A watch on Melbourne & how it looks to strengthen its front half in October. 

 

32 next year and a heart the size of a peanut, if we weren’t interested in him as part of the Luke Jackson trade why would we now? 

Absolutely no, I’d prefer Caleb Daniel as a key position forward. 

Nah.

I'd rather keep Schache for another year.

If he was five years younger I'd say roll the dice on him if he came cheap enough. No chance with his current output and age though. 

No, no and no

IF we were to go after him the time would have been at the end of 2022 when he had just come off a strong year at Freo

In hindsight that may have been a better choice than pursuing Grundy, but even then there were doubts about his competitiveness and ability to perform consistently 

He’s now two years older and hasn’t done his credentials any favours since crossing over to the Dogs 

Unfortunate for us because in an ideal world he’s exactly the type of player we’re in need of…

Him (or maybe even better a player like him but not actually him) would have been far more useful than the Grundy experiment, but hindisght is 20:20.  Not worth the risk at his age now though.

No. No. Stay the **** away.

He's a cancer on club culture. He's been at three clubs now, is already 32 and his infield output is inconsistent at best. For a guy his size he's as soft as they come. He makes Schache look like a brute.

I'll burn my membership if this [censored] ever pulls on red and blue.

I would rather play one short then have him on our list

If he wasn't the height he is, then he would be picking mangoes in the Top End. 

computer says: "next question"

I hope the Magpies swoop for him.

 

Edited April 24, 20241 yr by Winners at last

Another Josh Schache? 

NAHHHHHhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Yuck! 

I'd do it 

God no, amongst many other things, he’s not a team player, very selfish 

he's a big girls blouse 

1 hour ago, Demon Jack said:

I'd rather keep Schache for another year.

Lobb’s 20 times the player Schache is, and Lobb’s not particularly good.

if it's a choice between schache on a minimum contract and lobb on a healthy one, it's schache

they're both vfl players

If Bulldogs pay for a fair chunk it may be worth considering for depth once BBB goes.

Not a match day squad addition - So he'd probably go somewhere he gets a guaranteed game

LOL. 

Let’s add another NQR tall fwd to our list

and he seems like a tool

hell no!

We have a 1-player-only-peroxide-blonde-hair-policy, so he doesn't make the cut.