Charlie Curnow

[RalphiusMaximus 6,102]

It seems that the club is absolutely set on who they want at three given the lengths they went to to get the pick. Consensus is that it'll be Parish. Despite his terrible highlights video most observers say that he really does have great disposal which is what we need more than anything. Personally I'd be thrilled if Curnow were to slip through to us at 7 but that doesn't seem to be on the cards. I can see him developing into a really good mid who can push forward and have an impact if a club wanted to take him in that direction.

[manny100 1,621]

I thought Parish but when we look at the list we one gun KFP, Dawes who is frequently injured and inconsistent and 28? next year, Pederson was was just given a one year deal - we all know what the next deal is!! No young KPF's coming through. I'm thinking maybe Curnow who can play 3rd tall forward and run through the midfield now and then.

[CBDees 3,167]

It seems that the club is absolutely set on who they want at three given the lengths they went to to get the pick. Consensus is that it'll be Parish. Despite his terrible highlights video most observers say that he really does have great disposal which is what we need more than anything. Personally I'd be thrilled if Curnow were to slip through to us at 7 but that doesn't seem to be on the cards. I can see him developing into a really good mid who can push forward and have an impact if a club wanted to take him in that direction.

If he doesn't slip through and (assuming we take Parish at #3) Curnow gets taken by Essendon, then, in all likelihood, we will have to chose between, Francis and Weidemann. Either Weidemann or Francis would similarly be a massive boost for us in the advent that we miss on Curnow.

I am disregarding GC as a threat as I am sure that they have an arrangement with us when we traded pick #6 for their #3.

[olisik 4,060]

If he doesn't slip through and (assuming we take Parish at #3) Curnow gets taken by Essendon, then, in all likelihood, we will have to chose between, Francis and Weidemann. Either Weidemann or Francis would similarly be a massive boost for us in the advent that we miss on Curnow.

I am disregarding GC as a threat as I am sure that they have an arrangement with us when we traded pick #6 for their #3.

Francis and Weideman may both also be gone by pick 7. Leaving us to choose between Milera, Oliver and Mathieson

[Frank Grimes 121]

If he doesn't slip through and (assuming we take Parish at #3) Curnow gets taken by Essendon, then, in all likelihood, we will have to chose between, Francis and Weidemann. Either Weidemann or Francis would similarly be a massive boost for us in the advent that we miss on Curnow.

I am disregarding GC as a threat as I am sure that they have an arrangement with us when we traded pick #6 for their #3.

Essendon have 2 picks and the current speculation is they will take whoever is left out of Parish and Francis, along with Weideman and Curnow, so I think it's pretty unlikely we will get to "choose" between Francis and Weideman, rather we will have the decision made for us if they are in fact the players we rate next.

Also remember we didn't know that we would have pick 7 when we made the trade with Gold Coast. So while it's possible we know who they are planning on taking with pick 6, I doubt there was an arrangement about who they would take as there would be at least picks 8 and 9 before our pick 10... not to mention, why would they do that for us when we clearly wanted pick 3 badly enough to make that trade without andy predications on who they used pick 6 on? Despite this, the fact that they were willing to trade down 3 places does make it seem as though they are interested in a bolter, like Milera.

Bottom line, I think Francis, Parish and one of Weideman/Curnow will be gone by our pick 7, with the possibility that all are gone. I personally hope that Essendon opt for Weideman and Gold Coast do something different and target a guy like Milera, leaving Curnow to fall to us.

[Gator 17,972]

As has been mentioned previously, Parish's "highlights": video comes from one bloody game.

[Axis of Bob 11,898]

Parish has a few little highlights here (about 5 mins in):

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-17/u18s-sos-jnrs-big-day-out

A few here (5:30):

https://www.facebook.com/FutureStarsTV/videos/vb.130437356973525/1180023382014912/?type=2&theater

Plus there's a full replay of Vic Metro vs Vic Country on afl.com.au (his first game back)

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q1

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q2

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q3

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q4

[What 18,810]

If he doesn't slip through and (assuming we take Parish at #3) Curnow gets taken by Essendon, then, in all likelihood, we will have to chose between, Francis and Weidemann. Either Weidemann or Francis would similarly be a massive boost for us in the advent that we miss on Curnow.

I am disregarding GC as a threat as I am sure that they have an arrangement with us when we traded pick #6 for their #3.

Francis and Weideman may both also be gone by pick 7. Leaving us to choose between Milera, Oliver and Mathieson

If I had to guess I would say that GC will take Milera at pick 6 as their projected Bennell replacement. They dont really need any more tall forwards do they?

[RalphiusMaximus 6,102]

Parish has a few little highlights here (about 5 mins in):

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-17/u18s-sos-jnrs-big-day-out

A few here (5:30):

https://www.facebook.com/FutureStarsTV/videos/vb.130437356973525/1180023382014912/?type=2&theater

Plus there's a full replay of Vic Metro vs Vic Country on afl.com.au (his first game back)

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q1

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q2

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q3

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2015-06-07/under-18s-vicc-v-vicm-q4

Much better footage of him in there than in the previous highlight package. Very nice kick on both sides.

[Frank Grimes 121]

If I had to guess I would say that GC will take Milera at pick 6 as their projected Bennell replacement. They dont really need any more tall forwards do they?

