Rohan Bail

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

After being sidelined with concussion for a long time he returned yesterday only to be taken off the ground for a concussion test. He,his family and team mates must be concerned about what lies ahead. I dip my lid to you Rohan. You're not the best player and I have given you plenty over the years when it comes to your football skills. Yesterday you looked pretty sharp and had a crack all day. I will never ever question your endeavor.

[DeeSpencer 25,441]

I think the knock to the head obviously put a big concern over his day but before that (when the team was up and about) he was playing pretty good footy! Skills looked good for him as well.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I think the knock to the head obviously put a big concern over his day but before that (when the team was up and about) he was playing pretty good footy! Skills looked good for him as well.

I was quite impressed by his disposal and ability to resume his AFL career without a hitch. I really hope everything turns out well for him after his career health wise.

[Dee Dee 1,105]

I've met Rohan, seems a decent sort of bloke!

But he should leave while he still has a future.

Another blow to the head could really mess up his life!

[olisik 4,060]

We already lost bartram. Losing Ro would be a massive blow in terms of small defensive players. His probably one of the few players i have seen to not let being down in a game slow him in any way.

Really hope he pulls through

Edited April 14, 2013 by olisik

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

Walk away Rohan before you put your future at risk.

[Nasher 33,607]

Walk away Rohan before you put your future at risk.

My thoughts exactly.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I know concussion is still a work in progress from medical experts but I do hope if Rohan is seen to be in danger he will be told to end his career.

[machine11 142]

I know concussion is still a work in progress from medical experts but I do hope if Rohan is seen to be in danger he will be told to end his career.

shouldn't he have worn a helmlet like inb the old days?

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

shouldn't he have worn a helmlet like inb the old days?

The evidence that helmets help prevent concussion are inconclusive.

[Mono 455]

Bail's hardness, speed and competitiveness was on display yesterday. Be a big loss for mine if he has to retire. BUT your health is paramount.

[Webber 10,454]

The evidence that helmets help prevent concussion are inconclusive.

Actually they are conclusive.....they DON'T prevent concussion. They help prevent scalp and cranial injuries, e.g. lacerations and skull fractures. Concussion is a product of the brain 'sloshing' within the cranial cavity, which in turn is a product of the head coming to a sudden 'stop', generally termed 'decleration forces' such as with any of the hits we see that result in concussion. Helmets don't prevent this.

[mjt 640]

The evidence that helmets help prevent concussion are inconclusive.

Thats crap, shouldnt be allowed to play for the club again unless he wears a helmet, just another lawsuit headed MFC way.

[Webber 10,454]

Thats crap, shouldnt be allowed to play for the club again unless he wears a helmet, just another lawsuit headed MFC way.

Actually it's not crap. There is NO evidence, and that's worldwide, that helmets prevents concussion, and there's a reason. See my post above. The facts.

[Maldonboy38 6,390]

I hope he can continue. He has run and grunt and late in a game is still grunting and running.

But like I said to the woman in the crowd in front of me yesterday - I think Ro is done. He has suffered 5 (I think) concussions now.

[daisycutter 29,600]

according to the club (at least as reported) he didn't get concussion but a knock to the jaw area

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Agree with all the good will on this thread..

Happy to see Bail back...

[Dee Dee 1,105]

Actually it's not crap. There is NO evidence, and that's worldwide, that helmets prevents concussion, and there's a reason. See my post above. The facts.

I read an article many months ago in (I think) the Age suggesting that helmets of themselves did nothing to prevent concussion.

They certainly cannot prevent the brain bouncing around after a heavy knock to the head!

I'm sure none of us want to see Rohan end up like Daniel Bell!

[Undeeterred 3,118]

Thats crap, shouldnt be allowed to play for the club again unless he wears a helmet, just another lawsuit headed MFC way.

What a very compassionate response! Well done, champ.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,687]

Have always loved Bail's effort and persistence. Thought he was one of the best on Saturday.

Disappointed for him that he had to be checked for concussion during the game, but really pleased (1) that the club took the cautious approach and (2) with the new substitute rule which gave the club time to check before having to activate a permanent substitution which would have been unnecessary in this instance.

One small change is needed - the player being tested for concussion should be wearing a different colour bib on the bench (yellow, for example) so everyone can understand what's going on.

[rjay 24,852]

Have always loved Bail's effort and persistence. Thought he was one of the best on Saturday.

Disappointed for him that he had to be checked for concussion during the game, but really pleased (1) that the club took the cautious approach and (2) with the new substitute rule which gave the club time to check before having to activate a permanent substitution which would have been unnecessary in this instance.

One small change is needed - the player being tested for concussion should be wearing a different colour bib on the bench (yellow, for example) so everyone can understand what's going on.

That is a really good idea. An announcement was made that he was subbed off then I saw him in green and thought that we had stuffed up and someone lost the red one or forgot to put it on him. The announcement maybe should also state subbed for test or something like that.

[Young Dee 1,303]

Loved seeing Bail in that first half - he was great but after watching the Rohan Bail interview on the Robo show it just feels wrong (quite sad really). Hate to see him go but if it happens again I think he might be gone - there has to be a point where we put his well-being before the clubs.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/2013-04-12/the-robbo-show-round-3

Edited April 15, 2013 by Young Dee

[Forest Demon 4,681]

For those calling for him to retire, I think we should just let Rohan and the experts deal with that. Melbourne have taken a cautious approach and that is to be commended. I really liked his game on Saturday and have always seen something in him, so hopefully he can continue his career, and post career, unaffected.

[rjay 24,852]

It has to be a worry for Rohan and the club and I know there is no scientific evidence on the use of helmets but Paul Callery swears by it and it didn't hurt Gary Wilson. It's got to be worth a try if he's going to continue playing. As an ex player it's probably a good time for Paul and Rohan to have a chat.

[rpfc 28,249]

Happy he is ok.

It's his vocation and his decision.

And helmets will make it worse. They give you a false sense of security.