STABBING IN THE DARK by Whispering Jack

[Demonland 73,465]

STABBING IN THE DARK by Whispering Jack

With a week to go until the 2017 NAB National Draft meeting there’s not a great deal of excitement about it here on Demonland. 

The Jake Lever deal delivered a quality player with a projected long future at Melbourne but it also left the club without a first round draft pick. The Demons’ first selection is in mid-second round.

They have four vacancies on their primary list and unless they decide to take the unlikely course of recruiting a delisted free agent in the next few days, the Dees will go into the draft meeting in Sydney next Friday evening with selections 29, 31, 36 and 47 (or thereabouts because matching offers for academy selections and father-son picks can throw the order about slightly).

In light of the above, it would be absolute folly to even attempt a phantom draft although things are somewhat better than last year when Melbourne ended up with a third round pick at #46 as its first choice at about the time much of the viewership of the televised event was about to take a power nap.

As it turned out, the club’s first pick was a good one - Mitch Hannan who made his AFL debut in Round 1, 2017 against St Kilda, at Etihad Stadium and finished the season with 20 games and 22 goals to his name.

That’s the objective here - to look for players who might be available within the range of Melbourne’s draft selections when the meeting takes place next week. 

According to the statistical evidence, it’s not necessarily a gloom and doom scenario. The AFL Draft Guru tells us that over the past 33 national drafts, the average number of games played by pick 10 (the selection given away for Lever) was 87 compared with 79 games for the club’s current first pick at 29. And the Dees’ second pick at 31 yields an average of 60 which is better than the equivalent first selection of 53 for the Magpies at number 6. Yes, we all know about statistics and damn lies.

 I’ve looked at the field and acknowledge that it’s like stabbing in the dark but someone has to try - so here goes (with the help of some pen pics taken straight from the current edition of Inside Football):-

Given the recent success with recruiting the likes of Aaron vandenBerg and Hannan who came from the state leagues, why not take a player who wore the colours with distinction throughout 2017 in that very arena? I refer of course to Casey Demon Bayley Fritsch who is attracting interest from a dozen clubs after a scintillating season in the VFL.

The indications are that he might be available at around pick 36 and the club obviously has plenty of inside information about his ability as a player and his character.

Bayley Fritsch DOB: 06-12-96 186.9cm, 80.1kg Casey Demons 

“After two years tailed by injury, the left foot forward from Coldstream enjoyed a full season and was so impressive he elevated himself more into a draft certainty than a hopeful. Often spectacular in the air, deceptively quick, a penetrating kick, and crafty at ground level, the 20-year-old represented the VFL, topped Casey’s goalkicking with 44, made the VFL team of the year and received the Fothergill-Round Medal as the league’s best young player (always a reliable guide to a player’s AFL prospects). It won’t be a surprise to see him nabbed in the national draft.” -  VFL expert Paul Amy

Let’s face it. Picking players at this range isn’t necessarily going to provide you with ready made guns but we all like excitement machines and this next pair would add plenty of that - one is a high flyer and the other, a speedster.

Jordan Houlahan DOB: 19-Feb-99 185.7cm 76.0kg  Sturt

“Jordan is a spectacular player who tested well at the draft camp. He has an outrageously good vertical jump and also reads the flight of the ball really well. Every week he will take a couple of Jeremy Howe-type hangers. So he has some real x-factor about him but how that translates to AFL we’ll see. He might end up playing as a defender rather than a forward but he’s a nice shot at goal. More on the introverted, laid back side than on the extroverted side of the spectrum.” - Sturt general manager David Oatey.

Jack Petruccelle DOB: 12-Apr-1999 185.1cm, 77.7kg Northern Knights

“Jack came into the system mid-way through last year and put the basketball stuff on hold. He’s the quickest player in the TAC Cup and whether it’s in the air or on the ground he just does things that others can’t. We were impressed with his ability to chase and tackle - he tackles to hurt - and he puts his head over the ball. He’s been working extremely hard on his kicking - he’s OK when he’s on the run or from a set shot, but he can miss the short ones when he pokes at them. He’ll improve enormously in an AFL competition.” - Northern Knights talent manager Rhy Gieschen.

Then we have the players who start each year as highly regarded prospects but, for some reason or another, fall out of favour and slide down the scale. In Charlie Spargo’s case it’s been injury that has seen him drop from possible top ten to mid second round.

Charlie Spargo DOB: 25-Nov-99 171.6cm 70.2kg  Murray Bushrangers

"Charlie didn't play a game this year because of a shoulder injury after a handful of games last year. A really clever small forward, he would have developed in the midfield this year but because of the injury that didn’t happen. Certainly a draftable player and while the injury means he’ll slide I’m pretty sure he’ll get taken.” - Murray Bushrangers coach Leon Higgins.

