I've moved on from yesterday!  We didn't go all the way but we had some very fine performances over the three weks. 

Interested in who people think was our Mr September (across all three games).

My votes are (in Brownlow style):

• 3   J. Viney
• 2   N Jetta
• 1  J Harmes

They were the most consistent - each had an exceptional game in at least one of the earlier finals and were the most likely to drag us out of the quagmire yesterday.  (Apologies to Weideman and T Mcdonald).

Edited September 23, 20187 yr by Lucifer's Hero

3: Ron Barassi

2: Brian Dixon

1: Hassa mann.

James Harmes for me.  Not only was he able to curb some of the best players in the game, but he also found his own footy and was damaging when going the other way.  He has turned into a very important part of our side and his improvement has been a joy to watch.

Jack Viney a very close second.

I would have said TMac before the game but he was a strong contender for WOG yesterday. 

Definitely Viney for me though. 

Viney

Not sure we really had one.

17 minutes ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Not sure we really had one.

Oliver by a mile. 3 excellent games from the kid who was great from day 1 of the finals despite close atention. Agressive and gave as good as he got . Hugely advanced his reputation and no stage fright for one so young. Yesterday he was our best.

My main criticism of Viney, gets it tries to break every tackle under the sun... Loses it and..

3. Viney

2. Chomp

1. Vandenberg

Harmes for me. Teams are going to focus on him a lot more next year. So hopefully he can deal with it.

Viney second.

Neville the Jetta 3rd 

Edited September 23, 20187 yr by layzie

Harmes in my opinion. Very good in all three games.

Razor Ray

3. Harmsy 2. Viney 1. Jetta

Joint for Harmes & Viney for me, everyone lowered their colours in the West Coast game.

3 Viney

2 Harmes

1 Jetta

28 minutes ago, Dees_In_October said:

3 Viney

2 Harmes

1 Jetta

Agree 

3 hours ago, Nasher said:

I would have said TMac before the game but he was a strong contender for WOG yesterday. 

Definitely Viney for me though. 

Pretty harsh on Tmac. Spent most of the prelim in the backline plugging holes and rucking. 

3 Harmes

2 Viney

1 Jetta

Harmes

TMac 

Viney

Jetta

I’d argue Mr September is a player that rises above their season form.

Viney and Oliver both incredible, but no more so than typical. Harmes and Brayshaw emerged in season. Trac is the player we all hope for.

1. Hibberd. Found the desperation.

2. Weid. The big surprise.

3. TMAC. First to stand tall.

11 hours ago, picket fence said:

My main criticism of Viney, gets it tries to break every tackle under the sun... Loses it and..

He is very overrated on this site. 

Harmes

Oliver

Jetta

18 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

Not sure we really had one.

On reflection and based only on the first two finals it was probably Weideman.

As No 10 says above my view of a Mr September is someone who goes to that next level.

I was hoping it would be Petracca who while having an okay first few finals didn't have that stellar lift in form.

Sidebottom at Collingwood and Martin last year are perfect examples of the elusive Mr September

 1 Jesse Hogan on my calendar 

Harmes.