The Trade/Draft Rumour Mill

[MadAsHell 4,088]

Now I know it's early for this and this one doesn't even involve our club but I just thought I'd post this as it's a pretty big rumor. Filth supporter mate of mine is the nephew of a current filth board member and he texted me this rumour this morning which is pretty big if true.

Collingwood & GWS allegedly already had early discussions about the following trade at seasons end"

Collingwood trade Swan, O'Brien & their 1st round draft pick to GWS.

GWS trade Patton, Adams & a third round pick to Collingwood

The theory behind this being that the money Collingwood save on Swan & O'Brien (mainly Swan) they can use to match any offers for Thomas as a free agent.

GWS by trading Patton would use pick 1 on Boyd giving them a forward line next year of Cameron, Franklin (who they're confident of getting) and Boyd as the 3rd tall/ruck.

My mate doesn't normally give away to much, so not sure if he was out on the sauce celebrating the win last night, but would be a huge trade if it happened. I know Buckley was apparently a big fan of Adams when he coached or mentored him at junior level or whatever relationship they had?

[Scipio 5,868]

Here's what I've heard, and make of it what you will...

Carlton are practically demanding a trade of Dunn, Strauss, Davis, Spencer and Bail for Murphy. They were also pretty annoyed that we couldn't throw Morton in there.

[ThreeOneSix 953]

If I was Collingwood and GWS, I'd do that trade.

It probably favors Collingwood a smidgen, but Swan and Harry O have the points on the board.

Also, they would be ideal to slot in that sides in addition to Franklin.

[Mickey 4,188]

Would surely make it difficult to retain youngsters, with so much cap space taken up by buddy, swan, Harry, $cully etc....

[rjay 23,970]

Swan with only one or two years left according to him, I couldn't see GWS going for it.

[ThreeOneSix 953]

Swan with only one or two years left according to him, I couldn't see GWS going for it.

If he doesn't gel with Buckley - as speculated - then he could go for it.

It makes sense for both parties, I actually like the trade.

Swan and Franklin are similar, they'd both be a good fit.

[The Yarra 83]

I doubt we'd be making anything more than enquiries until a coach is installed.

[MadAsHell 4,088]

Would surely make it difficult to retain youngsters, with so much cap space taken up by buddy, swan, Harry, $cully etc....

Thought that myself, unless of course the AFL pay a large slice of Buddy's and Swan's wage as promotional players. Coleman medalist & brownlow medalist?

[Whispering_Jack 28,025]

Now I know it's early for this and this one doesn't even involve our club but I just thought I'd post this as it's a pretty big rumor. Filth supporter mate of mine is the nephew of a current filth board member and he texted me this rumour this morning which is pretty big if true.

Collingwood & GWS allegedly already had early discussions about the following trade at seasons end"

Collingwood trade Swan, O'Brien & their 1st round draft pick to GWS.

GWS trade Patton, Adams & a third round pick to Collingwood

The theory behind this being that the money Collingwood save on Swan & O'Brien (mainly Swan) they can use to match any offers for Thomas as a free agent.

GWS by trading Patton would use pick 1 on Boyd giving them a forward line next year of Cameron, Franklin (who they're confident of getting) and Boyd as the 3rd tall/ruck.

My mate doesn't normally give away to much, so not sure if he was out on the sauce celebrating the win last night, but would be a huge trade if it happened. I know Buckley was apparently a big fan of Adams when he coached or mentored him at junior level or whatever relationship they had?

Massive win to Collingwood unless they throw in a set of steak knives to even it up.

All we need now is for Chilliboy to return to the fold and the next six months are going to be sheer bliss!

[demon-4-life 467]

I couldn't see Swan agreeing to leave personally.

[Tatu 416]

Just heard on channel 7, that the giants have declaired the number 1 draft pick is on the trade table..... Hmm? Are they saying that there going to tank to get the number 1 draft pick? How can they put a pick on the trade table, that they don't have?

[Lord Travis 10,231]

That trade in the OP won't eventuate as Swan won't move. He already stated he will retire in 1-2 years as he doesn't have a burning passion for footy. You'd think he'd rather retire than move to GWS for 1-2 years, so that trade won't happen unless they trade someone else in Swan's place.

