Changes vs Essendon

[Brayshaw Self 847]

Harmes deserves a run.

[picket fence 15,131]

Wonder if Fitz might be brought in to play on Daniher?

Cheezus Chook given our luck with this sort of thing I'd back Daniher to bag 7 !!?

[Redleg 37,571]

Too many players missing games due to precaution these days.

Could we have a win in the game of precaution?

[Jaded No More 57,810]

We can't play 2 ruckmen again. Essendon barely have 1.

If we go to talk we will lose especially coming back from hot humid conditions. We need legs!

[rjay 23,901]

Choice between Howe and Dawes and trade both at the end of the year.

Bring in Harmes for one of them.

Spencer, Bail & Jones out for Newton, JKH & 'H'.

[drdrake 3,037]

Out two blokes that dropped chest marks 20m out. Plus Brayshaw

In JKH, H, Grimes

[leucopogon 1,468]

How far away is Salem?

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

How far away is Salem?

I think he lives in Elwood.

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

m8, you don't send a (possible) AA defender to the magoos. He made some mistakes but was beaten by a pull that was rocketed to the forwards lace out. Very hard to stop if the mids aren't applying pressure to their mids.

You can drop anyone if theyre not performing. He was smashing it earlier in the year when our mids were even worse, so im not sure thats the reason. He seems a different player last 5 weeks Just want him to lift a bit.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Harmes won't play. You're all dreaming.

One thing that has to happen is Spencer being dropped. We were too tall and, as many have mentioned, the Bombers barely have one ruckman playing, so we need to go with Gawn and Dawes pinch hitting and add more run to the side.

JKH and Newton are two who stand out, while Michie may also get another look in as well. Until Salem, VDB, Kent etc are ready to return though it's really a case of swapping a few deck chairs at the minute.

It's a big 3 weeks though we 3 VERY winnable games.

[JV7 2,339]

God help us if we lose to Essendon next week

[Binmans PA 26,049]

I hope Essendon play like they're playing today next week.

[monoccular 16,062]

Harmes won't play. You're all dreaming.

One thing that has to happen is Spencer being dropped. We were too tall and, as many have mentioned, the Bombers barely have one ruckman playing, so we need to go with Gawn and Dawes pinch hitting and add more run to the side.

JKH and Newton are two who stand out, while Michie may also get another look in as well. Until Salem, VDB, Kent etc are ready to return though it's really a case of swapping a few deck chairs at the minute.

It's a big 3 weeks though we 3 VERY winnable games.

Except that Dawes will not pinch hit. 2 years ago I though I would never say this, but we are missing [Pedersen].

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Except that Dawes will not pinch hit. 2 years ago I though I would never say this, but we are missing [Pedersen].

He will if he has to. We can't go in with 2 ruckmen, and we can't drop Spencer and replace him with Fitzy as that defeats the purpose.

I do agree though - we miss Pedersen in this regard. He provides exactly what we need in this area right now.

[Disco Demons 92]

After watching Max King in two of his last three matches at VFL level, I can honestly say there's no way that he's ready for AFL footy just yet.

Big blokes are usually gifted AFL games before midfielders. Apparently it helps their development.

Dawes form is terrible. He is a senior player with a premiership. He kicked two goals last night. Pretty easy goals. Was at the game in Darwin.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Debuting Harmes is just exposing us to get beaten by Essendon...his output wont be any better than playing a M Jones or Bail.

Out: Spencer

In: Lumumba

[Bang Bang Bang 5,455]

Traditionally, we play poorly the week after our trip to the Top End so I would make plenty of changes to ensure the team that runs our against Essendon next week has fresh legs and is capable of running out the game.

As well as Max Gawn has played since he came back into the side, I would rest both he and Jake Spencer by returning both back to Casey for this week and replacing them with Mark Jamar and Jack Fitzpatrick.

Angus Brayshaw was due for a rest and even if he comes up after his head and neck injury, let him have the week off.

Rohan Bail and Matt Jones had poor games and the deck chairs can be rearranged this week with any of Jay Kennedy-Harris, Viv Michie, Ben Newton or Aidan Riley.

I'm keeping Alex Neal-Bullen and Billy Stretch in the team so I'm inclined to make James Harmes to wait that extra week before making his debut.

Anyone know when Jack Grimes and Heritier Lumumba are due back?

Apart from a 2 minute cameo last night, he hasn't played for 2 weeks now. By next Saturday it will be 3. He will be fresh, provided his neck injury can subside.

[Henrietta Lumbago 331]

Harmes won't play. You're all dreaming.

One thing that has to happen is Spencer being dropped. We were too tall and, as many have mentioned, the Bombers barely have one ruckman playing, so we need to go with Gawn and Dawes pinch hitting and add more run to the side.

JKH and Newton are two who stand out, while Michie may also get another look in as well. Until Salem, VDB, Kent etc are ready to return though it's really a case of swapping a few deck chairs at the minute.

It's a big 3 weeks though we 3 VERY winnable games.

We were beaten by a very good midfield last night, The big men did ok. Our midfield and backline didnt provide the run into our forward line the way WC did, which made it harder for the resting ruckman and other forwards..We missed lumumba and Brayshaw last night who run the ball out of our defense and get the ball going forward so often.

[JV7 2,339]

The Gawn/Spencer combo worked against the cats when they really only had Blicavs and Walker as their ruckmen, it's easy to say we were too tall last night and Spencer needs to go because essendon don't really have a ruck anyway, it could be like the Geelong game a good chance to dominate out of the middle with Gawn & Spencer... That was a big difference last night compared to the Geelong game, we couldn't get our hands on the footy at stoppages which we dominated Geelong at the previous week

Edited July 5, 2015 by JV7

[What 18,810]

The Gawn/Spencer combo worked against the cats when they really only had Blicavs and Walker as their ruckmen, it's easy to say we were too tall last night and Spencer needs to go because essendon don't really have a ruck anyway, it could be like the Geelong game a good chance to dominate out of the middle with Gawn & Spencer... That was a big difference last night compared to the Geelong game, we couldn't get our hands on the footy at stoppages which we dominated Geelong at the previous week

The problem isnt Gawn and Spemcer., its that we added Hogan to the team without dropping a tall.

[chook fowler 18,226]

Cheezus Chook given our luck with this sort of thing I'd back Daniher to bag 7 !!?

p

Trouble is Daniher is too tall for Dunn and McDonald

[monoccular 16,062]

Too many players missing games due to precaution these days.

I am certain that were we fighting for a top 8 spot thing may be handled differently. And THAT IS NOT TANKING, it is sensible player management.

Wonder if Fitz might be brought in to play on Daniher?

Would ease the dilemma of two rucks, if Fitz ran with Daniher all day, wherever he goes, whether as a forward or in the ruck, or on the bench.

He will if he has to. We can't go in with 2 ruckmen, and we can't drop Spencer and replace him with Fitzy as that defeats the purpose.

I do agree though - we miss Pedersen in this regard. He provides exactly what we need in this area right now.

see above. Fitz one on one with Daniher all day...then poor Dawsey wouldn't have to ruck at all.

[monoccular 16,062]

p

Trouble is Daniher is too tall for Dunn and McDonald

....which could make Fitz an ideal match up. Apparently he had a good game at Casey.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

p

Trouble is Daniher is too tall for Dunn and McDonald

I'm holding my breath as I type this, but.... Fitzpatrick? I don't know how you fit him in to the side as another tall, but he could handle Daniher in terms of height, size and speed.

[Gorgoroth 12,319]

Must drop one ruck and bring in a runner, Saints are running them into the ground.