WATTS, SHORT CIRCUITING OR NOT?

[old dee 23,048]

I watched Jack amble around the ground tonight with no intent or desire to enter the contest.

I've come to the conclusion he is incapable of changing and no matter how many weeks he spends at Casey it won't be enough, he is simply not up to the task.

I doubt any other club would want him so we won't even get a trade for him and he will probably have to serve his time out at Casey. He is as soft as any footballer I've ever seen, if he watches the replay of tonight's game, he will be embarrassed by his lack of effort.

Spot on Robbie I said earlier in the week we should trade him but who give anything.

The last two weeks we have effectively played one short.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I watched Jack amble around the ground tonight with no intent or desire to enter the contest.

I've come to the conclusion he is incapable of changing and no matter how many weeks he spends at Casey it won't be enough, he is simply not up to the task.

I doubt any other club would want him so we won't even get a trade for him and he will probably have to serve his time out at Casey. He is as soft as any footballer I've ever seen, if he watches the replay of tonight's game, he will be embarrassed by his lack of effort.

People in the crowd were actually laughing at him as he just wandered around.

[3Dee 1,153]

arms length tackler

[old dee 23,048]

Lazy footballer.

All I have herd about is his record breaking sprint at the draft combined but we never see him use it.

His style of play remind me a little of Travis Johnston to be honest.

TJ is so far ion front of this bloke he could not hear the band

[KingDingAling 3,623]

The crowd cheered when Watts got the ball.

I think that sums up Watts.

I think the fans have had enough, they've all decided Watts is done.

Mentally, it will be hard to come back from, you're own club think you are a joke.

Watts has to fight, there is no other way but to grit your teeth and fight.

Personally, I see no future for Watts or Trengove, neither have aggression.

[rjay 24,067]

Enough of this JW stuff, he is not playing good footy and maybe he can't. His mate at WC was laughable today also if that gives anyone some satisfaction.

These JW threads are getting like the Col Silvia ones. Col was never good enough, maybe (a strong possibility) Jack isn't either. Time will tell but all this hand wringing goes nowhere.

[binman 39,129]

TJ is so far ion front of this bloke he could not hear the band

TJ is so far ion front of this bloke he could not hear the band

Spot on and i've said before comparing the two atm is an insult to trapper.

From Wikepedia:

In 2002 he finished equal fourth in Brownlow Medal voting, and in 2005 he won his first Melbourne Best and Fairest Award, the Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Medal, and he led the AFL in total kicks.

Johnstone gradually developed into a midfielder possessing terrific vision and skill, who in 2006 for the second year in a row, led the team in the Brownlow Medal, with 11 votes. During the year he accumulated 469 disposals at 21 an outing, which included first for inside 50s (87) and third for rebounds from 50 (55), and was also 5th in tackles (77).

[rjay 24,067]

The crowd cheered when Watts got the ball.

I think that sums up Watts.

I think the fans have had enough, they've all decided Watts is done.

Mentally, it will be hard to come back from, you're own club think you are a joke.

Watts has to fight, there is no other way but to grit your teeth and fight.

Personally, I see no future for Watts or Trengove, neither have aggression.

You're way off the mark with Trengove. The suspension he got from the Dangerfield incident had a big impact on him, he was hung out to dry by the AFL and the club should have really put up a fight for him. He was badly let down.

He will put his head down and get involved, injury has held him back and I hope he can get back on the park fit and well, he will be a bonus next year if he can.

[Carlos Danger 380]

Watts must go back to Casey. No intensity. No will to contest.

Again he is a basketballer.

Pendlebury seamlessly made the transition from basketball to AFL, I really hope someday Watts can do the same.

[pineapple dee 2,892]

In the first 20 minutes of round one, I looked at Watts and thought 'this guy might be an elite distributor of the ball with some real upside'. Tonight he provided nothing of value to the team unless you count guarding space, making half hearted leads or looking for soft possessions valuable. How frustrated must Dawes Viney Cross and Jones be with his lack of fire and agression. Give someone else a game who would kill to get the ball to a team mate. Enough !!!!!!!

[richyrich 44]

Pendlebury seamlessly made the transition from basketball to AFL, I really hope someday Watts can do the same.

Dont take any odds. $1.01 wouldn't be short enough for Watts! Hang the bloke out to dry, delist him. I am over watching soft players. Terlich, Howe, Watts leave...please...for all our sake!

[old dee 23,048]

Pendlebury seamlessly made the transition from basketball to AFL, I really hope someday Watts can do the same.

If it is not there after five years it never will be.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,637]

Enough of this JW stuff, he is not playing good footy and maybe he can't. His mate at WC was laughable today also if that gives anyone some satisfaction.

These JW threads are getting like the Col Silvia ones. Col was never good enough, maybe (a strong possibility) Jack isn't either. Time will tell but all this hand wringing goes nowhere.

Meanwhile they continue collecting paychecks and we continue to watch their rubbish week after week.

This is pro sport, if you can't handle the heat then [censored] off.

[ILLDieADemon 804]

TJ is so far ion front of this bloke he could not hear the band

I agree m8, TJ was a very good player.

