Football 101

[dazzledavey36 54,343]

Who cares...? The kid made a mistake in a meaningless pre-season game. He'll learn from it.

No the mistake was the bloke calling for it.

If its true that it was Cross then its a poor error from him. Should have known better to direct him to go straight down the line.

[Biffen 12,940]

No the mistake was the bloke calling for it.

If its true that it was Cross then its a poor error from him. Should have known better to direct him to go straight down the line.

Yep.considering the inexperience of the kicker and the marking ability of the lead,the proximity of the opponents.

spot on.

[picket fence 17,073]

Yep.considering the inexperience of the kicker and the marking ability of the lead,the proximity of the opponents.

spot on.

[censored]! Good teams have multiple leads when in possession and good teams pick the right option!

Nup Not having it! Not the callers fault, the decision making of Viney was shizen in this instance!!

[dazzledavey36 54,343]

[censored]! Good teams have multiple leads when in possession and good teams pick the right option!

Nup Not having it! Not the callers fault, the decision making of Viney was shizen in this instance!!

The good teams also have good leaders to steer the ship and direct players and movement.

Clarkson has said many of times that Luke Hodge and Sam Mitchell are like playing assistant coaches out there. You only have to see them always yelling and directing play and teaching the young fellas good habits.

Its common sense when you know theres not much time left and your deep in defence your number one option to always hit towards the boundary.

[samcantstandya 1,045]

That's what happens when you recruit a lad because his Dad works at the club.

Lets face the truth, he is 5 feet 6, can't mark over his head, can't hit a target with either foot, can't kick further than 30 metres, and is slower than a snail, oh yeh he has a good try, that's redeeming, future of the club, laughable.

A bit harsh. Let's look at him at seasons' end. I reckon he will be ok.

[daisycutter 29,605]

if cross did call for it (and i'm not sure if he did) then both were in the wrong, but more so viney

it's footy 101 that even a 15yo would know

he better not do it again in a real game

[Wiseblood 24,637]

if cross did call for it (and i'm not sure if he did) then both were in the wrong, but more so viney

it's footy 101 that even a 15yo would know

he better not do it again in a real game

Or else what daisy? You'll put him in timeout for 15 minutes?

[chook fowler 19,447]

No doubt about the Dees - they still manage to find new ways of losing. Eventhough it was only a practice game incidents like that are confidence sapping.

Putting the Viney clanger aside losing to Essendons seconds does not bode well.

[daisycutter 29,605]

Or else what daisy? You'll put him in timeout for 15 minutes?

academic wiseblood. maybe i should have just said that that should have been a lesson he won't forget. let's hope so

[Red and Bluebeard 2,083]

academic wiseblood. maybe i should have just said that that should have been a lesson he won't forget. let's hope so

True. but I think we should be aware of 'last mistake syndrome'. There were plenty of clangers well before that, any one of which could have made a one-goal difference to the game. If we had been 4 goals up at the time,Viney's would still be bad, but probably not talked about anything like as much.

[Sir Why You Little 36,989]

True. but I think we should be aware of 'last mistake syndrome'. There were plenty of clangers well before that, any one of which could have made a one-goal difference to the game. If we had been 4 goals up at the time,Viney's would still be bad, but probably not talked about anything like as much.

But that is why you do not do it...Because we were not 4 goals up

We were in front by less than a goal..and the game was lost

[deespicable me 1,485]

I've thought for a while Vineys disposal isn't great so I'm glad its being highlighted so he can hopefully learn.

Earlier in the night he was at the ball drop and Salem was in front of him and instead of giving a quick handball up to Salem he just took possession and it ended in a ball up. He needs to understand his role in the team as a bloke who gets it and feeds it to the classier uses of the ball. He needs to help us generate spread but at the moment he isn't quite doing it.

I agree Jones who was good on Friday night has developed his disposal game well. Sam Mitchell who is not a great overhead mark or long kick is a similar build and hopefully role model for our Jack.

By the by I thought Tysons game on Friday night was similarly not so team oriented but for different reasons. We are still gelling as a team. Hopefully we have a season where we improve these things and don't just lose our way and end up playing as a bunch of individuals.

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

Turnovers (notice the plural) and fumbles killed us, not any one particular play.

I agree Viney messed it up, but he was one of many in the last half. We had more than enough chances to win the game. And it's better JV learns that in a nothing practice match than in one that has 4 points riding on it.

