Neeld on Insider

[beelzebub 22,297]

Goddard will go to Fremantle if he leaves St. Kilda. Cloke's off to Carlton. Boak's off to Geelong, and Caddy's off to either Essendon or North Melbourne..

I'm forecasting an underwhelming trade period..

theres a certain undeniable logic to all of that. What it says to me is we arent looking at whom Neeld is.

All of these are somewhat linear ideals and I have my thought that Neeld is quite lateral whe it comes to who he wants to do what he deins.

We may all well be quite surpised by who end up lobbing on our doorstep. I cant think who personally.

What we rent privvy to but the club will be is who ( players ) has put feelers out . Everyones looking at the FA list but before FA there was just the field...its sill there.

I fess up. Im fascinated by the lead up to the preseason. Its like a multi dimensional game of chess that morphs as you play

[wattsup 470]

true. It would be tough for them to do a deal. North might be better placed...I'm sure we could do a deal that would satisfy GC if he chose to return to Melbourne, but all reports suggest he has his heart set on Essendon.

Perhaps someone should tell him we have a three game winning streak against them..

well if his heart is set on essendon he is in for some dissapointment, cant see who essendon would give up

[Dr. Mubutu 694]

well if his heart is set on essendon he is in for some dissapointment, cant see who essendon would give up

The Weapon.

[Guest King Cuthbertson]

theres a certain undeniable logic to all of that. What it says to me is we arent looking at whom Neeld is.

All of these are somewhat linear ideals and I have my thought that Neeld is quite lateral whe it comes to who he wants to do what he deins.

We may all well be quite surpised by who end up lobbing on our doorstep. I cant think who personally.

What we rent privvy to but the club will be is who ( players ) has put feelers out . Everyones looking at the FA list but before FA there was just the field...its sill there.

I fess up. Im fascinated by the lead up to the preseason. Its like a multi dimensional game of chess that morphs as you play

Well, I think you're probably right there. The David Mackay offer really came from left field. No-one saw that coming. I thought it was a terrific play, and i'm disappointed he didn't take the offer. I'm sure they're working really hard behind the scenes going after not just free agents, but all manner of uncontracted players, and also players in top sides who are just on the periphery, who could play a role for us..

It will be interesting. No one thought we'd get Mitch Clark, so who knows what might turn up as the trade deadline approaches..

[Guest King Cuthbertson]

well if his heart is set on essendon he is in for some dissapointment, cant see who essendon would give up

Well, Essendon tried to pull off one of those BigFooty type trades last year for him, by bundling up excess stock in the hopes that GC would be bamboozled by numbers. If we trade 5 of our injury prone duds for your young star...that'll work huh??? I think it involved Hooker and Gumbleton from memory.

GC didn't wan't a bar of it obviously.

Edited August 28, 2012 by King Cuthbertson

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

Well, Essendon tried to pull off one of those BigFooty type trades last year for him, by bundling up excess stock in the hopes that GC would be bamboozled by numbers. If we trade 5 of our injury prone duds for your young star...that'll work huh??? I think it involved Hooker and Gumbleton from memory.

GC didn't wan't a bar of it obviously.

Don't be too quick to bag Gumby. He might wind up playing for us next year :D

[Guest King Cuthbertson]

Don't be too quick to bag Gumby. He might wind up playing for us next year :D

That's if he doesn't snap in half before trade week. Seriously, he's the kind of character who would get run over by a bus while enjoying a picnic in the Botanical Gardens..

We have enough of those already.

[olisik 4,060]

experienced players btter not be more B grade hard working mids. Iv said it once and i will say it again, I will have a fit if we give up draft picks or big coin for B grade midfielders who work hard.

[diesel 420]

Caddy will stay at GC.

[IRW 1,270]

Well, it doesn't mean we can't have a crack.

We got Mitch Clark, so who knows...

Bet you MFC wouldnt get him if he'd watched them play in 2012 first.

How about buildng a team with what they've got,the early draftpicks, plus one or two promising young imports to grow along with the list.

Its crazy I know, but it just might work

[Moonshadow 16,398]

Please tell me he didn't say anything about reality checks!

Or reality bus or 7 day goggles......

[Hardnut 327]

How about buildng a team with what they've got,the early draftpicks, plus one or two promising young imports to grow along with the list.

Its crazy I know, but it just might work

At last, someone who is thinking - as long as our recruiters are up to it.

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

That's if he doesn't snap in half before trade week. Seriously, he's the kind of character who would get run over by a bus while enjoying a picnic in the Botanical Gardens..

We have enough of those already.

