I'll quickly put in a disclaimer at the start to say I'm not implying we should go for him, just more opening it up as something the club may consider.

Daniel Menzel is currently out of contract with the Swans as they try to balance things out for the impending Daniher trade.

I personally would be a probable no, but what are the chances the club looks at him given we could probably get him for cheap?

 

yeah not even a little bit of me would want this 

The position of a small forward has changed from the type of player he is. Now, small forwards also need to be high pressure players, as well as good crumbing forwards. He has ability, but lacks intensity to chase, tackle, and put pressure on the defense. There are plenty of players with lesser ability than him that get games because they're good pressure players first. It's a no from me.

I don't think there is a player I want less in this trade period than him.  

To me he is everything we don't need going forward.

[censored] no.

Pass

You want players who actually add tackling pressure and intensity.  This bloke is the complete opposite and one of the worst going around in terms of defensive pressure.

Next

Nuh Uh!

Add giph of the opening of The Twighlight Zone here

 Oh no 

Would’ve prefered Jamie Elliott.

I’d also offer Jeffy a rookie contract over Menzel every day of the week.

 

Edited October 8, 20195 yr by Ron Burgundy

No from me, but I can't see why we can't add Ben Ronke from the Swans. Then add Dan Butler and Jacob Townsend. It doesn't sound like we are trying very hard at all for much this trade period, definitely needs smalls and even a KPF.

?

Who has the most worrying hamstrings?

A. Menzel

B. Elliott

C. Ricky Barham

 

17 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Who has the most worrying hamstrings?

A. Menzel

B. Elliott

C. Ricky Barham

 

Me

Madness.

Big no. Still get a good laugh out of remembering him hitting the post from 5m out against us in the Elimination Final. Absolute spud

You would have to have rocks in your head to place him on your list.

1 hour ago, SFebes said:

No from me, but I can't see why we can't add Ben Ronke from the Swans. Then add Dan Butler and Jacob Townsend. It doesn't sound like we are trying very hard at all for much this trade period, definitely needs smalls and even a KPF.

Townsend and Butler are rotting away in the magoo's, be bold Dees and make a play for them.

We refuse to get quality small men that can tackle and have pace, but we will retain list cloggers such as Stretch,JKH, Wagner bros, Omac etc.

Edited October 9, 20195 yr by Win4theAges

42 minutes ago, dl4e said:

Madness.

2 minutes ago, Win4theAges said:

Townsend and Butler are rotting away in the magoo's, be bold Dees and make a play for them.

We refuse to get quality small men that can tackle and have pace, but we will retain list cloggers such as Stretch,JKH, Wagner bros, Omac etc.

Townsend is a scrubber. No thanks. 

8 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Townsend is a scrubber. No thanks. 

He's an upgrade on ANB and a few others though.

7 minutes ago, SFebes said:

He's an upgrade on ANB and a few others though.

No he's not.

No.

No, no, no.

NO.

too expensive for a casey player