I agree, but it's possible they go for a big guy to replace charlie dixon

[Gator 17,972]

Isn't it time to ban this ^^ [censored] ?

[jötnar 25]

Isn't it time to ban this ^^ [censored] ?

Harsh!

[rpfc 28,906]

I am wondering why my posts mentioning vacuous fools keep disappearing.

I don't know, who are you referring to as that? It might give you the answers you seek...

[Mach5 4,768]

It seems that the club is absolutely set on who they want at three given the lengths they went to to get the pick. Consensus is that it'll be Parish. Despite his terrible highlights video most observers say that he really does have great disposal which is what we need more than anything. Personally I'd be thrilled if Curnow were to slip through to us at 7 but that doesn't seem to be on the cards. I can see him developing into a really good mid who can push forward and have an impact if a club wanted to take him in that direction.

I look forward to being amused as this forum is inundated with calls to draft Parish following the release of his highlights package.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,102]

I look forward to being amused as this forum is inundated with calls to draft Parish following the release of his highlights package.

I don't know which thread it's in, but someone posted a highlights package for him a few weeks ago that made him look like a soft outside spud who can't hit targets. His passes to the leading forwards were exactly what we see from the team already, either too long or dropping short. Nobody looking at that footage would have him as a first round pick. The footage posted above is far more impressive.

[Coq au vin 755]

Which player will be the next Lucas Cook? The draft is a lottery. All the so-called experts on here: what a joke! How many times have you actually seen any of these junior players play apart from a few highly selected highlights on YouTube and other highlights reels? At least the MFC seems to know what they are doing after many years of hopeless recruiting.

[Gator 17,972]

Brett Anderson once again said this afternoon he thinks the Dees will take Curnow at pick 3.

I don't know whether it is pure speculation or an educated guess with a bit more substance.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Brett Anderson once again said this afternoon he thinks the Dees will take Curnow at pick 3.

I don't know whether it is pure speculation or an educated guess with a bit more substance.

It's all guessing at this stage I suppose - educated or not. As I mentioned on another thread, I had very positive reports on Parish as a pick up but his size might be a concern. Curnow also has very good credentials but is a big lad and this could be the difference.

[Mach5 4,768]

Brett Anderson once again said this afternoon he thinks the Dees will take Curnow at pick 3.

I don't know whether it is pure speculation or an educated guess with a bit more substance.

BA usually doesn't have the early scoop, and he has an incentive to keep us guessing over the picks (as this is his bread & butter).

I'd be backing the early mail coming through (as it turned out to be correct) that MFC was chasing pick 3 from Gold Coast because they wanted Parish.

I just can't see our recruiters having a late change of heart due to a few highlights, like us plebs do.

[Gator 17,972]

BA usually doesn't have the early scoop, and he has an incentive to keep us guessing over the picks (as this is his bread & butter).

I'd be backing the early mail coming through (as it turned out to be correct) that MFC was chasing pick 3 from Gold Coast because they wanted Parish.

I just can't see our recruiters having a late change of heart due to a few highlights, like us plebs do.

You're going to respond to every suggestion until now and draft day that doesn't have Parish at 3, aren't you ?

[H_T 3,049]

BA usually doesn't have the early scoop, and he has an incentive to keep us guessing over the picks (as this is his bread & butter).

I'd be backing the early mail coming through (as it turned out to be correct) that MFC was chasing pick 3 from Gold Coast because they wanted Parish.

I just can't see our recruiters having a late change of heart due to a few highlights, like us plebs do.

The same case could be made for the likes of Curnow.....

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

One thing we've seem from this recruiting team is they haven't sprung surprises like that, i think we'll grab Parish at 3 and hope Curnow is at 7.

we fought off the temptation to grab Lever early,

imo Parish is to good to pass up at 3.

[Mach5 4,768]

You're going to respond to every suggestion until now and draft day that doesn't have Parish at 3, aren't you ?

Not at all.

But the impression I get is that BA is not on the money here.

The same case could be made for the likes of Curnow.....

I never heard this, only that we were after pick 3 for Parish.

I just can't see what Curnow has that would make us reach.

[Demon_JB 1,389]

Curnow will fall to 7. Essendon would be dead set keen on Weideman and there is no way they are drafting wideman and curnow at four and five. They will probably draft Francis and wideman, Gold Coast Milera leaving us with Curnow.

[DeeSpencer 26,273]

Curnow will fall to 7. Essendon would be dead set keen on Weideman and there is no way they are drafting wideman and curnow at four and five. They will probably draft Francis and wideman, Gold Coast Milera leaving us with Curnow.

If we go Parish then I think it goes:

Ess: Mid - Mathieson, Oliver. Maybe Francis or Milera

Ess; Fwd - Curnow or Weideman

GC: Milera or Curnow

Why do you think Essendon are so keen on Weideman over Curnow? If they plan on playing 2 rucks and Daniher then they won't want a 197cm forward, they'll want the more mobile option.

Similarly I think Milera is a Scotty Clayton special on the Gold Coast but he might have some reservation about a SA boy and whilst Peter Wright will make a nice Dixon replacement I'm not sure they have a 3rd tall forward option. Depends on how much faith they have in Sam Day.