Why doesn't Howe go 3rd man up?

[TGR 1,367]

Our rucks are rucked. Our midfield is one paced. Our problems run deep.

Don't understand why we don't use this guy around stoppages as a 3rd man up.

Most teams do it. Lewis @ Hawthorn. Cunnington @ North. Blicavs @ Geelong.

Teams that have poor rucks and average mids should do it more.

[jazza 1,323]

Our rucks are rucked. Our midfield is one paced. Our problems run deep.

Don't understand why we don't use this guy around stoppages as a 3rd man up.

Most teams do it. Lewis @ Hawthorn. Cunnington @ North. Blicavs @ Geelong.

Teams that have poor rucks and average mids should do it more.

We dont usually play an extra at the stoppage.

Hawthorn and North do.

[Fork 'em 7,052]

Don't understand why we don't use this guy around stoppages as a 3rd man up.

That would require effort.

[deanox 10,052]

We dont usually play an extra at the stoppage.

Hawthorn and North do.

We did last week. Maybe not by design; the swans dropped a player back and ours didn't go with him. I think we are better off playing man on man than spares anywhere. It means we don't have anyone to kick it to when we win the ball.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

He doesn't for Frawleyesque reasons.

[SaberFang 7,151]

He doesn't because he's lazy, doesn't give a [censored], and clearly has both feet out the door as Frawley did by this time last year.

Just fark off Howe. You believe your own hype, but your clueless reaction to Roos' spray at your pathetic lack of effort says everything that needs to be said about your deficiencies as a footballer.

[praha 11,253]

If someone pays 600k for him, it'll be a blessing in disguise for us.

Another top 10 pick coming our way.

Oh, the question.

Because we are tanking, duh!

Edited May 17, 2015 by praha

[daisycutter 29,902]

Why doesn't Howe go 3rd man up?

[titan_uranus 25,203]

We dont usually play an extra at the stoppage.

Hawthorn and North do.

Actually, we regularly do. Especially when the ball is in the defensive half of the ground. We regularly push our numbers up into the contest. It congests the defensive 50 which means if we do get the clearance we are pressured and we panic and we rush the kick, which of course ends up being marked by the opposition's back six, who just sit back behind the play and wait.

One of the critical things Roos has to work on is stopping this from happening. If he's organising it, he should stop. If he's not, he needs to fix it, because if we keep playing with numbers too far back behind the ball our transitions from the backline to the forward line just aren't going to come together.

[John Crow Batty 8,886]

Saving his jumping credits for speccie's ?

Edited May 17, 2015 by america de cali

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Saving his jumping credits for species?

Species of what America?

[John Crow Batty 8,886]

Species of what America?

I beat you with my edit.

[DeeMfc 621]

His total lack of effort makes me even more infuriated with his knee to Jettas face...

[TGR 1,367]

By virtue of necessity (Pedo injured), Watts and Howe took some centre bounces, and did OK.

I know the ruck contest is a dangerous position for the immature bodies and/or poor technique; but we should have seen glimpses of this in the past in cameos etc...

Chris Scott will force Roos to again think proactively and radically in the ruck this week. Watts or Cross????? on Blicavs. I would go Tom Mc. If Stanley plays, we might need to think of a Howe type around the ground with him.

[Nasher 33,617]

I don't mind seeing Watts or Howe go third man up around the ground when there's a solid body there too. Watts did one very smart tap that resulted in a goal last week.

I'd hate to see them in actual ruck contests though. I just have visions of Jared Brennan contesting the ruck for Brisbane a few years ago and getting a bad knee in the ribs straight up. I'd see Hogan in there before I saw a flanker go in there to get killed.

[Seraph 1,824]

I don't mind seeing Watts or Howe go third man up around the ground when there's a solid body there too. Watts did one very smart tap that resulted in a goal last week.

I'd hate to see them in actual ruck contests though. I just have visions of Jared Brennan contesting the ruck for Brisbane a few years ago and getting a bad knee in the ribs straight up. I'd see Hogan in there before I saw a flanker go in there to get killed.

I'd have thought that Howe can potentially jump high enough in a ruck contest to avoid any potential knees.

[Fat Tony 5,322]

Watts actually does pretty well in the centre bounces. He is a much better option than Dawes.

[DeeSpencer 26,458]

Both Cross and Watts have been going 3rd man up for a lot of this year. Watts did it effectively against the Dogs.

3rd man up is useful against a good ruck, but it's not very often you can get a free man to go 3rd man up and then also outnumber a team in the direction that the 3rd man hits it. Most of the time it's just moving the problem, which is fine against a team with a dominant ruck or a particularly good clearance midfielder, but I don't think it's a substitute for winning a clear hit out to advantage.

[monoccular 17,695]

We dont usually play an extra at the stoppage.

Hawthorn and North do.

6th, 12th.....15th

Watts actually does pretty well in the centre bounces. He is a much better option than Dawes.

Not particularly high bar have you set, but yes, I get the gist

[Demon Disciple 12,482]

Why? I'll tell you why. He's lazy.

Trade him whilst other teams think he is more than a one-trick pony.

[Ted Lasso 19,564]

How's about we just learn to play basic footy consistently before we try and complicate it?? christ we don't know what sort of effort we're going to bring quarter by quarter at the moment

[Je Roos Salem 661]

It's Cross' forte. In fact he had 70 hitouts in 2010 with the Dogs. Although it's quite odd that Howe never takes ruck contests when he can seemingly leap at the flick of a switch, he'll probably just forget and try to mark them though

Wouldn't mind seeing Watts doing a bit of rucking. In fact he should run with Blicavs through the middle/maybe drag him into our 50