AFL National Draft 2014 Picks 2 & 3

[Demanding Success 298]

Just to add to de goey from what I've seen, he is a great tackler, and I mean a great tackler. Very, very aggressive at the ball and the man. Played a lot around half forward with stints in the middle. Had an outstanding finish to the season after the champs. Kicks goals as well. Is a terrific half forward at keeping the ball in the forward line. He really did get better as the year went on.

[jnrmac 20,065]

There is a distinct prototype being adhered to in the Roos era re mids. They are around 6 foot and no nonsense.

Roos imho likes to assemble teams founded upon a core of utilities. These are more than just mids per se they are the footy's version of the Universal Soldier. Get 8-10 of these out on the park at any given moment and they just wear down oppositions and relentlessly push forward. They grind games, they grind opponents. They sometimes exhibit flair but in the main they just go about a job...( their role ) and depending who's on song on any given day a slight jugglling may occur until the team clicks again.

Look at the foot soldiers...who are they in the draft...pick 2 of them and theyre ours

Remember Roos saying he saw Freo's mids and how they were all tall big bodied (maybe not Fyffe) and how that was the new prototype. I suspect he is heading down that path.

[jnrmac 20,065]

Pick 3 is a career defining one for Jason Taylor. I suppose they all are but this pick in particular stands to be the most difficult and contentious.

Whoever he takes his little boys are on the line.

The draft isn't what it was ten years ago, the top boys are hard to pick. He will earn every cent of his wage if he nails this one pick.

It could be career defining but its interesting isn't it. The recruiters get no plaudits if they do well with pick 2 or 3 but it if they stuff it up the world knows about it. They mostly go for safety with the low picks - a bit like buying an IBM

[InVINCEable 358]

Remember Roos saying he saw Freo's mids and how they were all tall big bodied (maybe not Fyffe) and how that was the new prototype. I suspect he is heading down that path.

Sounds like it, building no forward line too just like Freo.

[beelzebub 23,376]

It could be career defining but its interesting isn't it. The recruiters get no plaudits if they do well with pick 2 or 3 but it if they stuff it up the world knows about it. They mostly go for safety with the low picks - a bit like buying an IBM

who ?? lol

[ChaserJ 5,096]

Just to add to de goey from what I've seen, he is a great tackler, and I mean a great tackler. Very, very aggressive at the ball and the man. Played a lot around half forward with stints in the middle. Had an outstanding finish to the season after the champs. Kicks goals as well. Is a terrific half forward at keeping the ball in the forward line. He really did get better as the year went on.

Had some good stints at half back too.

Would compete with Lever for the title of most aggressive in this year’s draft pool. There’s a bit of Jack Ziebell in his game, though he may have a bit more pace. Not sure what Jordan’s endurance is like, it may be the area he needs to work on, but he may be on the next rung down from Brayshaw and Petracca in terms of midfielders this year.

[Qwerty30 196]

Pick 3 is a career defining one for Jason Taylor. I suppose they all are but this pick in particular stands to be the most difficult and contentious.

Whoever he takes his little boys are on the line.

The draft isn't what it was ten years ago, the top boys are hard to pick. He will earn every cent of his wage if he nails this one pick.

I would have thought both picks 2 & 3 are career defining for Taylor in a draft which is not regarded for stand out players at picks 1,2 &3.

[Pennant St Dee 13,173]

Sounds like it, building no forward line too just like Freo.

I would like you to explain how you know this, "Freo are buidling no forward line"

Review their recruiting of recent years and tell me how many times you saw Peel play last season

[Machsy 2,858]

Pick 3 is a career defining one for Jason Taylor. I suppose they all are but this pick in particular stands to be the most difficult and contentious.

Whoever he takes his little boys are on the line.

The draft isn't what it was ten years ago, the top boys are hard to pick. He will earn every cent of his wage if he nails this one pick.

That makes a good case for Lever then, bacause if he fails, it's likely that you could always blame injury...

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Good to see someone with a bit of credible inside sources instead of the 'My golf buddy said this so it means it true'' that says we are locked in at Lever or McCartin and no one else.

credible as in made up? Gees you are more gullible than i would gave expected. I can tell you now that anyone on the mfc payroll in recruiting broadcasting genuine information on our strategy would be marched in five minutes.

