Kurt Tippett

[grazman 6,610]

Rumours swirling around that Buddy's on the nose and not that popular with the playing group. Be very interesting if the Swans trade ban is lifted to see which way they swing - a very interesting cultural decision to be made.

[What 18,810]

Rumours swirling around that Buddy's on the nose and not that popular with the playing group. Be very interesting if the Swans trade ban is lifted to see which way they swing - a very interesting cultural decision to be made.

Good luck trying to trade Buddy with that toxic contract

[monoccular 16,326]

Rumours swirling around that Buddy's on the nose and not that popular with the playing group. Be very interesting if the Swans trade ban is lifted to see which way they swing - a very interesting cultural decision to be made.

But the trade ban is AFL policy : surely they would never make an off the cuff knee jerk decision on such an issue. Surely not?

:-)))

[beelzebub 22,271]

But the trade ban is AFL policy : surely they would never make an off the cuff knee jerk decision on such an issue. Surely not?

:-)))

never happen

[daisycutter 28,661]

But the trade ban is AFL policy : surely they would never make an off the cuff knee jerk decision on such an issue. Surely not?

:-)))

naah...............................yeaah (maybe)

[Biffen 12,398]

naah...............................yeaah (maybe)

the same thought process you go through after a sherry post tennis at Burwood on a Wednesday arvo.

In the end you ravage the yes vote like refugees on the Island of Lesbos.

[titan_uranus 22,725]

Anyone who watches football would.

I wouldn't.

I reckon Tippett's incredibly overrated. Benefits hugely from having Franklin there to make him the second forward.

Super slow, as bad a mark as Dawes, and nothing special around the ground.

I wouldn't be enthused by Tippett and I certainly wouldn't go near him at anything other than a very cheap price.

[What 18,810]

His salary vs output ratio would be one of the worst in the league

[grazman 6,610]

Use you're imagination. There are a number of rumours some of which are conflated so its hard to keep track, but in short Buddy has a number of issues to deal with and is perhaps persona non grata at the club at the minute.

Edited September 15, 2015 by grazman

[DeeZee 6,811]

I don't think Buddy would be silly enough to let a member of the public see him snort illegal substances at the races.

[jumbo returns 6,537]

What on earth does up the nose mean?

When I was a young 'un, I used to buy Wizz Fizz - great stuff, especially as the spoon came with a snap off imitation pirate ring.

Good times.

[Jaded No More 58,825]

No way would Sydney trade him, especially in light of Buddy's issues.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,572]

I wouldn't.

I reckon Tippett's incredibly overrated. Benefits hugely from having Franklin there to make him the second forward.

Super slow, as bad a mark as Dawes, and nothing special around the ground.

I wouldn't be enthused by Tippett and I certainly wouldn't go near him at anything other than a very cheap price.

Did you see his game on Saturday sans-Franklin? Did you see his 2012 season at the Crows? He is light years ahead as a second forward/second ruck option than anything we have or could really hope to get. I doubt we will get him so it's mainly a hypothetical argument but for a Melbourne supporter to turn their nose up at Tippett because we have Dawes, Fitzpatrick and an ageing Pedersen is frankly unfathomable.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Still think Horse is having trouble with Fwd line balance between Buddy and Tippett.

We would love that sort of balance. however a NO from me...

I can not see the excitement for Tippett !

I like his footy when he first came onto the scene way back with the Crows, but he went OFF... then eventually, went to Sydney, & to me he's done nothing... what is it I'm missing in the excitement for him ?

I admit I don't watch much anymore, but I don't hear or see any true excitement for this guy about his football. does he still have the desire for the game to achieve his original standard; or is he just after dollars. ?????

.

[dee-luded 2,958]

seems to be quite the scandal brewing, or should I say cooking,? right up there,,, Nth of us.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/sydney-swans-player-caught-in-3some-with-beau-ryan-lauren-brant.1111687/

[SaberFang 7,141]

He's not on indefinite leave for the epilepsy nor the seizures, but "mental illness."

