GET "JUICE" BACK

[picket fence 15,137]

In the absence of any common sense forward structure at Melbourne then why not?Lets redraft next year?! eh?

And I say this because Neeld refuses, REFUSES to play No 1 pick Jack Watts in forward line when really, all is lost this season and golden opportunity presented today as it has at other times this season.

Don't give me the spiel that Garland and Rivers are the answer either because as proved today goals are easy against Greater Western Shockings Mosquito defenders, but not against reasonable( and that's all Brisbane defenders are after all) reasonable defense.

Juice Kicked 4 today at Norwood at key post, and was the best forward today and won them the game!

Never ever given consecutive run when Bailey in charge,

Injured at crucial stages,

24 yrs of age must, mature age recruit must be a better bet than any key forward at Melbourne bar Clarke.

Neeld must be rueing letting him go given scenario as played out.

I say get him back before others redraft based on his form at Norwood.

[dee-luded 2,958]

In the absence of any common sense forward structure at Melbourne then why not?Lets redraft next year?! eh?

And I say this because Neeld refuses, REFUSES to play No 1 pick Jack Watts in forward line when really, all is lost this season and golden opportunity presented today as it has at other times this season.

Don't give me the spiel that Garland and Rivers are the answer either because as proved today goals are easy against Greater Western Shockings Mosquito defenders, but not against reasonable( and that's all Brisbane defenders are after all) reasonable defense.

Juice Kicked 4 today at Norwood at key post, and was the best forward today and won them the game!

Never ever given consecutive run when Bailey in charge,

Injured at crucial stages,

24 yrs of age must, mature age recruit must be a better bet than any key forward at Melbourne bar Clarke.

Neeld must be rueing letting him go given scenario as played out.

I say get him back before others redraft based on his form at Norwood.

Should never 'ave Left!

[Scipio 5,868]

Oh come on, he was at Melbourne for six (?) seasons and gave nothing. He always played well at VFL level but never showed at AFL and was given way way too many chances. Troll thread?

[Bitter but optimistic 21,246]

Am I missing some jocular aside here? This cannot be a serious thread, surely?

[rjay 23,903]

Not a chance, he is great at the 2nd level but does not have it to step up the same as someone like Maric who now can't get a game at the Tiges.

Cook is a really smart player who makes good decisions and can use the ball well, if you could put his head with Juice's athletic ability you would have a world beater. It is time for Cook to step up though.

[Old Man Rivers 326]

Great Idea lets bring back Juice.

Actually why stop at Juice?

* Isaac Weetra

* Jace Bode

* Cameron Hunter

* Ross Funcke

Surely all these blokes are worth another look just incase we stuffed up first time around.

[jnrmac 18,954]

Picket is a 'Ology refugee and a senile 'juice' fool who is somehow related to MN. Ignore anything he says on the subject

[Kiss of Death 708]

Would like a Q1 vs North Melb 2010 Juice, but that only happens for 1 qtr a decade sadly.

[Biffen 12,323]

In the absence of any common sense forward structure at Melbourne then why not?Lets redraft next year?! eh?

And I say this because Neeld refuses, REFUSES to play No 1 pick Jack Watts in forward line when really, all is lost this season and golden opportunity presented today as it has at other times this season.

Don't give me the spiel that Garland and Rivers are the answer either because as proved today goals are easy against Greater Western Shockings Mosquito defenders, but not against reasonable( and that's all Brisbane defenders are after all) reasonable defense.

Juice Kicked 4 today at Norwood at key post, and was the best forward today and won them the game!

Never ever given consecutive run when Bailey in charge,

Injured at crucial stages,

24 yrs of age must, mature age recruit must be a better bet than any key forward at Melbourne bar Clarke.

Neeld must be rueing letting him go given scenario as played out.

I say get him back before others redraft based on his form at Norwood.

They'll be beating down the door after a bag of 4 in the SANFL-I hope his manager has the phone on.FFS I'm gonna score some smack.

[daisycutter 28,508]

In the absence of any common sense forward structure at Melbourne then why not?Lets redraft next year?! eh?

And I say this because Neeld refuses, REFUSES to play No 1 pick Jack Watts in forward line when really, all is lost this season and golden opportunity presented today as it has at other times this season.

Don't give me the spiel that Garland and Rivers are the answer either because as proved today goals are easy against Greater Western Shockings Mosquito defenders, but not against reasonable( and that's all Brisbane defenders are after all) reasonable defense.

