WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - JESSE HOGAN

[Demon Disciple 11,802]

Who says he is the clear choice? HUN and Big Footy?

kevin sheehan, and i think he'd know

[Lil_red_fire_engine 10,881]

kevin sheehan, and i think he'd know

Kevin Sheehan said Tom Scully was the best number 1 in living memory (or something like that). Would you take Stephen Hill or Matthew Pavlich?

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

I'm pretty sure that Hogan put his hand up as a must for us to draft him today. 24 touches 10 marks and 4 goals.

[Dockett 32 1,238]

I'm pretty sure that Hogan put his hand up as a must for us to draft him today. 24 touches 10 marks and 4 goals.

How tall is he?

[ox_5 163]

How tall is he?

193cm and 91kgs

[Dockett 32 1,238]

193cm and 91kgs

The 91 kg part I like.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

The 91 kg part I like.

That is one of the main reasons why I want this kid. There will be no waiting around for him to bulk up he is already there. By the time he is in 20's he will nearly be 100kg's! That's a monster of a kid and he is mobile not a blob who sits in the square.

[BIG JIM 508]

That is one of the main reasons why I want this kid. There will be no waiting around for him to bulk up he is already there. By the time he is in 20's he will nearly be 100kg's! That's a monster of a kid and he is mobile not a blob who sits in the square.

Great point mate, we need men who are ready to go like Hogan.

Tex Walker number 2 bring him on.

Even Grundy in this years draft would be great if we dont get Hogan.

[Hannibal 5,814]

I'll be surprised if Hogan isn't 194cm by now and he was mentioned as that height in a recent Perth Now article.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

The only thing people need to remember is that the 91kgs isnt baulk muscle like Mitch Clark or Frawley. It will be alot more fat than AFL players and wont mean he is 91kg AFL strong. Yes it is a good base for now at 17 but will be more like 85 at AFL level imo. he still has a bit to owrk on before stepping up to AFL as an 18yo is all i am saying. But he has that year obviously.

[Matt Demon 1,407]

He's a bull and plays like a bull. People get so caught up on height & weight when the best thing about Hogan is he has an appetite for the contest. He reminds me a lot like Hurley just more agile and more speed.

[BAMF 4,171]

The only thing people need to remember is that the 91kgs isnt baulk muscle like Mitch Clark or Frawley. It will be alot more fat than AFL players and wont mean he is 91kg AFL strong. Yes it is a good base for now at 17 but will be more like 85 at AFL level imo. he still has a bit to owrk on before stepping up to AFL as an 18yo is all i am saying. But he has that year obviously.

True. But it's more his body size and shape that I like about him. He has that big build in the chest and upper legs. Means he is likely to become a Johnaton Brown / Barry Hall type shape once he has a few years in the system.

[rolly 149]

How old is this kid?

He would have plenty of time over the next 18months to lose 7kilos of "fat" and put back on 5kg of muscle...any excess skin folds he has currently would just be fuel for his body to burn while creating new muscle.

Hate the idea of giving GWS ANOTHER top 3 pick but it really does seem like this is the exact type of kid we need at the dees to help the climb back up the ladder

[Pennant St Dee 12,804]

I was there today and say take him, I wasn't previously sold on giving up one of our early picks but after todays display he looked very good hada presence and a bit of arrogance.

I watched Dayle Gartlett & Koby Stevens in the seniors &

Garlett

Did a couple of nice things, kicked a great snap that was class. Has quality but IMO lacks a high work rate and doesn't look to push himself. The Swans were able to get Jetta to lift his workrate and that may happen with Garlett, but something they need to sort out at interview

Stevens

Opposite to Garlett, high workrate but lacks polish, his disposal was good when he had space but butchered it a little when under pressure. Would not use a pick above the third round for him but his work ethic and intensity are positives

[Deers 202]

Question for all:

If we are forced to commit pick 3 to Viney, would you still consider trading (pick 4, no doubt) for Hogan?

[Roost It 1,434]

A forward line of Clarke Hogan Watts Howe, a midfield of Viney Jones Trengove Grimes Toumpas Wines and all of a sudden we're back in the competition

[rpfc 28,072]

Question for all:

If we are forced to commit pick 3 to Viney, would you still consider trading (pick 4, no doubt) for Hogan?

It's a good question.

I would, but I can understand those that would prefer to get a mid in the ND.

[olisik 4,060]

Players like Hogan are a dime a dozen. I still would go for him.

We have seen time and time again that mids can be developed from within. Beams is a perfect example of this, as is Barlow.

Power forwards on the other hand can't be in my opinion. They either have it or they don't.

Sadly our last few attempts to find one have failed as our recruiter was unable to determine the difference between having it or not.

Edited September 17, 2012 by olisik

[Guest KingDingAling]

I hope we get both Hogan and Martin.

But then again, I wouldn't complain with Toumpas and Wines or Stringer either.

[Lucifers Hero 39,035]

Hogan finished on 24 possessions, 10 marks, 19 kicks and 4 goals, plus 136 DT points.

As for not having the same physical advantage at AFL level ? He's not a slow bullocking key forward that is rag dolling skinny kids. He's a big agile aggressive key forward with excellent pace, who can also go into the midfield. His traits translate anywhere.

He's a gun and we must get him. Whatever it takes.

Sounds like another Buddy.

Just imagine our forward line with Clarke & Fitzy both who are 200cm and Hogan alongside, then Jones Howe, Viney & Blease feeding them? A few of our small forwards at their feet...swoon! Delicous thoughts

Where do we sign!

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Question for all:

If we are forced to commit pick 3 to Viney, would you still consider trading (pick 4, no doubt) for Hogan?

I say get him and Viney at all costs. There will be more mids to draft next year as well. We still get a mid in Viney but I realise we need more. As Many have pointed out a Hogan type of player doesn't come along too often. Mids have and always will be readily available in drafts.

[Dr. Gonzo 23,881]

Question for all:

If we are forced to commit pick 3 to Viney, would you still consider trading (pick 4, no doubt) for Hogan?

Based on what I've heard of him and the other kids available (haven't seen anything really) yes.

Players like Hogan are a dime a dozen.

Haha REALLY? Is that why we have only really had one (Neitz - and now two with Clark) at our club over the last 25 years (and probably longer). Midfielders are a dime a dozen, power forwards most certainly are not which is emphasised by you contradicting this point in the rest of your post.

[Pennant St Dee 12,804]

I hope we get both Hogan and Martin.

But then again, I wouldn't complain with Toumpas and Wines or Stringer either.

Just out of curiosity have you seen Martin play and I am not having a go just wondering.

And not talking about TV I am talking live.

I have doubts about his workrate and attitude, any doubts I had on Hogan were washed away yesterday. Spoke to someone involved with WAFL club and Doggies are into Hogan as well and will be chasing him through mini draft

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

The bidding for F/S happens before Trade Week.

Adelaide is a non-player here.

Worded it wrong- I meant that GC wouldn't be able to use pick 2 to bid on Viney or involve themselves in the MD, because they would have to give it to Adelaide.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Worded it wrong- I meant that GC wouldn't be able to use pick 2 to bid on Viney or involve themselves in the MD, because they would have to give it to Adelaide.

Off topic but is Tippet worth pick 2? would think GC would want change from this, Clark is as good a player and we got him for pick 12, yes it was unders for what he produced but is still very much not worth pick 2 imo.