On 28/03/2022 at 07:57, BAMF said:

Interested to hear about these Cap issues. We have signed our big name players to long term deals last year so I already assumed that we would be tight, but has there been anything further reported on our salary cap?

Jackson, Brayshaw, Sparrow and Spargo still out of contract I see.

 

Considering how well the Journo's went at guessing the players salaries, i'd definitely believe them about our cap issues.

He will sign 

  On 28/03/2022 at 06:48, Bang Bang Bang said:

Out of contract young superstar plays career best game over the weekend. Ralphy is a smart journo, this story was always going to fill the Monday papers but he doesn’t have much to go with. It’s mainly speculation at his end. 

Like most of Ralph's offerings he gives the impression he's telling you something while telling you absolutely nothing. He's wasted in the footy media. A highly successful career in public office has gone begging.

Luke's manager will be loving this. His young client's profile is being pushed further skyward and his value to Melbourne & all other suitors is appreciating by the week.

I hope he signs for MFC - in his own good time - for obvious selfish reasons but also for young Luke himself. I can't begin to imagine the pressure he'd be under should he return to WA. He'd be seen as a saviour & messiah and the scrutiny on his performance would be intense. The goldfish bowl over west is a hell of a lot smaller and contains fewer fish. Even for someone who appears as laid back as Luke, that would be hard to handle. There a quite a few cautionary tales about unhappy homecomings. He's still a very, very young man

  On 28/03/2022 at 08:56, Jibroni said:

He also said that our offer is $700 per year for 2 years. I would anticipate West Coast or Freo would offer more which makes it a big decision for the young man.

That doesn't sound right at all. Surely we would have put a longer offer in front of him, any money Ralph is guessing.

Tell him to talk to Hogan re: going home. 

  On 28/03/2022 at 10:36, CYB said:

Tell him to talk to Hogan re: going home. 

Why?

  On 28/03/2022 at 10:39, dazzledavey36 said:

Why?

Had bad time. Stay have good time.

  On 28/03/2022 at 08:11, Lucifers Hero said:

Ralph is assuming we have sal cap issues.  He may be right.  But it won't stop us signing Jackson (and Oliver) and I would guess they would follow the lead set by others and be reasonable.  The club will contract other players in order of priority.

If need be they won't renew contracts for Hibberd, Melksham and others.  And maybe trade out a few:  Harmes (2yrs to go on contract), Hunt ☹️(OOC this year) etc.  Some players may go for lack of opportunity.

The club would have planned for this several years ago.

Hope that is reassuring.

Thanks mate. Pretty much as I thought. I just thought I might have missed something a little bit more official than John Ralph guessing that our salary cap is tight.

  On 28/03/2022 at 03:38, Jaded No More said:

I highly doubt Jackson, who is 21...

He was a teenager in the GF and plays the entire year as a 20 year old.

  On 28/03/2022 at 00:27, John Crow Batty said:

He looks to be enjoying his football ATM. In career best form, giving a 100% and does not look like he’s bothered by the crystal ball gazing happening around him. Of course we have no clue of what’s in his head but I take it as a positive sign that it’s business as usual so far. Even if he decides to leave and the club knows about it he will play out the rest of the season because he can help deliver another flag. 

His next contract may well resemble a 'football ATM'!

Jackson needs to cut out the middle man and just request a trade to GWS

Jackson doesn't need media speculation or gossip to drive his price up - it's already sky high

But he'll sign and be paid well, very certain of that 

This discussion about the cap is an interesting one, we had a thread on trade targets where I had my go at who is getting paid what: 

I think that to keep Jackson and Oliver we are going to have to move on players in their prime who are role players - by definition they will attract a decent salary but their loss can also be covered relatively easily. 

So McDonald, Harmes, Hunt, Tomlinson, Spargo, and Weideman…

I refuse to consider trading ANB and Brayshaw due to the fact that they are more than just role players (which may also apply to Harmes), and Melksham and Hibberd are delisted in this scenario. 

The downside of having so many stars is the quick progression of Jackson causes problems.

  On 28/03/2022 at 09:58, Demons11 said:

He will sign 

Am hearing this too, will put pen to paper at some point. Just not sure what club yet. 