Edited November 11, 2014 by Norm Smith's Curse

[Norm Smith's Curse 2,602]

Pick 3 will not be a gamble that is for sure knowing how important the pick is and how much if a gamble it already is (like the pre draft articles describing Tapscott as a ball if muscle like Rich that would have immediate afl impact or Gysberts as the steal if the draft).

[Dee tention 616]

Pick 2 = Brayshaw (lock)

Pick 3 = McMartin or Lever based on media and majority opinion. My original Pick 3 was Lever.

If we are to go left field and I hope we do with Pick 3. I think Liam Duggan.

I believe Brayshaw & Duggan are the two safest picks and both will play 250+ great games.

I'm crossing my fingers for these two...

[chook fowler 19,459]

Interesting article about Liam Duggan in the Sun - wonder if he's on our radar?

[InVINCEable 358]

I would like you to explain how you know this, "Freo are buidling no forward line"

Review their recruiting of recent years and tell me how many times you saw Peel play last season

And how good is their forward line without Pavlich PSD?

[Ted Lasso 19,518]

Got told today that the saints are looking seriously at brayshaw

[whatwhat say what 22,757]

I don't think that'd be that big a surprise.

He looks ready-made and automatic best 22 midfield for sides such as ours and the Saints who lack both class and depth in the middle.

[Demons rising 52]

I have always wondered why if we are all happy with Bradshaw and tossing up other options ,why he did not figure highly for saints.

IT would then be interesting if we go petracca and then continue with the other endless pages of debate about our other choice

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,735]

I still think there's a chance the Saints will take Mccartin. In the picking comp on the website I went with Petracca at 2 and Brayshaw at 3 in the hope this happens.

[InVINCEable 358]

I have always wondered why if we are all happy with Bradshaw and tossing up other options ,why he did not figure highly for saints.

IT would then be interesting if we go petracca and then continue with the other endless pages of debate about our other choice

Because it's the Ollie Wines situation.

[Machsy 2,858]

Got told today that the saints are looking seriously at brayshaw

Hardly shocking.

Hell, only a few months ago there were posters lamenting the fact we wouldn't have a chance of getting Petracca.

But if the Saints are into Brayshaw, don't fool yourself; it hasn't only just happened.

[ManDee 7,148]

who ?? lol

IBM always one step behind HAL

[Davos 920]

Probably won't mean a lot to you all, but I remember watching Duggan play for St Pats as a year 10.

In a side that featured future AFL players such as Jake Neade, Dom Barry, Tanner Smith, Michael Close, Dallas Wilsmore and Matt Crouch, Duggan still caught the eye as the classiest player on the field. Anyone who saw the Herald Sun Shield final this year would've seen a young player with unbelievable ability.

Although it is unlikely, I would be fine with us taking him with pick 3.

[Bay Riffin 1,474]

Got told today that the saints are looking seriously at brayshaw

Makes sense. He and Petrecca appear the two standout midfielders, but Brayshaw has more exposed form as a pure midfielder. he looks a safe bet, but his pace has improved so much he looks like he could be a real weapon. wouldn't be surprised if Roos rated him number 1. so why not the saints.

you do wonder why the saints would still be deliberating. all the football, draft camps and interviews surely are done.

[Pennant St Dee 13,173]

And how good is their forward line without Pavlich PSD?

How good is Sydney's without Buddy, how good are the Cats without Hawkins, how bad is our midfield without Jones it's irrelevant Pav is still in their forward line and I think you may need to review Freo in 2013 and see how many games Pavlich played, their forward line functioned well enough then.

You said they were not building a forward line, sorry but they are and it will consist of Taberner, Apeness & a big gun they have in their sights with a shite load of salary cap room they have coming up, My mail is Walker is well within their sites. In regards to Taberner & Apeness I have seen them play at WAFL level and they are going to be good players not to mention having Ballantyne and Walters as crumbers .

Your post was an assumption and not based on any fact.

Freo drafted them for that purpose as a future plan and they are developing them appropriatley and as I said above they will not be the number 1 forward in 2016/17

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,829]

if

Got told today that the saints are looking seriously at brayshaw

If st Kilda go Brayshaw, would it be possible we overlook both Petracca and McCartin?

Edited November 12, 2014 by Bring-Back-Powell