Selection Table

[Dee-licious 1,954]

Hi All - have sat on this for 6 weeks now but though with the Stretch arguments on the other page that I should bring this up. A fringe Demon player was having a [censored] to me about selection. That Goodwin is the main man in selection and he is more focused on buiding his list. He felt that the younger players were given more focus than the older ones and that he felt that he wasn't in Goodwin's plans which was a reasons behind his lack of selection.

Has anyone else heard this from their sources? Just want to confirm if it is true or not or him being a little disgruntaled. Thanks.

[rjay 25,347]

Hi All - have sat on this for 6 weeks now but though with the Stretch arguments on the other page that I should bring this up. A fringe Demon player was having a [censored] to me about selection. That Goodwin is the main man in selection and he is more focused on buiding his list. He felt that the younger players were given more focus than the older ones and that he felt that he wasn't in Goodwin's plans which was a reasons behind his lack of selection.

Has anyone else heard this from their sources? Just want to confirm if it is true or not or him being a little disgruntaled. Thanks.

Sure hope he is...

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I think a lot of team selections have been poor this year, not because young players are getting unwarranted games but because so many fringe players have been getting a good run.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,271]

I think a lot of team selections have been poor this year, not because young players are getting unwarranted games but because so many fringe players have been getting a good run.

The only reason for this I see is giving them one last chance after another pre season with Roo's and Co.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

I think a lot of team selections have been poor this year, not because young players are getting unwarranted games but because so many fringe players have been getting a good run.

Our run with injuries hasn't helped. Once we got a few there wasn't much else to choose from.

[dazzledavey36 55,990]

Hi All - have sat on this for 6 weeks now but though with the Stretch arguments on the other page that I should bring this up. A fringe Demon player was having a [censored] to me about selection. That Goodwin is the main man in selection and he is more focused on buiding his list. He felt that the younger players were given more focus than the older ones and that he felt that he wasn't in Goodwin's plans which was a reasons behind his lack of selection.

Has anyone else heard this from their sources? Just want to confirm if it is true or not or him being a little disgruntaled. Thanks.

Why do I have a strange feeling that its Jordie Mckenzie.

[beelzebub 23,390]

It might or might not occurred to this certain fringe-player that the footy world doesn't revolve around him. The FD will do what's required to better our results. It's not even personal, though he may see it that way.

[chook fowler 19,734]

Why do I have a strange feeling that its Jordie Mckenzie.

It also has a Russian feel to it.

[beelzebub 23,390]

It also has a Russian feel to it.

was similarly my first inclination as well.

[Lucifers Hero 40,563]

Hi All - have sat on this for 6 weeks now but though with the Stretch arguments on the other page that I should bring this up. A fringe Demon player was having a [censored] to me about selection. That Goodwin is the main man in selection and he is more focused on buiding his list. He felt that the younger players were given more focus than the older ones and that he felt that he wasn't in Goodwin's plans which was a reasons behind his lack of selection.

Has anyone else heard this from their sources? Just want to confirm if it is true or not or him being a little disgruntaled. Thanks.

When a club 'rebuilds' or decides to 'play the kids' fringe players will, fairly or unfairly, miss out.

Some get delisted (Cross, Chapman) and picked up by another club, some get traded (Cooney, Podsiardly) some stay on the list as depth.

Its all a natural part of every club's list management and there will be aggrieved players.

We have an unusual number of inexperienced players who need to be developed and when ready play senior games.

That is not good for the more senior players that aren't regular 22.

Player development and experience will be given priority and whether it is Roos or Goodwin it is what I would expect and want them to do.

[dazzledavey36 55,990]

It also has a Russian feel to it.

Yeah your probably right actually.

[What 18,810]

That player sounds like another unprofessional sook. Hope he gets the chop at seasons end whoever it is.

Team selection was spot on this week btw.

[Nasher 33,617]

Good to hear that Goodwin is trying to establish his list.

