Oli or Jack

[Courtney_Fish 183]

Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

[My TD 156]

Bloody hell.

[Dr. Mubutu 697]

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Both drafted as inside mids with a hunger for contested footy. Both have good skills and endurance. One is Ollie wines the other has trained with a AFL club for 12 months and played VFL footy who is also the son of a champion. Hmmmm I wonder who I would pick?

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

Please, please, please not be serious.

Both haven't played an AFL match yet!

Ugggghhhh...i give up.

[rjay 24,178]

Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

??????

[Robot Devil 1,895]

Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

Trick question... We were always going to take Viney

The choice was between Wines and Toumpas.

Your question is faulty.... Faulty I tell you!

[Courtney_Fish 183]

Dr. Mubutu, LOL, At last someone who understnds me.

[CBDees 3,162]

Trick question... We were always going to take Viney

The choice was between Wines and Toumpas.

Your question is faulty.... Faulty I tell you!

Why not change the thread to RD's suggestion: Oli or Jim? Is suggest Wines for immediate impact however I have a sneaking suspicion that JT will turn out to be another Robbie Flower!

[stuie 7,374]

Can this troll be banned from starting threads? Seeing Ollie Wines isn't the son of a former player you are just showing your stupidity.

[Courtney_Fish 183]

Can this troll be banned from starting threads? Seeing Ollie Wines isn't the son of a former player you are just showing your stupidity.

So becuase Jack is the son of a former player, he is better?

[mjt 640]

So becuase Jack is the son of a former player, he is better?

No one knows, they havnt played a game yet.

[Gorgoroth 12,431]

Was this similar to the debate you had before posting?

Heroin or ice?

[DemonWA 3,630]

Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

FMD

Jack Viney was selected with a father son selection at 26.

A thead about who would be a better player (wines or viney) or weather we should have picked Wines & Viney over Toumpas & Viney would still be a waste of cyber space, but Would we have been better off with Oli Wines or Jack Viney?

there are no words!

[Pates 9,551]

Was never going to be choice between those two. Wines or Toumpas is the only relevant question, and given we had Viney in the bag there was no need to get Oli.

[DeeSpencer 23,637]

I'm pretty sure what the OP means is that Todd Viney has fathered both these boys and therefore we actually had the choice and did we pick the right one.

That's what you meant right?

Ridiculous.

[rpfc 27,673]

This is a joke right?

Because the decision to recruit Toumpas meant we couldn't get Wines.

[Chook 14,647]

Trick question... We were always going to take Viney

The choice was between Wines and Toumpas.

Your question is faulty.... Faulty I tell you!

Agreed. The real "dis or dat?" question (for those who ponder such hypotheticals) is between Toumpas and Wines, and at this stage I'd pick Wines (even though I still back Toumpas for best 1st year Melbourne player).

Edited March 11, 2013 by Chook

[DemonOX 8,559]

Really!!!!!

As someone has said before me, U cannot be serious.

Edited March 11, 2013 by DemonOX

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

So becuase Jack is the son of a former player, he is better?

No it's because as a father son we were able to pick him up at 26. You should be asking toumpass or wines. That is a valid argument.

[Pennant St Dee 11,751]

Was this similar to the debate you had before posting?

Heroin or ice?

LMFAO

[P-man 13,309]

Wines is gonna be a star though. We need to pinch him in a couple of years to complete the Viney & Wines fairytale..

[old dee 23,255]

I will let you know around 2016

[Nasher 33,246]

I was hoping this thread was going to ask me to choose between olisik and Whispering_Jack.

[DemonDan... 77]

Can this troll be banned from starting threads? Seeing Ollie Wines isn't the son of a former player you are just showing your stupidity.

Can THIS troll be banned from posting in threads? I mean, you show your stupidity in every post.

After your efforts for winning tool of the week in the 'gameday thread' a couple of days ago - you have the nerve to hark up at someone else?

Fool.

BTW - my pick of Wines as the best mid, inside / outside from the draft a few months ago.. wasnt too far off huh? You were in the process of disagreeing when we last spoke..

That was before you began slagging me off in other threads..

This is a joke right?

Because the decision to recruit Toumpas meant we couldn't get Wines.

I really think we messed up not taking all 3 (Wines instead of Hogan - then Toumpas and Viney) -besides the fact were short on mids,

its no good having an elite forward line if it doesnt get down there..

Lovin the 'Hulk', but for me - its mids, mids, mids..