Jesse Hogan on the way out at Freo?

[Wobbly Bob 79]

Straight swap for Jackson.  #bringlukehome

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

17 minutes ago, FritschyBusiness said:

I don't think the environment back in WA has actually been ideal for him to succeed. It seems like fitness staff never got ontop of his injury, rushed him in and thats why he kept not performing at the level we saw.

They (FFC) were under a fair bit of pressure at the time. New kid on the block Bell saw the danger signs and tried to pull out of the trade, but the new president told him that the fans would crucify them if they let this once-in-a-generation talent slip through their fingers. subsequently, the urge to get him on the park at all cost must have been enormous.

 

17 minutes ago, FritschyBusiness said:

Imagine Hogan at FF taking the number 1 defender, leaving Weed with number 2 defender and Jackson playing on the wing or half forward to stretch their defence and chopping Max out in the ruck.  

I think he's an old fashioned CHF, best when roaming around, marking, linking up, the odd bit of ruck work, while snagging the occasional sausage roll himself. But it's all moot now as I think the footy world has seen the best of him.

[FritschyBusiness 1,463]

Just now, Mazer Rackham said:

They (FFC) were under a fair bit of pressure at the time. New kid on the block Bell saw the danger signs and tried to pull out of the trade, but the new president told him that the fans would crucify them if they let this once-in-a-generation talent slip through their fingers. subsequently, the urge to get him on the park at all cost must have been enormous.

 

I think he's an old fashioned CHF, best when roaming around, marking, linking up, the odd bit of ruck work, while snagging the occasional sausage roll himself. But it's all moot now as I think the footy world has seen the best of him.

Rushing him onto the field did more damage for sure, Freo were desperate at the time. 

He is very much suited at CHF, I Like Weed at FF yet it seems Tmac is playing deeper than him generally.
Hard to tell just from TV what exactly is happening with our gameplan.

Hogan is a huge talent that can play many positions when mentally healthy

[Yze_13 272]

17 hours ago, Anti-Saint said:

what about MOOOODeeerrrAAHHH .. Tony was on one leg?

And, Peter Bell went on to cap the Freddos?

 

Jason Norrish?

[jnrmac 19,908]

move on.

 

Look forward not back

[D4Life 2,405]

Would be very happy with him lining up at CHF today for the Demons!

Doubt the club would go for Hogan again, as many rumours when he left.

But would take him as a late first round or second round pick!

[titan_uranus 24,684]

If he's struggling to make it work at Freo (which seems to be rumours at worst), there's probably a bit too much going on in his life for him to be able to make it work back in Melbourne.

[Deefensive Language 124]

Is there something negative about the culture in Freo that's turning some guys off?

- Cam McCarthy seems to have a bit of bad blood

- Sam Collins was barely used despite promising form and now killing it on the GC

- Matt De Boer was mismanaged, delisted but remade at GWS

- Rumour has it Crozier was keen for the Bulldogs trade

[whatwhat say what 22,237]

please come back jesse, we need a forward who marks the ball

[DeeSpencer 24,808]

Croad, Tarrant....Hogan?

We could do with a CHB.

No interest in him as a forward, he's exactly what we don't need.

[Elegt 872]

not hogan; too many blokes in the current team are drinking their own bathwater and hogan does the same

[rjay 24,618]

...for a throw away pick in the 50's???

[DemonSam 171]

When he left I thought the messaging around it felt like the door was open.

Would be foolish not to put it out there... give them a late second rounder?

Is an instant upgrade in the forward line, was one of the big reasons we had a solid home and away in 2018.

Weed & the Hulk 2021!

[John Crow Batty 8,792]

Freo seem to be happier and improving since they cast aside McCarthy and sidelined Hogan. Frankly we don’t need the drama and negativity he will bring back to the club even for a throw away pick.

Edited August 24, 2020 by america de cali

[Return to Glory 8,250]

1 hour ago, rjay said:

...for a throw away pick in the 50's???

Absolutely

 

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

On 8/22/2020 at 1:11 PM, jnrmac said:

move on.

 

Look forward not back

 

Is that you David Brent?

[Ethan Tremblay 30,133]

1 hour ago, Pickett2Jackson said:

 

Is that you David Brent?

My hero. 

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,655]

Questions any club would have to ask:

• Can he play to the same standard as when he first started his career?
• Is his head in the right place? If not, will it improve if he comes to us?
• Is his body OK, in particular his troublesome foot? If not, will it improve if he comes to us?
• What will list sizes be in 2021 and beyond? Does that limit the number of "project players" (if he's considered to be a project player) that the club can have on their list?
• Could we use him or do we have his position adequately filled?
• Will his asking price fit comfortably within the salary cap?
• Is he worth the remuneration he asks for? 
• Could his pay packet end up causing other players to be aggrieved or even force them to leave to create space? If so, who would he effectively replace on the list? Would we want to lose that player?
• With this year's draft compromised by lots of father/sons and academy players combined with a lack of junior football because of Covid, is he a better prospect at the price to be paid (in draft picks) than what may be available in the draft?

Given none of us know the answers to any of the above, how can anyone say they think Melbourne should pursue him or not?

Edited August 24, 2020 by La Dee-vina Comedia
typo

[Redleg 40,242]

We let him go because he became a big problem.

Freo have discovered that he is still a problem.

Don't we have enough problems?

[KLV 1,762]

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

We let him go because he became a big problem.

Freo have discovered that he is still a problem.

Don't we have enough problems?

Correct, no way we’ll get him back 

[Wiseblood 24,637]

3 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

My hero. 

"And if there's one other person who has influenced me in that way I think, someone who is a maverick, someone who does that to the system, then, it's Ian Botham.  Because Beefy will happily say "that's what I think of your selection policy - yes I've hit the odd copper, yes I've enjoyed the old dooby, but will you p*ss off and leave me alone, I'm walking to John O'Groats for some [censored]!"

[Pates 9,625]

17 minutes ago, Redleg said:

We let him go because he became a big problem.

Freo have discovered that he is still a problem.

Don't we have enough problems?

I think one of the major problems was the “when will he go home?” It became a distraction for the club where players had to constantly trot out the usual line of “we love Jesse and we hope he stays a Melbourne player for the rest of his career”. You’d think if he were to return to us that would be one issue gone. 

The others are well publicised: attitude, off-field “interests” (won’t elaborate), and depression related issues which I have no doubt were cause mainly by the loss of his father, his own battles with cancer, injury issues, and being isolated from his family. 

He’s an older head now and perhaps like Bennell a change of scenery, but perhaps with familiar faces, could be of benefit to him. 

This is of course all speculation. 

Edited August 24, 2020 by Pates

[Half forward flank 1,022]

43 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

"And if there's one other person who has influenced me in that way I think, someone who is a maverick, someone who does that to the system, then, it's Ian Botham.  Because Beefy will happily say "that's what I think of your selection policy - yes I've hit the odd copper, yes I've enjoyed the old dooby, but will you p*ss off and leave me alone, I'm walking to John O'Groats for some [censored]!"

Invest in one or two diamonds in the rough each year. Why not that rather than a few journymen.

[rjay 24,618]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

We let him go because he became a big problem.

Freo have discovered that he is still a problem.

Don't we have enough problems?

One of our problems is a lack of talent.

I don't know if his issues are insurmountable but he does have talent.

[Redleg 40,242]

50 minutes ago, rjay said:

One of our problems is a lack of talent.

I don't know if his issues are insurmountable but he does have talent.

Yes he has talent.