[Dee-licious 1,954]

My mind we selected really well down to the withdrawal of Fitz once we knew Hickey was out. And they way the young kids are playing is more impressive than some of the older counterparts who get more of the ball in the vfl. I do wonder though if we had at kildas run with injuries (eg none) if we'd have played as many players. Assume that Kent, Salem, Frost would have all not missed a game.

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

This player needs a good hard look in the mirror.

If you are a fringe player in the worst performing team of the decade, the odds are that the younger players are better than you.

The odds are that you have had many chances and failed to grasp them and it's probably safe to say that you are just not good enough and you should be thankful for the chances you had.

Seriously, it's not like there's been many 'fringe' players tearing it up for Casey and not being given a chance.

[Harrisonrules 273]

I think a lot of team selections have been poor this year, not because young players are getting unwarranted games but because so many fringe players have been getting a good run.

Examples?

[Harrisonrules 273]

That player sounds like another unprofessional sook. Hope he gets the chop at seasons end whoever it is.

Team selection was spot on this week btw.

Why a sook, I would hope he was disgruntled. That's the attitude that impresses me

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Why a sook, I would hope he was disgruntled. That's the attitude that impresses me

What, that he is sooking about games he hasn't deserved to get?

[M C 221]

Why a sook, I would hope he was disgruntled. That's the attitude that impresses me

Someone who doesn't complain but instead works harder would be much more impressive

[MadAsHell 4,217]

Jordie McKenzie

Viv Michie

Jack Grimes

Mark Jamar

Rohan Bail

Dean Terlich

Have to be the main suspects.

Matt Jones has been in the side recently while Riley & Gawn's back in so doubt it would have been either of them.

[Earl Hood 6,152]

Some player's papers have been stamped. Only injuries will give them another chance and the way we are travelling I wouldn't give up yet.

[mo64 5,886]

Jordie McKenzie

Viv Michie

Jack Grimes

Mark Jamar

Rohan Bail

Dean Terlich

Have to be the main suspects.

Matt Jones has been in the side recently while Riley & Gawn's back in so doubt it would have been either of them.

I doubt that it's Michie or Grimes. Michie is still young and has had some chances, whilst Grimes doesn't strike me as the type to whinge. If the conversation occured 6 weeks ago, I'm thinking that the prime candidates are M. Jones, Jamar, McKenzie or Terlich. Out of that lot, Jamar is the only one to have some case to question selection, because he wasn't playing that bad when he got dropped, and Spencer wasn't going to offer anything better.

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

I love this thread. A rumour followed by a manhunt. I reckon it was Keyser Soze.

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,354]

No issue with Goodwin running selection considering he's getting the keys to the joint next October.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I think a lot of team selections have been poor this year, not because young players are getting unwarranted games but because so many fringe players have been getting a good run.

list screening..?

It also has a Russian feel to it.

... &, maybe a gripe from Grimes.

My mind we selected really well down to the withdrawal of Fitz once we knew Hickey was out. And they way the young kids are playing is more impressive than some of the older counterparts who get more of the ball in the vfl. I do wonder though if we had at kildas run with injuries (eg none) if we'd have played as many players. Assume that Kent, Salem, Frost would have all not missed a game.

this is right Dee-l', & the hangover of the old culture & the recent seasons beatings has hurt some footy psyches.

Roosy has little time to achieve the AFL's mission impossible, & hand this club over in good shape, for Goodwin to take forward. This mission, which was accepted, has no time for too much sympathy, as we were down to our last elbow patches, & chances.

last season imo, was about teaching, sorting the chaff, changing the culture & forming future plans; this season imo is about further cleaning the list, for the future club, & establishing/ingraining strong winning attitudes & re-establishing 'hope' throughout the club, & respect throughout the AFL.

..... next season I think will be about putting the show on the road, climbing the ladder & gaining upward momentum. I can see this coming 'off-season', will be our most important in a long long while.

.