FAREWELL CHRIS DAWES

[Coq au vin 754]

On 04/11/2016 at 1:55 PM, nutbean said:

nope - it's just an opinion like everything else. And my opinion is pretty clear - anyone can critique a player and posters will agree or disagree with it - when a critique respectfully highlights a players flaws or shortcomings or praises the players skills to the heavens there is robust debate on it. When a poster resorts to derogatory name calling or plain nasty send off's it usually gets called out and rightly so. It is unnecessary, adds nothing to the debate and leads me to believe that the poster may struggle to formulate a well reasoned response.. If you feel it is positive posting to write "good riddance" about a delisted player then don't be surprised if other posters call you out.  But hey that's just my opinion.

  

Ok fair points. 

However I reserve the right to have opinions that are not "positive posts". 

[nutbean 8,837]

16 hours ago, Diamond said:

Ok fair points. 

However I reserve the right to have opinions that are not "positive posts". 

You can say whatever you like but again, my point has nothing to do with positive or negative posting. My point has always been about respectful vs disrespectful posting and whether comments that can be labelled as plain nasty serve any purpose at all. Saying "good riddance" to a player serves exactly what purpose and furthers the debate how ?

My thoughts on a Dawes are hardly positive. He was drafted as a key forward who simply did not take enough marks, impose himself on enough games or kick enough goals. Judging his time with us it would not be considered a success. 

[Biffen 12,323]

At least we helped him and Stefan further their prospects in the law.

Lets hope he grabs his legal career with both hands.

[old dee 22,850]

2 hours ago, Biffen said:

At least we helped him and Stefan further their prospects in the law.

Lets hope he grabs his legal career with both hands.

Very nice Biff!

[DemonFrog 1,347]

3 hours ago, Biffen said:

At least we helped him and Stefan further their prospects in the law.

Lets hope he grabs his legal career with both hands.

But will he be an Essendon or Melbourne type lawyer ?

[AzzKikA 2,369]

3 hours ago, Biffen said:

At least we helped him and Stefan further their prospects in the law.

Lets hope he grabs his legal career with both hands.

Prosecuting with concrete evidence.

[DemonFrog 1,347]

On Monday, November 07, 2016 at 9:00 AM, AzzKikA said:

Prosecuting with concrete evidence.

Melbourne then?

[Coq au vin 754]

On 07/11/2016 at 6:18 AM, nutbean said:

You can say whatever you like but again, my point has nothing to do with positive or negative posting. My point has always been about respectful vs disrespectful posting and whether comments that can be labelled as plain nasty serve any purpose at all. Saying "good riddance" to a player serves exactly what purpose and furthers the debate how ?

My thoughts on a Dawes are hardly positive. He was drafted as a key forward who simply did not take enough marks, impose himself on enough games or kick enough goals. Judging his time with us it would not be considered a success. 

B$.  You wrote "If you feel it is positive posting to write "... I don't think it's positive. It's passionate. I stick by it. It doesn't have to be positive on a blog about one of the most unsuccessful football clubs of the modern era. I couldn't care less if you think it's classy or not. He was useless to us as a team. I don't believe all the press about his leadership qualities. Leadership in footy involves current ability on field. 

[nutbean 8,837]

15 hours ago, Diamond said:

B$.  You wrote "If you feel it is positive posting to write "... I don't think it's positive. It's passionate. I stick by it. It doesn't have to be positive on a blog about one of the most unsuccessful football clubs of the modern era. I couldn't care less if you think it's classy or not. He was useless to us as a team. I don't believe all the press about his leadership qualities. Leadership in footy involves current ability on field. 

Good for you. Just don't be surprised when posters call you out.

There is passionate and there is rude - and then there is passionate expressed rudely. Where exactly saying "good riddance" to a player delisted falls - well.. each to their own.

All the other stuff is opinion and all good. He was useless to the team  - he certainly did not produce enough on most occasions. Don't believe the press about his leadership qualities ? I disagree  - i think he was a leader  - an example was working with and mentoring the young forwards when he was out injured. Leadership in footy involves current ability on the field ? Yes - amongst other things. Leadership off the field, on the training track.. But most footballers who have good ability but don't display leadership stay on list. If you can get a footballer with both ability and leadership all the better. But as Dawes found out that a footballer with good leadership skills who cannot get on field enough and when on field doesn't produce enough wont last on a list.   

[Uncle Fester 2,835]

We got sold a dud. Then again with Harry. Benken is looking like that too

 

Oh well, the price of dealing with Collingwood.

 

Still they've now got Howe and Dunn

 

I guess the lesson is when you are getting beaten up you take whatever you can from a a better team. When you are on top they want yours.

 

Not being hard on Chris, but but we bought high and sold for nothing

[nutbean 8,837]

Like all trades - you trade and hope.

Some work and some don't  - Bernie Vince has been a win. Daniel Cross for free was a definite win.

I liked the idea of Dawes at the time but he has definitely been a loss.

"H" and Benken - "H" hasn't worked and Benken  - too early but on exposed form to date it looking less likely to be a win.

This year we have Melksham, Lewis and Hibberd - I am hoping for at least 2 out of these to work.

[jnrmac 18,954]

1 hour ago, Uncle Fester said:

We got sold a dud. Then again with Harry. Benken is looking like that too

 

Oh well, the price of dealing with Collingwood.