Juice Kicked 4 today at Norwood at key post, and was the best forward today and won them the game!

Never ever given consecutive run when Bailey in charge,

Injured at crucial stages,

24 yrs of age must, mature age recruit must be a better bet than any key forward at Melbourne bar Clarke.

Neeld must be rueing letting him go given scenario as played out.

I say get him back before others redraft based on his form at Norwood.

you should seek help pf. there is a cure if you act promptly

juice was not even good enough to get a regular game in the worst side in the comp

[picket fence 15,137]

Nice to see some "astute" observations weed eater! Yeah probably because he had stress fractures in his foot might just explain why you didn't see him after the early rounds last year!

Oh and one other thing...

35 goals in 25 games er, can you define anyone else in the past 6 or so years who had a better average??

Now be careful because only a few can lay claim to those figures for Melbourne!

AND finally who would you rather in the forward line at present

Sellar?

Martin?

Magner?

Dunn?

what about Spencer?

Never ever was given an extended run is my point of view and for reasons other than ability times he would have been picked if not for injury remains and probably will now pass into "What if" Pity!

C'mon rollem out and please do, do your homework! before posting again.

[Jaded No More 57,820]

Worst. Thread. Ever.

And I've seen a few.

[DeeZee 6,732]

Bring back Roger Ellingworth

[picket fence 15,137]

Not a bad player on his day,was Roger!!!

[Carrot Top 947]

Zomer! FTW!

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I thought this was a joke thread, but alas it wasn't.

I'm concerned for your mental health buddy.

[Moonshadow 16,168]

Nice to see some "astute" observations weed eater! Yeah probably because he had stress fractures in his foot might just explain why you didn't see him after the early rounds last year!

Oh and one other thing...

35 goals in 25 games er, can you define anyone else in the past 6 or so years who had a better average??

Now be careful because only a few can lay claim to those figures for Melbourne!

AND finally who would you rather in the forward line at present

Sellar?

Martin?

Magner?

Dunn?

what about Spencer?

Never ever was given an extended run is my point of view and for reasons other than ability times he would have been picked if not for injury remains and probably will now pass into "What if" Pity!

C'mon rollem out and please do, do your homework! before posting again.

YOU FREAK!!!

Few had a better average because few were kicking goals. But that doesn't mean we should bring back a dud who had more than enough opportunity. He cried wolf tooooooooooooooooooo many times.

Any of those you mentioned would do better than Juice.

[picket fence 15,137]

Missing the point here, 35 goals in 25 games!!!!

Do the homework and see for yourself,

While others were kept, others with very modest records were retained!

Worse thing is I reckon he would be a shoe in this season

Pity... eh?

Oh and in response to

Pink Floyd. Mr Dark Side of the Moon....

If any mentioned would be better then thrill me with your acumen, facts, stats, etc so a reasonable debate can ensue,eh! then why arent they producing?? Eh

and as for Sloonie Mc Floonie Looney.. ah ahem your name says it all!

Edited July 1, 2012 by picket fence

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

GET AROUND HIM!

As a supporter behind me once said at the back end of 2007, why Neitz when we've got Newts!

[Jaded No More 57,820]

GET AROUND HIM!

As a supporter behind me once said at the back end of 2007, why Neitz when we've got Newts!

I hope you punched that supporter in the head.

[DEELIRIOUS 156]

I hope you punched that supporter in the head.

HAHAHA, of course my comments are all fun and games. He almost took the cake from Brent Grgic as the biggest dud I have ever seen play at the club. He rivals Dunn and Bate but seriously, Grgic takes the cake!

[rpfc 27,451]

Na na na-na-na, HEY! Na na na na.

Na na na-na-na, HEY! Na na na na.

Maybe we can save this thread. Anyone here a Chuck fan?

So sad to see it go. Thankgod for Subway!

[diesel 420]

Missing the point here, 35 goals in 25 games!!!!

Oh, Fence.....you are like a dog with a bone. Now this may surprise you but Juice (like JW) has been playing behind the ball at Norwood as well as up forward. Second efforts & tackling pressure are first and foremost now and Juice didn't have enough of these for Bails to give him a game!

[The Big Ticket 94]

Never seen such a hot and cold player at Melbourne. Still better than PJ though.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I would rather Miller back. At least he is still stinking it up in the relevant competition.

You nutcase!