I ment TJ is the type of player WATTS could become like if he actually had more determination to play better.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,637]

Pendlebury seamlessly made the transition from basketball to AFL, I really hope someday Watts can do the same.

Please can we stop with the Pendlebury comparisons, they are just plain embarassing. Pendlebury was recruited in 2005 and by 2010 had won a flag and was one of the premier midfielders in the comp. By 2014 he is captaining his side and is in the top 5 players in the comp.

Watts was recruited in 2008 and by 2014 hasn't done anything.

[Carlos Danger 380]

If it is not there after five years it never will be.

Tonight's effort was as rubbish to me as it was to you, I don't think I've ever seen a player handball backwards as much as Watts did tonight.

Point being of all people to be getting in his ear every week, Roos is the man. I'm still optimistic this will potentially lead to something.

[SaberFang 7,141]

Can we please get Jack the hell off the Demonland banner and replaced with Dawes or Crossy or Dunn or Pederson or JKH or anyone in the team who actually plays like an AFL footballer?

Edited April 26, 2014 by Lamashtu

[ILLDieADemon 804]

Spot on and i've said before comparing the two atm is an insult to trapper.

From Wikepedia:

In 2002 he finished equal fourth in Brownlow Medal voting, and in 2005 he won his first Melbourne Best and Fairest Award, the Keith 'Bluey' Truscott Medal, and he led the AFL in total kicks.

Johnstone gradually developed into a midfielder possessing terrific vision and skill, who in 2006 for the second year in a row, led the team in the Brownlow Medal, with 11 votes. During the year he accumulated 469 disposals at 21 an outing, which included first for inside 50s (87) and third for rebounds from 50 (55), and was also 5th in tackles (77).

Like I said in the quote above.

TJ is the type of player Watt could become like if he tried a bit more.

[baysidedave 246]

Enough of this JW stuff, he is not playing good footy and maybe he can't. His mate at WC was laughable today also if that gives anyone some satisfaction.

These JW threads are getting like the Col Silvia ones. Col was never good enough, maybe (a strong possibility) Jack isn't either. Time will tell but all this hand wringing goes nowhere.

with you on this, i get sick to death of all the armchair critics sitting at heir typewriters telling people how Watts or Trengove or whoever are not up to it, the bloke along with about 5-6 others in the team are playing with no confidence. I know Watts and Trengove can play because l've seen it. I was there tonight and l hated what l saw with Watts but he is totally out of form and needs a run at Casey not to be judged by toerags who really have no right to judge AFL footballers.

[Dr. Gonzo 22,637]

with you on this, i get sick to death of all the armchair critics sitting at heir typewriters telling people how Watts or Trengove or whoever are not up to it, the bloke along with about 5-6 others in the team are playing with no confidence. I know Watts and Trengove can play because l've seen it. I was there tonight and l hated what l saw with Watts but he is totally out of form and needs a run at Casey not to be judged by toerags who really have no right to judge AFL footballers.

If you don't want to read people analysing the footy then I think you're on the wrong forum.

[praha 10,372]

I actually felt sorry for him tonight.

14 minutes into the final quarter, AFL members wing. He is able to get his opponent under the ball, pushes out into space and runs onto the ball. With a paddock ahead of him, and Frawley and Dawes deep, he actually doubles back: he had no one in front of him, but for whatever reason doubled-back into the opponent. He's able to push aside the opponent and get some space again, but then kicks it straight into them.

The balls goes out of bounds, the supporters in the vicinity jeer and yell, and Jack throws his head down.

It was a sad, sad sight. That is a young man completely shot of confidence, and clearly not quite up to the task of AFL footy: he either lacked the confidence to run and carry, or simply panicked and looked back into the corridor for the handball. It was a frustratingly silly decision, and indicative of the club's struggles in going forward all year.

But Jack epitomised it better than anyone.

Gotta feel for the kid. But the VFL beckons. He is not AFL standard. Potential gets you so far. I'm getting sick of people saying he is "talented". Having a nice kick and side-step does not make you a good AFL player. The fundamentals required to win contests and put your team in a better position are things he really struggles with. Salem managed to do it twice in one quarter of football.

He may struggle to play 150 games. He is second-rate.

Edited April 26, 2014 by Cudi_420

[P-man 13,277]

Is playing like someone yet to sign.

Afraid to tackle and be tackled. Absolutely useless atm.

[Pipefitter 2,042]

Not only is he not worthy of being drafted no 1, at the moment it's baffling he was even drafted at all. This guy is not a footballers shoelace.

[frankie_d 1,410]

He does look completely lost in the mid field, and plays like he has no feel for the game. We've tried him up forward, down back and now in the middle.

I think it's all over and the major challenge is how to manage his contract.

He's had five years and Salem did more in five minutes.

Edited April 26, 2014 by frankie_d

[monoccular 16,443]

Round 1 against an undermanned Saints he was impressive but as each goes by he becomes more exposed.

Just wondering if there is any coincidence in the fact that JW had a pretty good game against the Saints and seemed to be going in harder than ever before (albeit off a low base), then Alex McKinnon broke his neck the following Monday, and JW has ever since reverted to his old very timid self? Do we have a team psychologist anymore?