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Surely it's a sign that Fitzy's gone? He never got back in the team after tunnel ball.

[jumbo returns 6,744]

I liked him....

[Ted Lasso 19,586]

I thought he showed something, clearly needs another couple of years in the system to develop physically but the raw ingredients are there.

would like to see young White given a run next week at the expense of Matt Jones or someone like that.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

His disposal was somewhat average, but that can be attributed to nerves.

I didnt think he was ever really convincingly beat 1 v 1, which is a really good sign for a first game key defender who at every occasion fremantle dragged deep.

[Demon Jack 7,192]

Ironically, he reminds me of when his brother debuted at the end of 2011. Raw, but gave us an idea what he could produce once he puts on some muscle.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,112]

It was a solid debut given he's not really ready. Seven marks or so. He needs to be more decisive. Most of his mistakes came from being indecisive and holding the ball too long.

[CBDees 3,167]

  On 30/08/2015 at 12:21, Coup Cooper said:

NO!! NO NO..

NO!

  On 30/08/2015 at 13:05, Lamashtu said:

Surely it's a sign that Fitzy's gone? He never got back in the team after tunnel ball.

Yes despite his holding the Western Bulldog's $1M man to a single possession and some BOG performances for Casey. I am not sure why we are not playing a 200cm KP player who can ruck and play both ends? Maybe we should trade him so he can replicate what Steph Martin did at another Club!

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

  On 30/08/2015 at 14:52, CBDees said:

Yes despite his holding the Western Bulldog's $1M man to a single possession and some BOG performances for Casey. I am not sure why we are not playing a 200cm KP player who can ruck and play both ends? Maybe we should trade him so he can replicate what Steph Martin did at another Club!

He had concussion so had missed the last 2 or so weeks in the VFL. Has he shown potential in games to be a similar player to Stef Martin and go to another club and play consistently good football? Not at all.

Fitzy if 50/50 for next year depending on how Jason Taylor see the athletic KP players in the draft

[CBDees 3,167]

  On 30/08/2015 at 15:14, Mad_Melbourne said:

He had concussion so had missed the last 2 or so weeks in the VFL. Has he shown potential in games to be a similar player to Stef Martin and go to another club and play consistently good football? Not at all.

Fitzy if 50/50 for next year depending on how Jason Taylor see the athletic KP players in the draft

So you miss two weeks with concussion (like Jetta) and you suddenly become 50/50 with no potentional? I think that the clip in the link below from his last game suggests that there is some upside with Fitzy!

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/video-melbournes-jack-fitzpatrick-kicks-running-goal-in-vfl-for-casey-scorpions/story-e6frf3e3-1227487350475

[CityDee 738]

We have a winner here Id say , at the right height with time to devolop physically will be a better player than the muppet at the other end Zac Dawson

[baysidedave 246]

  On 30/08/2015 at 11:36, Forest Demon said:

I didn't see anything to enthuse me. But it's his first game, in a poor team getting a touch up against a quality opposition, so I am holding any judgement until we see more.

He was ok, disposal is not up to it, bit like his brother with the kicking but he didn't disgrace himself and reckon has a future

[ManDee 7,375]

I thought he was OK.

Will develop into a good player.

[praha 11,267]

  On 30/08/2015 at 11:36, AdamFarr said:

His 'chase' after turning the ball over on 50 was concerning, but it was his first game. At least he got involved in the play a bit.

He was absolutely stuffed. Underdone and not ready but will be better for the run.

Gave it a go and seemed confident with the ball even against top opposition even if his disposal was bad at times. At least he doesn't hyperventilate and fluff most of his possessions like some of the team's 100+ gamers. His errors were genuinely a product of him just having zero tank. Give him a break.

[dazzledavey36 56,203]

Can anyone see him becoming more of a forward later in the next couple of years.

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

  On 30/08/2015 at 18:47, CBDees said:

So you miss two weeks with concussion (like Jetta) and you suddenly become 50/50 with no potentional? I think that the clip in the link below from his last game suggests that there is some upside with Fitzy!

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/video-melbournes-jack-fitzpatrick-kicks-running-goal-in-vfl-for-casey-scorpions/story-e6frf3e3-1227487350475

You completely misunderstood my quote and took it out of context. But you were wondering why he didn't play and I gave you the reason

What I said was he has not shown potential similar to what Stef Martin had, in order to clarify this further so you understand, this is in regard to AFL football. Stef had several games where he played as number 1 ruck and showed that he has the level recquired to be a consistent AFL footballer but when moved into the resting positions of CHF or CHB he seemed to struggle to get involved.

I still maintain Fitzy is 50/50 to stay on the list next year, which hardly means he has no potential, but rather if the list managers think there is an athletic KP player that they would rather give 5 years into then they will take him.

Fitzy consistently plays solid VFL football but struggles at AFL, which is not really new knowledge to most.

[rjay 25,408]

  On 30/08/2015 at 20:44, CityDee said:

We have a winner here Id say , at the right height with time to devolop physically will be a better player than the muppet at the other end Zac Dawson

Dawson is a much better player than he gets credit for.

[Deeoldfart 8,199]

For an under-developed teenager and potential KPP, I reckon I'd take him at pick 53 in 9 out of 10 drafts.

[praha 11,267]

  On 31/08/2015 at 01:23, rjay said:

Dawson is a much better player than he gets credit for.

Has cemented his spot in good sides for almost a decade. Got under Hogan's skin for a while there as well. Important piece of Freo's defense, which is the best in the league (although "defense" in the AFL embodies the whole team across the ground).