Cameron Pedersen

[Machsy 2,858]

NB. I defended him early in the season based on his preseason form, against a torrent of Pedersen-hate.

I'm not one to take pot shots at players for the hell of it.

It's something I've noticed on multiple occasions in recent weeks, and I just hope it doesn't become a strong trend.

[DeeSpencer 23,689]

I can only imagine we ran out of interchanges, which if so was a potentially costly mistake.

Cam's doing a good job in his role, and as many have said on here, Roos is all about role players in a team.

We've been consistently low so don't think so. Just part of Jamar's timed breaks to get him off towards the end of quarters but they need to put him on even if a forward comes off and then swap him in play with Pedersen. Can't be defending the crucial last 3 minutes of the 3rd quarter without your starting ruck to bottle up the contests.

[jumbo returns 6,619]

He's not absolutely 100% selfish at all times.

But I've noticed him make selfish decisions.

Don't take it to heart.

Never do, M, never do.

Edited May 4, 2014 by jumbo returns

[praha 10,575]

Not the first time Demonland has been wrong.

I also hope it's wrong about Spencer, Jetta, Toumpas and Watts. And I think it will be.

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

NB. I defended him early in the season based on his preseason form, against a torrent of Pedersen-hate.

I'm not one to take pot shots at players for the hell of it.

It's something I've noticed on multiple occasions in recent weeks, and I just hope it doesn't become a strong trend.

Congratulations.

[Machsy 2,858]

Congratulations.

Well Sherlock, it's relevant for those who seem to think I'm targetting Pedersen due to some sort of preconceived notion he is a spud.

Jog on x

[Elusive Tunbridge 795]

Well Sherlock, it's relevant for those who seem to think I'm targetting Pedersen due to some sort of preconceived notion he is a spud.

Jog on x

Wasn't having a go at your defence of Pedersen, because I agree. It's the self-justification/self-congratulation I was commenting on. I'll jog on now.

[thaipantsman 180]

Your thoughts on Pederson?

I thought he was ok in 2013. If you ignore the head ducking incident of round 1, he was a decent servant for us in 2013. Provided good depth and had no dramas getting possessions and contested marks in defence. Got some coaches awards votes in the second GWS game. Can take a contested mark either forward in back.

I think Pederson is underated around here and should provide solid depth next year.

Pederson is a terrific example how Roos has brought the best out Low to middle tier players. He could be the next Steven Icke or Anthony Ingerson and provide support for McDonald. Hopefully Garland back soon and under Roos he too will be a significantly improved player...I hope.

Just a thought. Given the clubs losses with Clark and Hogan how do we think Big M Might go up forward swapping around with Chip? I recall the days Biffo went forward frequently and often with great success. While Biff cleared with searing torps with kick outs he also was a dead eye dick drop punting from 40 M out.

Final comment. Great to see Viney just ripping the opposition apart. lets hope Jimmy T can do the same.

[thaipantsman 180]

Not the first time Demonland has been wrong.

I also hope it's wrong about Spencer, Jetta, Toumpas and Watts. And I think it will be.

"demonland"...has a variety of opinions but mostly pretty conservative.

[Machsy 2,858]

Ok, a current example.

1st quarter, about 3min to play.

Crows player marks and Pedersen stands the mark as the player backpedals.

JKH about 5-10m from Pedo on one side of him, another crows player runs past Pedo unmarked about the same distance away on the other side of him.

JKH motions and tells Pedo to follow the running player, and JKH will come over to man the mark, a standard defensive switch.

Pedo ignores JKH.

JKH has to run around Pedo and make up 15-20m on the running crows player.

It's little things, but it happens.

I hope it is ironed out of his game, because he's either not very smart, or he's not very team-oriented.

Working hard both ways is great, but it doesn't mean he always works hard for his teammates.

I see an element of self-preservation is his "playing personality" rather than a whatever-it-takes-to-get-the-win mentality.

[jazza 1,323]

Ok, a current example.

1st quarter, about 3min to play.

Crows player marks and Pedersen stands the mark as the player backpedals.

JKH about 5-10m from Pedo on one side of him, another crows player runs past Pedo unmarked about the same distance away on the other side of him.

JKH motions and tells Pedo to follow the running player, and JKH will come over to man the mark, a standard defensive switch.

Pedo ignores JKH.

JKH has to run around Pedo and make up 15-20m on the running crows player.

It's little things, but it happens.

I hope it is ironed out of his game, because he's either not very smart, or he's not very team-oriented.

Working hard both ways is great, but it doesn't mean he always works hard for his teammates.

I see an element of self-preservation is his "playing personality" rather than a whatever-it-takes-to-get-the-win mentality.

great example,ive seen many times at all clubs.

ive also seen it at local level,some players just dont follow the game in that respect,all good blokes but it doesnt come natural to them.i dont have a problem with pedders because he supplies other things to the team.

but that example can be shown mant times over with every club in the league.

i can also show you examples of other players in the league including our team that make fundamental mistakes.

every player has a downside,and needs to repair some aspects of thier game.

maybe you have a needle against this bloke.

same as i have one against JW.

