POLL: Do you want Mark Neeld to remain coach in 2013?

[thaipantsman 180]

To those 9 people that voted against Neeld, really should watch Coaches office this week.

One of the questions by a fan is how come we seem to win 3 games this season when we won 8 games with our playing list last year? and apparently according to neeld our list is less experience than our list last season, please watch full interview http://www.melbourne...50/default.aspx

BE VERY CLEAR HERE!! READ THE TOPIC!! ITS CLEARLY ASKS IF YOU SUPPORT MARK TO REMAIN COACH IN 2013? MANY OF US DEMONLANDERS DID NOT VOTE SIMPLY BECAUSE THE QUESTION IS NOT WITHOUT MISCHIEF. MOST WANT MARK TO COACH UNTIL THE END OF HIS CONTRACT 2014 AND THE REMAINDER (VAST MAJORITY) DON'T CARE OR SEE A NEED FOR SUCH A POLL. THE MERE FACT THERE IS A POLL SUGGESTS NEELDS'S GRIP IS FRAGILE AND THIS SUGGESTION IS COMPLETE AND UTTER NONSENSE

Edited August 9, 2012 by thaipantsman

[Range Rover 1,935]

268 - 10

Keep 'em coming folks!

[beelzebub 23,383]

we're not deaf !!!

[thaipantsman 180]

268 - 10

Keep 'em coming folks!

BE VERY CLEAR HERE!! READ THE TOPIC!! ITS CLEARLY ASKS IF YOU SUPPORT MARK TO REMAIN COACH IN 2013? MANY OF US DEMONLANDERS DID NOT VOTE SIMPLY BECAUSE THE QUESTION IS NOT WITHOUT MISCHIEF. MOST WANT MARK TO COACH UNTIL THE END OF HIS CONTRACT 2014 AND THE REMAINDER (VAST MAJORITY) DON'T CARE OR SEE A NEED FOR SUCH A POLL. THE MERE FACT THERE IS A POLL SUGGESTS NEELDS'S GRIP IS FRAGILE AND THIS SUGGESTION IS COMPLETE AND UTTER NONSENSE

Edited by thaipantsman, 09 August 2012 - 06:10 PM.

[thaipantsman 180]

gptta love Range Rover's persistence to keep his Poll alive.

Interesting Mathews insists Port Adelaide go for an experienced Coach. Melbourne should of done the same IMO>

Experience a must at Port: Leigh Matthews

[thaipantsman 180]

Interesting there has been 278 yes votes and 128 replies to the topic.

[thaipantsman 180]

Range Rover on Neeld's first year

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1efGFYcxJg&feature=player_embedded

[thaipantsman 180]

Range Rover, on 09 August 2012 - 07:49 PM, said:

268 - 10

Keep 'em coming folks!

Interesting there has been 278 yes votes and 128 replies to the topic.

130 replies to this topic

[hardtack 10,627]

gptta love Range Rover's persistence to keep his Poll alive.

Interesting Mathews insists Port Adelaide go for an experienced Coach. Melbourne should of done the same IMO>

Experience a must at Port: Leigh Matthews

Well, between RRs persistence and your persistence, it's not hard to tell who is having more success when taking a look at the count.

[Deez 298]

I have voted for the sake of voting, but i agree with that other bloke.

Waste of time, of course most want him to continue next year.

range rover posts some useless stuff huh.

[GrandOld 367]

Give him a chance with the players he has selected. He had to work with whatever he had this year. If next season turns to crap then it's his problem but let's not stat kicking him in the dick before he's even had a chance to put his plan into action .

[Tatu 416]

Not sure who started this poll?

But the message is loud and clear.... Mark Neeld stays....

P.S. RR is a lively member of demonland...... I like his polls...... And would welcome him back.....

[skills32 229]

Wow... Worst poll ever.

If people are genuinely calling for the sack then we know who to ignore, but my impression is that most who are being labelled with that are either calling for more accountability of the coaching staff and/or questioning why the same posters saying "you don't know if he's bad or not, needs more time" are also saying "I have faith in Neeld".

It's a circular argument, and pretty obviously this poll was started and worded in such a way as for point scoring by certain posters.

Henceforth, I won't be voting in this thread, and I'm TOTALLY SICK of the same 4-5 posters over running every thread with their name calling and off topic posts.

STOP RUINING DEMONLAND.

I stopped reading at post no4.

Range Rover? I'll bet you drive a Vespa.

[daisycutter 29,743]

I stopped reading at post no4.

Range Rover? I'll bet you drive a Vespa.

nah, he'd be a lycra larry

[jnrmac 20,189]

What a dumb thread.

[Demon17 5,203]

I've read that thread and the one thing it doesn't address is just what a frigging cess pool would be left if we removed another coach and who his replacement would be, therefore to suggest Neeld be removed is a totally moronic suggestion. I despair for the capacity to think clearly of those who vote in favour of his removal.

A stupid and destructive thread

[P-man 13,366]

Not sure who started this poll?

But the message is loud and clear.... Mark Neeld stays....

P.S. RR is a lively member of demonland...... I like his polls...... And would welcome him back.....

I think Hulkamania started this poll.

(j/k Hulk)

[stueyspencer no12 73]

The poll couldn't be any more simply worded.

Don't like the results Stu?

12 - 1 ... not looking good for the anti-Neeldists.

It's a very silly poll. Although I've found N to be quite unsatisfactory I certainly wouldn't want to see a change now. But if we are hopeless at the end of 2013 we must make a move because I'm aware of the sense of despair amongst many of the young (real) stars some of whom wil be out of contact and who would like to leave.

[Little Richard 6,265]

Poor Range Rover, pretty sure he created this thread to show his support for Neeld and prove the haters wrong... Oh well

[dees64 104]

I respect freedom of free speech.......but to have a vote on Neeld after 1 season???

We had a basket case list & shocking drafting....look at the delistings & draft to clera the decks a rebuild of the list.

Give Neeld & his team the time

Edited October 27, 2012 by dees64

[BangkokDemon 96]

What an uneccesary poll and topic. Obviously there are some Demonland members who read and listen to too much Damien Barrett. Mark Neeld was employed to do a job. And, cutting the fat and the could've should'ves from the list is part of it. Bringing in solid replacements is just as important.

To my mind the club has done a pretty reasonable job in that regard. Also don't be surprised if things don't go to plan...but at least we have a plan - now

[grant 10]

Fact is we just experienced the worst season maybe ever in the history of the club. 1 win against a non-expansion club is an utter risgrace that only one-eyed Melbourne supporters could sugar coat or see any positives.

Neeld can talk the talk all he likes but another season like last and he will struggle to find a job as a VFL coach.

[monoccular 17,575]

Fact is we just experienced the worst season maybe ever in the history of the club. 1 win against a non-expansion club is an utter risgrace that only one-eyed Melbourne supporters could sugar coat or see any positives.

Neeld can talk the talk all he likes but another season like last and he will struggle to find a job as a VFL coach.

1953 was as bad.......and we played finals for the next decade!

Keep faith.

[Sir Why You Little 37,134]

Bring Back Rangey....

[Bitter but optimistic 22,249]

1953 was as bad.......and we played finals for the next decade!

Keep faith.

Good positive point Mono, on what is an otherwise poinless thread. Off course the jury is still out on Neeld but to even ponder axing him now is one of the sillier topics to come up on this site.