True, but he wouldn't cost all that much, he's not a first choice player at the Bombers, he's had years in the system and he's finally starting to show a bit. I'd give them a third round pick for him quite happily. Maybe thrown in one of our tradeable players as well.

[beelzebub 22,297]

It will be interesting. No one thought we'd get Mitch Clark, so who knows what might turn up as the trade deadline approaches..

This goes to the heart of it in a way. All this was done almost off the cuff and with simple dumb determination ( dumb in this instance simply meaning blind -faith style ) So given a good time to think about things and plan , who knows who is on the radar.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Trade month & draft day will be busy.

If it aint Cloke is it Goddard??

We have the war chest.....

Well now it seems confirmed that we're not chasing Cloke

Oh No, what will Clarkey do now, all on his lonesome > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cviMM02_ixI

We'll just have ta find some Mids now, won't we? Send out the Lynch Mob ! Pronto.

[Redleg 38,021]

there is no way caddy is going to essendon they have nothing to give i think our pick 13 would get the deal done

Might be part of a three way deal. Keep Tippett in mind.

On the other hand, could Crows get pick 2 from GC and use it on Grundy?

[rjay 24,038]

After reading the many posts on this site and listening to some (a lot) of the media stuff I was getting concerned with how we were looking to rebuild the club.

Listening to Neeld restored a bit of faith that he has the right approach, what that really means is he has an approach that I agree with, let's hope it is the right one. No Cloke as a quick fix, thank ... that was a beat up and use our early draft picks to get the best young talent. If the right player is available then go after him. It's going to be more of a build from within approach with a top up along the way.

I think there will be a fair turnover of our list at the end of the season, up to 10 players could go but I don't think you will see us being as active during the trade period as many do. The draft and list development will be our way forward.

[angrydee 842]

Don't forget that a number of rookies will be upgraded as well.

[thaipantsman 180]

don't get too excited or depressed at this stage. Neeld's keeping his hand close to chest and throwing out some red herrings in the process. Just the way the game should be played.

[monoccular 16,385]

So, other than no David Cloke and son, what else did he reveal?

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Is Cloke not part of our plans or are we not part of his?

[MadAsHell 4,089]

Well, I think you're probably right there. The David Mackay offer really came from left field. No-one saw that coming. I thought it was a terrific play, and i'm disappointed he didn't take the offer. I'm sure they're working really hard behind the scenes going after not just free agents, but all manner of uncontracted players, and also players in top sides who are just on the periphery, who could play a role for us..

It will be interesting. No one thought we'd get Mitch Clark, so who knows what might turn up as the trade deadline approaches..

Has David Mackay signed a new conract with Adelaide?

Would love it if we could get him to rotate off half back and through the midfield.

Was thinking we could try and secure him through a three way deal that would of seen Stef Martin go to the filth as has been rumored.

[rjay 24,038]

Is Cloke not part of our plans or are we not part of his?

It seems that Cloke has never been a part of our plans despite all the media and Demonland speculation.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Probably boring when compared to the recruiting discussion about Cloke, Boak, Caddy etc - but it'll be interesting to see who we pick with our rookie selections this year.

Who are the good VFL, SAFL, WAFL players that we might target? For instance, Zorko looks a ripper for the Lions (I know he wasn't a rookie, but he seems to be the type of player that can be unearthed through the rookie draft).

I've heard Mark Hutchings from West Perth is a likely lad (character, ability etc). Others have obviously been mentioned as good rookie prospects too.

I used to find the rookie draft to be a bit 'ho hum' - I now think it's bloody important. Will be interesting this year, and should give another good insight into Neeld's thinking/strategy.

[MadAsHell 4,089]

Probably boring when compared to the recruiting discussion about Cloke, Boak, Caddy etc - but it'll be interesting to see who we pick with our rookie selections this year.

Who are the good VFL, SAFL, WAFL players that we might target? For instance, Zorko looks a ripper for the Lions (I know he wasn't a rookie, but he seems to be the type of player that can be unearthed through the rookie draft).

I've heard Mark Hutchings from West Perth is a likely lad (character, ability etc). Others have obviously been mentioned as good rookie prospects too.

I used to find the rookie draft to be a bit 'ho hum' - I now think it's bloody important. Will be interesting this year, and should give another good insight into Neeld's thinking/strategy.

I think it could be a bit ho-hum for us this year Ron.

I wouldn't be suprised if we only pick 2 rookies, being one Clint Bartram and Liam Jurrah.

Bartram to see if he can recover from his knee issue and Liam for his obvious court case in March.