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Rumours swirling around that Buddy's on the nose and not that popular with the playing group. Be very interesting if the Swans trade ban is lifted to see which way they swing - a very interesting cultural decision to be made.

The rumour I've heard about Buddy which, when it comes out (and I suspect it will), will probably blow up his engagement to JC (if she has a brain) and will really trouble the Swans and their addiction to having a decent club culture.

[grazman 6,610]

Another rumour associated with it is that media have the story but the Swans took out an injunction to stop it going to air (or more likely called in some favours).

[grazman 6,610]

The rumour I've heard about Buddy which, when it comes out (and I suspect it will), will probably blow up his engagement to JC (if she has a brain) and will really trouble the Swans and their addiction to having a decent club culture.

Ideally matched couple I would have thought. Narcism incarnate. So much for their no DHs policy. This is the same reason I don't want Bennell, highly talented player but someone with some pretty serious off field issues that has shown no inclination to do anything about it. For all intents and purposes a cultural time bomb.

Edited September 15, 2015 by grazman

[titan_uranus 22,725]

Did you see his game on Saturday sans-Franklin? Did you see his 2012 season at the Crows? He is light years ahead as a second forward/second ruck option than anything we have or could really hope to get. I doubt we will get him so it's mainly a hypothetical argument but for a Melbourne supporter to turn their nose up at Tippett because we have Dawes, Fitzpatrick and an ageing Pedersen is frankly unfathomable.

I didn't say Dawes or Pedersen were better options, but given the price that it would take to get Tippett, I wouldn't necessarily want him.

Yes he played well on the weekend, but I felt his 2015 (and 2014) were underwhelming. I'm not really sure his 2012 season for Adelaide is relevant much - Dawes had a good 2012 season for Collingwood too.

[Adzman 2,085]

Franklin signing has been nothing but a circus. If I was tippet I would be keeping my options open.

[Fat Tony 4,479]

Tippett is 29 next year. Why would we go after him given when we are still 2-5 years away from challenging? Picking up older players like Cross makes sense when they don't cost much in terms of salary cap and draft picks, but it makes no sense otherwise.

Besides, I still feel we would be better off playing Tom McDonald as a second ruckman. I thought he was good in the role against the Dogs when we were killed at Etihad. He can provide a reasonable contest in the ruck and is a mobile, marking threat around the ground.

Pederson was good in a number of games also.

[H_T 2,941]

Tippett is 29 next year. Why would we go after him given when we are still 2-5 years away from challenging? Picking up older players like Cross makes sense when they don't cost much in terms of salary cap and draft picks, but it makes no sense otherwise.

Besides, I still feel we would be better off playing Tom McDonald as a second ruckman. I thought he was good in the role against the Dogs when we were killed at Etihad. He can provide a reasonable contest in the ruck and is a mobile, marking threat around the ground.

Pederson was good in a number of games also.

The aim is for finals next year. That's what PJ, Roosy, Goodwin et al. have set the bar at. Players such as Hogan, Viney are intent on getting there sooner not later. I like that attitude. Sometimes players 29-33 are when they're playing their best football. Age doesn't concern me when 'challenging' is sooner rather than later. And sometimes these decisions actually help team performance in the interim rather than 'down the track.'

I agree with Pederson re: this season and last year. And I'd prefer McDonald down back for stability and am keen on Sam Frost and what he has to offer next year. My main concern is where Dawes is at in terms of output and our second ruck/forward option.

[juzzk1d 1,354]

Something very fishy going on with the whole Buddy ordeal..

[monoccular 16,326]

Something very fishy going on with the whole Buddy ordeal..

So. What is new? This deal has always been very piscatorial.

If Frankenstein doesn't play again then Tippett would become king pin up there and may want to stay.

Unless the entire no DH policy has collapsed since Roos left and BF was picked up on that ridiculous deal, in which case could there be a mass exodus?