Edited March 28, 20223 yr by Ethan Tremblay

  On 28/03/2022 at 10:56, Hannibal Inc. said:

He was a teenager in the GF and plays the entire year as a 20 year old.

You are correct. I shouldn’t listen to Petracca who said he was 21. 

I am still hopeful the Luke Jackson stays with the Melbourne Demons.

He could get paid more elsewhere at West Coast or Fremantle. Although, we will pay him reasonably well too.

I am a bit annoyed at David Schwarz saying he is worth $1 million a season though! While Luke Jackson could be worth that much in the future. To say he is worth that now puts undue pressure on him and the club. Especially as we need to take into account that Angus Brayshaw's contract finishes at  the end of this season and I think Clayton Oliver's contract finishes next year or the year after.

However, if Luke Jackson wants to win more Premierships and create a Chicago Bulls or Los Angeles Lakers or Boston Celtics style dynasty at the Melbourne Demons (kinda like we did in the 1950s and early 1960s) then he will stay.

In the end, he will need to decide between money and extreme scrutiny as an individual or a bit less money and sustained team success.

My tip is he will re-sign with the Melbourne Demons. How long his contract will be I have no idea though.

Edited March 28, 20223 yr by Supreme_Demon

Don’t think he has any desire to return to Perth, but in the off chance he did now isn’t a bad time with both at the bottom they have the picks to at least compensate us well. Dees knew he and other young guns would be coming out of contract I’m certain we have allowed enough room to officer him a more than adequate contract, if there is any contract squeeze it will effect players like Brayshaw, Tomlinson and Hunt, or even someone like Sparrow and Rivers.

  On 28/03/2022 at 06:40, Dwight Schrute said:

The thing is, i am incredibly confident he stays, but if he did request a trade, geez they're going to have to give up a lot to get him. if Freo wanted him i'm demanding 2 first round picks and a player. 

West Coast, give us pick 1 and your 2023 first rounder. 

If WCE hold pick one why would they trade that to us plus a future first when he could walk to the ND and they just draft him with p1. 

 

  On 28/03/2022 at 10:02, Go the Biff said:

Like most of Ralph's offerings he gives the impression he's telling you something while telling you absolutely nothing. He's wasted in the footy media. A highly successful career in public office has gone begging.

Luke's manager will be loving this. His young client's profile is being pushed further skyward and his value to Melbourne & all other suitors is appreciating by the week.

I hope he signs for MFC - in his own good time - for obvious selfish reasons but also for young Luke himself. I can't begin to imagine the pressure he'd be under should he return to WA. He'd be seen as a saviour & messiah and the scrutiny on his performance would be intense. The goldfish bowl over west is a hell of a lot smaller and contains fewer fish. Even for someone who appears as laid back as Luke, that would be hard to handle. There a quite a few cautionary tales about unhappy homecomings. He's still a very, very young man

I heard sometime ago that Jacko's were uprooting their life and moving East so why would he sign with any "West" team ?

I'm putting this thread on ignore

  On 28/03/2022 at 11:36, Ethan Tremblay said:

Am hearing this too, will put pen to paper at some point. Just not sure what club yet. 

🤣🤣

  On 28/03/2022 at 06:45, Dr. Gonzo said:

He's not a FA - which club could satisfy a trade? WCE may have pick 1 this year, that would be a start.

Let's just say hypothetically GWS somehow bomb out this year and end up with a real high pick. Then on top of that someone like Steve Coniglio randomly requests a trade. Could a club like that one enter the frame? 

I know it's all 'choose your own adventure' at this stage but I just can't rule out the left field suitor. 

  On 28/03/2022 at 21:38, layzie said:

Let's just say hypothetically GWS somehow bomb out this year and end up with a real high pick. Then on top of that someone like Steve Coniglio randomly requests a trade. Could a club like that one enter the frame? 

I know it's all 'choose your own adventure' at this stage but I just can't rule out the left field suitor. 

Coniglio….???

Do you even football, bruh?!

Edited March 28, 20223 yr by Ethan Tremblay

If he decides to leave, can the club request his front tooth back?

Could somebody send me a PM when something actually happens with Jackson's contract?

Not interested in uninformed opinions, guesses, speculation, bed-wetting or shadow-jumping.