Rival clubs fume at Collingwood’s hold on MCG seats

[pitmaster 3,453]

“Collingwood moved from Victoria Park to the MCG and the deal Eddie McGuire and the board devised was one to support the redevelopment and the long-standing growth of the MCG. We were the founding tenant club and we brought all our members across,” Kelly said.

Rival clubs fume at Collingwood’s hold on MCG seats

[rpfc 28,052]

‘Founding tenant’…

Imagine the look of MFC people when the ‘founding tenant’ announced itself… 

Collingwood going for a weekend away “I claim this B&B as the founding tenant!”

Collingwood arriving in Jan 26, 1788 in Botany Bay “I claim this land as the founding tenant!”

Oooh, see what I did there… 

[buck_nekkid 5,820]

‘Founding tenant’ - first uninvited guest.  Like the cane toad was the founding tenant of the QLD cane fields.

GFY Kelly, Melbourne FC are the original and only true team of the MCG. 

[drysdale demon 4,703]

He is just bathing in his own non importance.Th e bloke is so far up himself they will need a front end loader to get him out.

[TRIGON 4,783]

Wasn't Richmond the first tenant?

[daisycutter 29,343]

28 minutes ago, TRIGON said:

Wasn't Richmond the first tenant?

second

[pitmaster 3,453]

1 hour ago, buck_nekkid said:

‘Founding tenant’ - first uninvited guest.  Like the cane toad was the founding tenant of the QLD cane fields.

GFY Kelly, Melbourne FC are the original and only true team of the MCG. 

Before the administrators reworked it my headline was "what is this clown drinking?' but you've nailed it with the toad!

[Sydee 4,215]

1 hour ago, pitmaster said:

“Collingwood moved from Victoria Park to the MCG and the deal Eddie McGuire and the board devised was one to support the redevelopment and the long-standing growth of the MCG. We were the founding tenant club and we brought all our members across,” Kelly said.

Rival clubs fume at Collingwood’s hold on MCG seats

To be honest it irks me more that they never have to head down the Geelong Road to Mordor - EVER !

What a joke the AFL fixture is year after year

[Dr. Gonzo 23,757]

7 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

second

No they were the first. We are not a tenant, we are the home club. The rest are tenants.

[FearTheBeard 1,196]

As Melbourne fans, we must never forget that Eddie allowed us to have Queens Birthday as our home game for 15 years.

As for the Ponsford agreement, its BS if you're richmond because they have reserved seat areas level 2 Ponsford.

For us, its really irrelevant, we might have 500 people that sit in the Ponsford so it is just about whether they should be paying to get in.

And the whole thing with changerooms is pretty irrelevant too, pretty sure we are happy to run out the mcc race as an away team.

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 6,603]

We are the MCG. 

The delusion and Arrogance from Craig Kelly is at unmeasurable levels with these comments.

FMS!

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,642]

Honestly, asides from the Collingwood arrogance about this issue, I'm not really that bothered as it hardly impacts me and I suspect it doesn't really impact our members.

The bigger issue for me is how the MFC has decided to manage it's allocation of seating during our home games.  I resent that the club took away the premium seating area on the wing/half forward ground level of the Northern Stand which use to be the MFC members ' Red Seats ' area open to all MFC members and made it into an exclusive MFC reserve seating area.  I get the finacial imperatives the club operates under, but I actually think this move was somewhat corrosive to the fabric of the club from a supporters perspective.

I reestablished my MFC membership since around 2011 back when we were rubbish, so think I hace contributed reasonablely to the club over recient history.

The way the MFC reserve seat area on the wing is managed is [censored]:

1. For a family it would cost me excessively for everyone to purchase reserve seats in the area;

2.  Even if I could afford it, it's difficult to get enough seats in a block together and almost impossible to also be allocated next to/near my old man's reserved seat in this area;

3.  The other issue with perminantly reserved seats is that when people don't rock up, they go vacant, per the Collingwood home game issue.  Having vacant seats in premium viewing positions is bad business and bad for footy culture in my view and bring a real finacial eliteisim to the game that erodes it.

Please bring back the old MFC members Red Seat area (Even if they are now grey!).  Perhaps Kate can champion that cause for the average MFC punter.

Edited February 22, 2023 by Rodney (Balls) Grinter

[Katrina Dee Fan 2,787]

2 hours ago, pitmaster said:

“Collingwood moved from Victoria Park to the MCG and the deal Eddie McGuire and the board devised was one to support the redevelopment and the long-standing growth of the MCG. We were the founding tenant club and we brought all our members across,” Kelly said.

