The One That Got Away

[daisycutter 29,341]

Brad Sewell.

sorry, my bad

need brain cells serviced

[Melbman2 226]

Sydney took Lewis Jetta

And Barry Prender-aghast sat in the Jetta lounge room while the mom told him Lewis was the pick of the crop (we could have rookied him that year as he missed being drafted).

Unlike BP to miss one

[tilly18 287]

Tom Rockliff was overlooked by us..

The knock on Rockcliff was he had no endurance and was overlooked in the National draft.

He was training at Melbourne and with all the tests done on him it was decided to use pick 1 in the pre season draft to select him.

It was then decided it would be a better outcome to use pick 1 in the pre season draft on Jurrah and then use pick 1 in the rookie draft on Rockliff.

It was never anticipated Brisbane would take.

[Ted Lasso 18,786]

Was it Rory Sloane who we told we'd draft then took Jamie Bennell instead?

[Demon Disciple 11,680]

Was it Rory Sloane who we told we'd draft then took Jamie Bennell instead?

Yep, we basically swore to his family that if available, we'd pick him with our 2nd rounder.

Whoops.

As for the other one that got away..............it simply has to be Ollie Wines. He's a dead-set gun, whereas Toumpas is about to be fired out of one.

[Redleg 40,219]

Easy.

In the 2009 AFL National Draft, Melbourne had four picks in the top 18 selections and we were looking for midfield talent to shore up our third world midfield. We took -

1. Tom Scully

2. Jack Trengove

11. Jordan Gysberts

18. Luke Tapscott

Fremantle took Nathan Fyfe with pick 20.

Also, in between Gysberts and Tapscott, Adelaide took Daniel Talia, Sydney took Lewis Jetta and Geelong took Daniel Menzel. Collingwood got Luke Ball with #30 so there you have a good few who got away considering three of our four are no longer at the club and JT will have missed near on two full seasons by the end of 2015 and but for a cracked foot would have been at Tigerland anyway this year.

Nailed it son.

Though that pick 1 got us Jesse and Dawes, so Prendergast must have been a genius or a clairvoyant.

[spirit of norm smith 15,249]

please this is a horror show !!

[Sir Why You Little 36,668]

please this is a horror show !!

Too right it is Norm

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,652]

I'm surprised no-one has mentioned potential coaches (meaning those actually interested and available) we could have had since 2000 rather than the ones we decided upon.

[Roost It 1,434]

Where the hell do you start?

We have tried to play catch up over 8 years rather than reinventing ourselves Roos is now just continuing the past . Just Pathetic and I cant blame him because obviously he is not allowed to drop under performers like Jack.

Dropping Watts is not the answer. His problem is confidence. Roos is showing belief in him and pushing him to regain confidence in the seniors. Dropping him will kill what little self belief he has after becoming the worst handled high pick in AFL history. He is one player that the club owes more to than he does to the club

[Yossarian 1,820]

I'm surprised no-one has mentioned potential coaches (meaning those actually interested and available) we could have had since 2000 rather than the ones we decided upon.

Neeld over Hinkley's a pretty good one.

[Buzzy 992]

Tom Rockliff was overlooked by us..

Not sure he's the type of character we need down at Melbourne anyway..

Source: my vibe

[jackaub 1,402]

Dropping Watts is not the answer. His problem is confidence. Roos is showing belief in him and pushing him to regain confidence in the seniors. Dropping him will kill what little self belief he has after becoming the worst handled high pick in AFL history. He is one player that the club owes more to than he does to the club

Lets get one think straight Roosty

The club owes nothing to these professionals other than an opportunity to participate at the highest level and if they perform they are valued and if not they get another career.Never understood this notion of debt in a completely professional sport

[Ted Lasso 18,786]

Imagine the confidence jimmy Toumpas got last year when he'd come up to afl level plays okay but clearly needs time to get used to the pace of the game but gets dropped the next week while watts gets chance after chance

Not a great example imo

[jackaub 1,402]

As others have said before Roos' either has unshakable belief in JW or club politics won't allow him the decision.Neither are helping JW,other players' perceptions or the club

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Sloane, Rockliff and Wines were all seemingly players we were very interested in, had spoken to a lot, and were available to us at the time, but we took Bennell, Jurrah and Toumpas instead.

The Fyfe one is funny, you would have hoped one of BP's blind punches might have connected, but who is to say Fyfe would be the player he is today if he were a Dee.

Edit: obviously I would be willing to take that chance to see if he would have become that player

Edited May 6, 2015 by Forest Demon

[markc 975]

What about Todd Goldstein , we spoke to him prior to the draft then again when he was looking at him after 2 years

[faultydet 7,594]

Dropping Watts is not the answer. His problem is confidence. Roos is showing belief in him and pushing him to regain confidence in the seniors. Dropping him will kill what little self belief he has after becoming the worst handled high pick in AFL history. He is one player that the club owes more to than he does to the club

Absolute bulshit.

Yes, he was hyped up, and played WAY too soon.

But it wasn't that decision that made him a scared little man, who wees his smalls every time a physical contest is imminent, or even in the general vicinity.

He is a bust. Just like Toumpas appears to be, and just like Plodgrove appears to be (might be a bit harsh on Trenners, as he looked the goods early, apart from being a tad slow)

Drop him now, and make him EARN his place. My money would be it wouldn't happen, as VFL requires physical contact also.

[Crompton's the man 659]

Martin Pike for me.

We had him and he showed what a great player he could be - just we never saw it while he wore the best colours

[Strapping Young Lad 227]

Martin Pike for me.

We had him and he showed what a great player he could be - just we never saw it while he wore the best colours

And he punched Garry Lyon!!!

[Gator 17,261]

Wirrpanda, because Kowal didn't want to go.

[faultydet 7,594]

Martin Pike for me.

We had him and he showed what a great player he could be - just we never saw it while he wore the best colours

Really?

I thought Scott Thompson was much more valuable at the Crows, than Pike was at Brisbane.

[Crompton's the man 659]

Really?

I thought Scott Thompson was much more valuable at the Crows, than Pike was at Brisbane.

Fair enough - won't argue too much except to say Martin has played in more Premiership sides.

But I've been feeling the pain for quite a few years now,every time watching Adelaide play, agreed.

[faultydet 7,594]

Fair enough - won't argue too much except to say Martin has played in more Premiership sides.

But I've been feeling the pain for quite a few years now,every time watching Adelaide play, agreed.

Steven Armstrong played in more premiership sides than Robert Harvey, and Robert Flower.

But, I feel your pain also.

edit for single malt spelling. Apologies.

Edited May 6, 2015 by faultydet

[spirit of norm smith 15,249]

Rory Sloane

we promised him & his family and then turned our back on them.

Prendergast was a disaster !!!