[Machsy 2,858]

That's also not to say he's the only one guilty of this example, or that he does it every time or won't change.

But it's something that needs to be ironed out of the side.

[Moonshadow 16,647]

Really liked his guts backing into that marking contest in the 2nd qtr (??) to cut off an Adelaide attack. Got crunched big time and then fronted up to contest a stoppage bounce. That took a lot of courage and got a fair bit of praise from his team mates. Hope he keeps up the improvement.

[Machsy 2,858]

It was right at the end of the 1st.

Yes, very impressive, and for that alone I'd keep him in the side.

[Satyriconhome 10,094]

Ok, a current example.

1st quarter, about 3min to play.

Crows player marks and Pedersen stands the mark as the player backpedals.

JKH about 5-10m from Pedo on one side of him, another crows player runs past Pedo unmarked about the same distance away on the other side of him.

JKH motions and tells Pedo to follow the running player, and JKH will come over to man the mark, a standard defensive switch.

Pedo ignores JKH.

JKH has to run around Pedo and make up 15-20m on the running crows player.

It's little things, but it happens.

I hope it is ironed out of his game, because he's either not very smart, or he's not very team-oriented.

Working hard both ways is great, but it doesn't mean he always works hard for his teammates.

I see an element of self-preservation is his "playing personality" rather than a whatever-it-takes-to-get-the-win mentality.

Oh right, so he's making sure the players doesn't play on and doesn't hear the call from JKH above the 40000 baying in the crowd, do you actually watch to enjoy the footy...or never made a mistake in your life.......

[Machsy 2,858]

Oh right, so he's making sure the players doesn't play on and doesn't hear the call from JKH above the 40000 baying in the crowd, do you actually watch to enjoy the footy...or never made a mistake in your life.......

Nope, plenty.

It's just a trend I've noticed in his play.

No need to take it personally.

[Bay Riffin 1,434]

Nope, plenty.

It's just a trend I've noticed in his play.

No need to take it personally.

Yes its a fair point and maybe when Roos is saying they are coaching at 80%, its some of these things they may leave for now so they can teach blokes like Pederson, running patterns, blocking, where to position, all the big basics they don't know how to do.

It's a feather in Roos cap this bloke has improved when almost everyone on demonland had written him off completely.

[P-man 13,353]

I would've loved it so much had he kicked that goal from the forward pocket after the big don't argue. Spoilsport boundary ump.

[monoccular 16,707]

He certainly seems very willing to take on whatever is asked of him. None of this "that ain't my role" stuff.

For his size his ruck competitiveness is a revelation.

Well done Cam.

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

Definitely the best game by Cam.

I now have a lot of confidence that those stupid errors won't raise their heads again.

He does have that hard body we have been after.

I really hope his past two weeks suggests the penny has fallen.

Keep up the good work Cam.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Definitely the best game by Cam.

I now have a lot of confidence that those stupid errors won't raise their heads again.

He does have that hard body we have been after.

I really hope his past two weeks suggests the penny has fallen.

Keep up the good work Cam.

again?

when the team is on the rocks & a new player comes in to the club that no supporter wanted, & the players were all unhappy & unfocused, how then does a new player get the confidence & support to automatically feel secure enough, to be able to 'focus' to the level of backing into oncoming packs.

He stopped the ball on that occasion, even if he went one handed at it.

most here had transferred they're anger they felt over the two 2012/13 seasons, onto Pederson. last year was like a witchhunt. the guy had no chance... now he is showing his true abilities, under a new footy dept, with a united footy list, & club.

he always deserved more respect, than the muck he copped last year.

[1964nowMORE 463]

Good on him. Seems pretty simple though.

Give a physically strong and athletic footballer the structure, instruction, feedback and confidence he requires and look out. The boy has many skills capable of performing at AFL level. Is he any better or worse than LRT or Ted Richards! I wouldn't have thought so, and they both looked good with a premiership medal hanging off them.

Roos is clearly one of a small group, maybe 4-5 "elite" coaches who are capable of achieving greatness. He will prove a lot more than Pedo over the coming years. Right now I bet the Tigers wish they had one of the 4-5 not one of the mainstream capable.

Things are looking up, now we see the boys play with confidence, look out Bulldogs.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

Definitely the best game by Cam.

Seems that get's said every week now.

[Binmans PA 26,766]

Oh right, so he's making sure the players doesn't play on and doesn't hear the call from JKH above the 40000 baying in the crowd, do you actually watch to enjoy the footy...or never made a mistake in your life.......

Calm down. Every time someone has some constructive criticism, it isn't necessary for the white knight to ride in. M was merely pointing out his observations, which he was well within his right to do, and you had to come in and make it personal. Get off the high horse and accept that our players can improve aspects of their game. Further, we the supporters, are quite right to observe these trends and demand improvement. No one is saying improvement is impossible, just that for the team to improve past second last, we need to, as M put it, 'iron out' these flaws in our game.

[Webber 10,181]

Seems that get's said every week now.

It does, and about Matt Jones, Rohan Bail, Dean Terlich. The reality is that most reckon they're stopgap players at best, when in fact they've all held their spots with aplomb so far this season.