Rival clubs fume at Collingwood’s hold on MCG seats

founding tenant club?  Of the four clubs tenanted at the MCG they came last!  It seems we know now the drugs Ginnivan got must have come from Kelly.....

[BangBnagBang 594]

 

30 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

No they were the first. We are not a tenant, we are the home club. The rest are tenants.

SNAP

 

[daisycutter 29,343]

36 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

No they were the first. We are not a tenant, we are the home club. The rest are tenants.

it's not worth arguing, however i think you'll find that technically the mfc is defined as a tenant club of the mcg

i could provide links but it's not worth getting into a drawn out argument

[pitmaster 3,453]

37 minutes ago, FearTheBeard said:

As Melbourne fans, we must never forget that Eddie allowed us to have Queens Birthday as our home game for 15 years.

 

We must never forget that Eddie allowed us to have the QB home game AFTER the MCC rolled over for him with the deal that the Ponsford Stand would be the Pie social club at home and away games. Not so generous as it might first seem.

And then, when we started pulling a crowd he wanted the home status to alternate between us.

[old dee 23,506]

13 minutes ago, pitmaster said:

We must never forget that Eddie allowed us to have the QB home game AFTER the MCC rolled over for him with the deal that the Ponsford Stand would be the Pie social club at home and away games. Not so generous as it might first seem.

And then, when we started pulling a crowd he wanted the home status to alternate between us.

I don't have any problem with that. He helped when we needed it most. 

[DeeSpencer 24,811]

Obviously it's rough for anyone who has reserve seats in the Ponsford. But largely I do like the idea of keeping most of the ferals in the same spot. 

Ideally just wall off the Ponsford stand  and AFL members for Melb v Coll games and don't let any of them in the rest of the ground. 

[Winners at last 5,167]

I hate the filth .... tripplechins .... joffa ....  buckley  ...  their feral supporters  ...  et al. 

[AzzKikA 2,371]

34 minutes ago, Winners at last said:

I hate the filth .... tripplechins .... joffa ....  buckley  ...  their feral supporters  ...  et al. 

I actually met Buckley at the show "best on ground" and he was quite a nice bloke, had a lot more time for us than Roo did.

Also met the one and only Russell Robbo Robertson that night too which was awesome!

Edited February 23, 2023 by AzzKikA

[layzie 33,075]

4 hours ago, rpfc said:

‘Founding tenant’…

Imagine the look of MFC people when the ‘founding tenant’ announced itself… 

Collingwood going for a weekend away “I claim this B&B as the founding tenant!”

Collingwood arriving in Jan 26, 1788 in Botany Bay “I claim this land as the founding tenant!”

Oooh, see what I did there… 

Or Duck Dodgers claiming this planet in the name of the Earth. Then seconds later Marvin the Martian arrives and "claiming this planet in the name of Mars, isn't that lovely?"

[No. 31 1,081]

I thought Carlton were the "founding tenant" football club in 1885 at the MCG as the MCC had MFC playing next door at an oval in Yarra Park at the time? I think MFC started using the MCG as a home ground in 1890? I think CFC started playing at Princes Park in 1897 when the VFL commenced.

http://www.demonwiki.org/1885

https://blueseum.org/1885

Anyone have any authoritative sources on this opaque period of MCG tenancy history?

Anyways, Collingwood are definitely late comers to the MCG.

[dl4e 5,851]

The filth are a disgrace.

There is only one club as the owner of the MCG and that is the MFC. The rest of them can go and get stuffed.

[cookieboc 740]

2 hours ago, pitmaster said:

We must never forget that Eddie allowed us to have the QB home game AFTER the MCC rolled over for him with the deal that the Ponsford Stand would be the Pie social club at home and away games. Not so generous as it might first seem.

And then, when we started pulling a crowd he wanted the home status to alternate between us.

NOT ONLY THAT, BUT IT ALSO MEANT ANOTHER GUARANTEED WEEK DURING THE SEASON WHERE COLLINGWOOD DINT HAVE TO TRAVEL. AT THEIR HOME GROUND IN FRONT OF THEIR HOME CROWD IN THEIR PRE PAID SEATS. CLUB DIDNT LOSE A THING, AND ADRE I SAY IT, WE DIDNT MAKE THAT MUCH BECAUSE OF IT

[Deebauched 1,220]

Collingwood can afford to be arrogant and always get what they want. They have a massive following due to bogans having lots of kids. 

Collingwood would fill a stadium in the African Congo if they were scheduled there.

They'll pull 80,000 R1 against the spoilt kittens.  Geelong supporters may not even turn up but the pies will. 

Melb v Bulldogs  maybe 45k mostly dees supporters. Doubt if their supporters will turn up in numbers.