On Viney: he reminds me of a young Chunk. The Jones boy loved grabbing the ball and trying to crash packs in his first couple of years. Beat one, beat two, get caught HTB on the third. And as he matured he understood that he wasn't a big kid among little kids anymore, he was a big kid playing against big men. And so he adapted. Jack will do the same.

[jackaub 1,402]

Btw who was Viney actually kicking it too??

Cross!

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

If jack Viney turned into a Nathan jones I wouldn be over the moon!

[beelzebub 23,313]

If jack Viney turned into a Nathan jones I wouldn be over the moon!

you wouldnt be alone

Im sure JV will indeed develop. Hes had a lot put on his plate. That plate needs to be cleared somewhat and better 'teachings' heaped upon it..

That stuff up what a call back to the dark ol days ...of panic football. They need to be banished

[Mad_Melbourne 877]

[censored]! Good teams have multiple leads when in possession and good teams pick the right option!

Nup Not having it! Not the callers fault, the decision making of Viney was shizen in this instance!!

Cross in the leadership group, calling for the football where he ran into the spot and sat there instead of continuing his lead is worse than a player in his third season looking to a leader and giving it to him.

That said the kick was loopy and thus it was the execution that was a bigger issue, if viney had stabbed the pass through the issue would not be spoken about, or had cross continued to lead back to the square allowing for us to bring it out the other side it would not have been spoke about either.

[beelzebub 23,313]

Cross probably had a brain fade and went bac in his mind to when a team mate could kick a ball...and more than 30m

[hardtack 10,517]

If jack Viney turned into a Nathan jones I wouldn be over the moon!

If Jack Viney turned into Nathan Jones, the sound of the impact would be heard over several city blocks!

[Akum 2,660]

I've thought for a while Vineys disposal isn't great so I'm glad its being highlighted so he can hopefully learn.

Earlier in the night he was at the ball drop and Salem was in front of him and instead of giving a quick handball up to Salem he just took possession and it ended in a ball up. He needs to understand his role in the team as a bloke who gets it and feeds it to the classier uses of the ball. He needs to help us generate spread but at the moment he isn't quite doing it.

I agree Jones who was good on Friday night has developed his disposal game well. Sam Mitchell who is not a great overhead mark or long kick is a similar build and hopefully role model for our Jack.

By the by I thought Tysons game on Friday night was similarly not so team oriented but for different reasons. We are still gelling as a team. Hopefully we have a season where we improve these things and don't just lose our way and end up playing as a bunch of individuals.

Good post. IMO the fact that we are still gelling as a team - and still have a long way to go - is our main problem.

Which, by the way, is a slight negative (far outweighed by the positives, but a negative nonetheless) of making wholesale changes to the list year after year.

I think Roos' main priority has been to try to settle the various parts of the team - midfield, attack & defence - even if it means limiting the amount of experimentation he can do. That's why he's kept the selection fairly stable, which means the guys like Bail & Matt Jones & McKenzie have been selected for all three games, despite struggling.

He would probably prefer to bring the likes of Brayshaw & Stretch into a settled "gelled" midfield than into one which was still scrambling for everything.

Edited March 23, 2015 by Akum

[Tony Tea 2,806]

Why would an AFL football even consider kicking across the face of goal deep in defence?

Players will make mistakes when under pressure, tired or when rushed but what Viney did should never happen.

The idea of kicking across the face of goal should not even enter his mind. It's like suddenly deciding that drinking battery acid is a good idea, it just should not ever happen, especially from a free kick with no pressure.

What year is this: 1962? Footy has changed.

[beelzebub 23,313]

What year is this: 1962? Footy has changed.

and yet the ball is still oval, theres still 18 per side and rule 101-25-para-B says never kick it to the opposition in front of the goals !!

The more things change, the more they stay the same

[Sir Why You Little 36,989]

I will always be a nervous wreck when the ball is kicked sideways in defence!!

Late in the game when scores are close can cause premature death!!

Look for the same loose man up the ground for christ sake!!

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

When you have seniors like Grimes and Garland constantly kicking backwards and sideways setting the example you can't blame 3rd year players for following that example. The scars from years of having to defend against superior forward presses and carrying too many passengers remain. WYL was spot on, and the sooner we move most from "186" on, the better!

[Moonshadow 17,675]

If jack Viney turned into a Nathan jones I wouldn be over the moon!

No you wouldn't, I like to be on top.