Dylan Shiel

[dazzledavey36 48,980]

Why are people still bringing up Adams when he has CLEARLY said Melbourne is not in his destinations list. We were never going to get him and never will.

[Mgdee 319]

Just like we were never going to get Roos

[Axis of Bob 10,266]

It'd be a big call, GV.

I'd certainly give away pick 2 for Shiel. Actually, I'd add a sweetener if it got the deal done. Shiel is quality. Aish is also quality, but Shiel is mature and we know he can do it in the big time.

If Shiel is contracted, we might need to give a little bit extra to get the deal done.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

It'd be a big call, GV.

I'd certainly give away pick 2 for Shiel. Actually, I'd add a sweetener if it got the deal done. Shiel is quality. Aish is also quality, but Shiel is mature and we know he can do it in the big time.

If Shiel is contracted, we might need to give a little bit extra to get the deal done.

Put yourself in the shoes of GWS. Shiel has come to you expressing an interesting in heading back to Victoria. His manager informs you that Melbourne has put forward a very lucrative contract offer. You don't want to keep an unhappy player and see this as an opportunity to either get a mature player or spread the demographic of your young picks. What would you ask for? And what would you settle for?

[Dee Fan 3,247]

under no circumstances will tmac be traded. Far too important. Can think of about 20 blokes I would send first

Can we send them all at once?

[Axis of Bob 10,266]

I think GWS would be looking for the flexibility of pick 2. They could use pick 2 to trade on to other clubs for players that they'd want.

I think that McDonald's value to us would be higher than GWS, purely from an off field/culture POV. I don't think that they'd be happy to do a swap of McDonald for Shiel.

From a Melbourne perspective, I would do the deal. I love McDonald, but I think that the ceiling of Shiel is far higher as a damaging, goal kicking midfielder is far higher. The problem is that I would find it very hard to release a really good person from our club when we are trying to build a strong culture.

If I was GWS I would be asking for Frawley.

[Demon Jack 6,340]

Pick 2 for Shiel.

Maybe Jetta as sweetener.

[titan_uranus 22,618]

I think GWS would be looking for the flexibility of pick 2. They could use pick 2 to trade on to other clubs for players that they'd want.

I think that's probably right. If McDonald is the best we can/are willing to offer them, then they're probably more likely to want Pick 2, which will open doors to other clubs and other players which probably exceed McDonald's worth.

[Machsy 2,858]

Pick 2 for Shiel.

Maybe Jetta as sweetener.

I wouldn't call that a "sweetener."

I'd call that a "bitterer."

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,945]

Having McDonald made the transition easy when Rivers departed. He and Chip are both required to play on the big men, Garland again showed this year his flexibility to play on a number of differant types of players effectively. These three down back plus our forwards being fit are crucial to us being competitive. Now if Watts is in the midfield he's on a wing with Toumpas on the other so the Swans can stick their offer. I haven't seen a lot of Shiel but if he's good to go lets get him. We can become more competitive quicker than most think.

[demonoid 317]

https://twitter.com/9newsmelb/status/387116246635782144

[Gorgoroth 12,331]

I hope we get him and a pick or exchange of picks so our pick 20 goes to 13 or what ever their mid pick is.

Screw em over!

[What 18,810]

https://twitter.com/9newsmelb/status/387116246635782144

OH BABYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,945]

https://twitter.com/9newsmelb/status/387116246635782144

https://twitter.com/9newsmelb/status/387116246635782144

not big on the tweet, what was said please?

[Wiseblood 24,636]

https://twitter.com/9newsmelb/status/387116246635782144

Interesting. Talks starting means there will probably be more to it than just Pick 2 for Shiel but it's a positive start. I'd be very happy adding him to our midfield.

[Goodvibes 3,596]

You would assume "talks starting" really means we've been talking to Shiel's management for some time and we've offered him a pretty attractive contract and now it's a matter of whether GWS is prepared to let a contracted player leave.

[beelzebub 22,255]

Fabulous...but... are they really that dumb lol

[demonoid 317]

not big on the tweet, what was said please?

from Clint stay away saying that Melbourne and gws have begun Talks over shiels

[Wiseblood 24,636]

from Clint stay away saying that Melbourne and gws have begun Talks over shiels

Ha ha!

[demonoid 317]

Ha ha!

didnt notice the auto correct. Not intentional but quite funny

[rpfc 27,590]

Hope it's true and we can get something done.

Throw in Miles or Bugg...

I am greedy.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Hope it's true and we can get something done.

Throw in Miles or Bugg...

I am greedy.

If we got greedy and GWS bit I'd love Bugg. Reckon he could really add something to our list.

[Jerry Lundergard 388]

from Clint stay away saying that Melbourne and gws have begun Talks over shiels

Clint is a big Demons supporter too I believe. Maybe he got a little scoop.

[dazzledavey36 48,980]

Just like we were never going to get Roos

Completely different scenario Mgdee. Roos didn't rule out coaching all year and actually chatted to us and showed intrest.. Adams Wants nothing to do with us at all. There are 5 clubs that are his preferred destination before Melbourne so highly doubt he will get through to 5 clubs before coming to us. Get this through your head if he doesn't want to even speak to us DONT bother with him then..

[ucanchoose 1,804]

Guys it was just a bit of fluff to fill up the sports news section

NOTHING TO SEE HERE!!!!!!!!!!