 

Still they've now got Howe and Dunn

 

I guess the lesson is when you are getting beaten up you take whatever you can from a a better team. When you are on top they want yours.

 

Not being hard on Chris, but but we bought high and sold for nothing

We didnt get sold anything. We recruited two ex-premiership players.

We knew their worth, we knew what they were capable of, we knew everything about them. We live with our choices. It's not the players fault (so long as they gave or give their all).

 

[old dee 22,850]

1 hour ago, jnrmac said:

We didnt get sold anything. We recruited two ex-premiership players.

We knew their worth, we knew what they were capable of, we knew everything about them. We live with our choices. It's not the players fault (so long as they gave or give their all).

 

I am no Dawes fan but he did IMO give his all. His failure was not due to lack of effort.

[beelzebub 22,225]

3 hours ago, jnrmac said:

We didnt get sold anything. We recruited two ex-premiership players.

We knew their worth, we knew what they were capable of, we knew everything about them. We live with our choices. It's not the players fault (so long as they gave or give their all).

 

Id actually argue we didn't...i.e  We thought, quite rightly possibly that what they might deliver was ...say  'X"  ...and  "Y"     we've at best got a fraction on either.. So as far as that goes..I reckon we've done extremely poorly.  Thats not a slight on the person(s) per se at all, just an evaluation of  the football equation.  Both seem quite decent blokes. For what it's worth.

 

Why are people so coy about calling anything for what it is, and just making apologies for  things that don't work out.. What is...IS... But what IS>>>IS !!!!

[nutbean 8,837]

2 hours ago, old dee said:

I am no Dawes fan but he did IMO give his all. His failure was not due to lack of effort.

That is why I will on occassion call out a poster. 

We can write lines on the failings of Dawes as a footballer. That's a reality. However, he, like 95% of other "failures" give it a shot but due to frail bodies, lack of ability, game going past them or just plain age are not a success. 

I understand why they are cut and in nearly all cases agree with the decision but giving them a kick up the ar$e on the way out is just so unnecessary. 

It's not passionate, it's not being a tough club that no longer accepts mediocrity - it is just plain nasty. 

[doc roet 1,199]

6 hours ago, Uncle Fester said:

We got sold a dud. Then again with Harry. Benken is looking like that too

 

Oh well, the price of dealing with Collingwood.

 

Still they've now got Howe and Dunn

 

I guess the lesson is when you are getting beaten up you take whatever you can from a a better team. When you are on top they want yours.

 

Not being hard on Chris, but but we bought high and sold for nothing

You can add Mark Neeld to that list from collingwood as well.

[xarronn 380]

Chris Dawes playing for Sorrento in 2017.

 

Don't know if this has been brought up before:

 

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/localfooty/mpnfl/sorrento-lands-prized-recruits-andrew-lovett-and-chris-dawes/news-story/4e9062fde039049ad1bbaddc18c04dd9

[Redleg 37,574]

4 minutes ago, xarronn said:

Chris Dawes playing for Sorrento in 2017.

 

Don't know if this has been brought up before:

 

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/localfooty/mpnfl/sorrento-lands-prized-recruits-andrew-lovett-and-chris-dawes/news-story/4e9062fde039049ad1bbaddc18c04dd9

Wish him well, nice bloke and injuries stopped him at Demons.

[Soidee 1,496]

On 22 October 2016 at 1:23 PM, stuie said:

Average AFL salary is 380k, the rumour was Dawes was paid 500k. Hardly call that "huge money" when taken in context.

Do you begrudge Trengove being paid by the way?

 

If you think 500K is not huge money in any context, then I suggest you spend time with a few billion less fortunate on this planet! Chris Dawes is not short of a dollar or 3

[monoccular 16,063]

On 10/11/2016 at 3:37 PM, jnrmac said:

We didnt get sold anything. We recruited two ex-premiership players.

We knew their worth, we knew what they were capable of, we knew everything about them. We live with our choices. It's not the players fault (so long as they gave or give their all).

 

Which Chris did, but.........

[jnrmac 18,954]

15 hours ago, Soidee said:

If you think 500K is not huge money in any context, then I suggest you spend time with a few billion less fortunate on this planet! Chris Dawes is not short of a dollar or 3

The context is AFL players, not the community. Wouldn't have thought that needed pointing out.

[Sir Why You Little 34,441]

Sorrento will be stoked to have the big man down there

Good Luck Dawesy

[barneymfc 152]

have been following this thread for awhile,sure he did not succeed but he tried.Went to sandy to watch him play you could not fault is endeaver

[Sideshow Bob 2,156]

4 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Sorrento will be stoked to have the big man down there

Good Luck Dawesy

Yes yes they are. The committee are over the moon, along with picking up Andrew Lovett as well 

[CBDees 3,162]

On 10/11/2016 at 3:25 PM, nutbean said:

Like all trades - you trade and hope.

Some work and some don't  - Bernie Vince has been a win. Daniel Cross for free was a definite win.

I liked the idea of Dawes at the time but he has definitely been a loss.

"H" and Benken - "H" hasn't worked and Benken  - too early but on exposed form to date it looking less likely to be a win.

This year we have Melksham, Lewis and Hibberd - I am hoping for at least 2 out of these to work.

We didn't fare too bad dealing with the Giants with Tyson, Frost, McKenna and Bugg!