It seems highly likely Buddy will end up at GWS under free agency. Here's hoping we can pinch Daisy Thomas through free agency or trade across a Craig Bird, Taylor Adams type with a late first round or early second round draft pick.

[jumbo returns 6,515]

Just heard on channel 7, that the giants have declaired the number 1 draft pick is on the trade table..... Hmm? Are they saying that there going to tank to get the number 1 draft pick? How can they put a pick on the trade table, that they don't have?

Very good point.

Having said that, they just got done by the Bullies by less than a goal.

Can't see them winning a game.

Over at Etihad, Norf are putting the Tigers back into 9th.

[Scipio 5,868]

Just heard on channel 7, that the giants have declaired the number 1 draft pick is on the trade table..... Hmm? Are they saying that there going to tank to get the number 1 draft pick? How can they put a pick on the trade table, that they don't have?

GWS would always have been putting their top pick up though. They desperately need some quality, experienced players. The last couple of years have been great for drafting potential stars but now they really need some older leaders.

[Scipio 5,868]

Very good point.

Having said that, they just got done by the Bullies by less than a goal.

Can't see them winning a game.

Over at Etihad, Norf are putting the Tigers back into 9th.

Nothing like watching Carlton and Richmond get hammered one day after the other, satisfaction!

[Crompton's the man 635]

Hawthorn FC site reports Lance Franklin's manager "very confident " he will re-sign with Hawthorn next year

[Scipio 5,868]

Hawthorn FC site reports Lance Franklin's manager "very confident " he will re-sign with Hawthorn next year

Probably read off a page of the exact statements that Scully's manager made.

[Dee-licious 1,859]

Usually I'd be skeptical about any rumours this time of year but I have been wondering what set Harry O off. Maybe this is it?

[Machsy 2,858]

Pretty sure I started the rumour that Buckley loves Taylor Adams on big footy a couple of years ago.

Based on a kid I worked with being good friends with him at school, who relayed the info that he was Buckley's pet when coaching the VC U/16 team. Always saying "do this, just like Tay does it."

Also during some brief half-time footage a few years ago to show Buckley's supposed state U/16 coaching "prowess" when still a media darling, he praised Adams multiple times.

[Theo 263]

After yesterdays game Adams may be looked at in a different light. Round arm punch to Cooney will get him weeks. Hot head.

[BAMF 3,787]

Chris Yarren is out of favour with new coach Mick Malthouse.

[General 35]

Anyone heard anything about Mitch Banner from South Freo? I'm from Melbourne haven't seen him play this year but I see his stats over the past couple of months have been consistent. High possessions and kicking goals. 23 years old.

[jazza 1,323]

Now I know it's early for this and this one doesn't even involve our club but I just thought I'd post this as it's a pretty big rumor. Filth supporter mate of mine is the nephew of a current filth board member and he texted me this rumour this morning which is pretty big if true.

Collingwood & GWS allegedly already had early discussions about the following trade at seasons end"

Collingwood trade Swan, O'Brien & their 1st round draft pick to GWS.

GWS trade Patton, Adams & a third round pick to Collingwood

The theory behind this being that the money Collingwood save on Swan & O'Brien (mainly Swan) they can use to match any offers for Thomas as a free agent.

GWS by trading Patton would use pick 1 on Boyd giving them a forward line next year of Cameron, Franklin (who they're confident of getting) and Boyd as the 3rd tall/ruck.

My mate doesn't normally give away to much, so not sure if he was out on the sauce celebrating the win last night, but would be a huge trade if it happened. I know Buckley was apparently a big fan of Adams when he coached or mentored him at junior level or whatever relationship they had?

funny, I heard a swan rumour also.

[Scipio 5,868]

Chris Yarren is out of favour with new coach Mick Malthouse.

Definitely, would be a really handy acquisition too. Provides good run and clean disposal from the back line.

Wonder what he'd be worth?

[jazza 1,323]

Definitely, would be a really handy acquisition too. Provides good run and clean disposal from the back line.

Wonder what he'd be worth?

take him and take him NOW