Another who was fancied early but has dropped in draft calculations is South Australian Callum Coleman-Jones, possibly because clubs are loathe to go too early with the taller types and also because of injury which restricted him. He could make a good fit as a developing tall at Melbourne.

Callum Coleman-Jones DOB: 13-6-1999 200.9cm,  98.9kg, Sturt

“Callum is a 200cm ruckman/forward who was an AFL Academy member. Always a certainty to be drafted but he had a few injuries this year, which didn’t help him. National carnival was OK and would have played senior footy for us but because of AIS and school duties it didn’t happen. A good quality tall who can get off the ground.” - Sturt general manager David Oatey.

You can never have enough hard at it inside footballers and there have been some suggestions that James Worpel could be in that mix all of the way to pick 47.

James Worpel DOB: 24-Jan-1999 1851cm, 85.5kg Geelong Falcons

“James’ strength is to win the contested ball and does that better than anyone I’ve coached. He’s just a beast on the inside and is super explosive with repeat efforts. If you get tackled by him - which he’ll lay seven or eight in a game - you’ll know about it. Super leader and had all the accolades this year with Vic Country captain and Falcons captain. Just a wonderful person to have around the club.” - Geelong Falcons coach Dan O’Keefe

Of course, when draft night comes around, there’s a good chance that none of the above will be selected by Melbourne so the next reference point might be this.

[Salems Lot 2,682]

Thanks Jack!  Is Charlie Spargo any relation to the MFC Spargos?

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,954]

Jack Petruccelle sounds like a good choice to me, just so we can have the comentators wrangle with - "Clayton the tounge twister Oliver feeds one out to Petruccelle, passes to Pertracca.... kicks a GOOOAAAAALLLL".  I could imagine Rex Hunt going stupid over that.

[Deemania since 56 6,763]

1 hour ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Jack Petruccelle sounds like a good choice to me, just so we can have the comentators wrangle with - "Clayton the tounge twister Oliver feeds one out to Petruccelle, passes to Pertracca.... kicks a GOOOAAAAALLLL".  I could imagine Rex Hunt going stupid over that.

It would be phantastique, yes. Fritsch, Petruccelle and Lever as the main MFC pick-ups for the 2018 season and then, there would be no need to call on Rex Hunt to go ape-[censored] over the calls - every Dees supporter would be heard en masse doing that for him across 100 minutes of football, every week. 

[demonmerv 92]

I think we should be looking for some tall players. We always seem to get monstered by tall marking forwards like ben brown and we lack that same pressure. Other than big Maxxy, King and Filipovic we have no body around 200cm. Jack was our next tallest at 196cm and of course Simon Goodwin ( or should I say Simon Badloss) sacked him. I would think we would be looking at Sam Hayes or Charlie Ballard, or even Connor Ballanden if we can wrestle him from the Lions.

Edited November 17, 2017 by demonmerv

[whatwhat say what 23,418]

Casey Demon Bayley Fritsch, methinks that should be

Would love him, Pettrucelle and Spargo with those three picks clustered together

[Elwood 3184 1,362]

On 17/11/2017 at 6:16 AM, Demonland said:

Jack Petruccelle DOB: 12-Apr-1999 185.1cm, 77.7kg Northern Knights

“Jack came into the system mid-way through last year and put the basketball stuff on hold. He’s the quickest player in the TAC Cup and whether it’s in the air or on the ground he just does things that others can’t. We were impressed with his ability to chase and tackle - he tackles to hurt - and he puts his head over the ball. He’s been working extremely hard on his kicking - he’s OK when he’s on the run or from a set shot, but he can miss the short ones when he pokes at them. He’ll improve enormously in an AFL competition.” - Northern Knights talent manager Rhy Gieschen.

Brings back memories of that tv show Petrocelli about a big shot lawyer who practiced in a small town in the USA. I'm sure Petruccelle the footballer isn't as bland.

After losing Trengove and Watts we really do need some Jacks up our sleeve.

[Demon trucker 1,800]

22 hours ago, Elwood 3184 said:

Brings back memories of that tv show Petrocelli about a big shot lawyer who practiced in a small town in the USA. I'm sure Petruccelle the footballer isn't as bland.

After losing Trengove and Watts we really do need some Jacks up our sleeve.

Yes there are a lot less jacks on the list, maybe a good thing not a very good team with so many jacks, Jack watts only ever showing potential, Jack Grimes being a back slapper, and jack trengove being limited.

[Freddy Fuschia 764]

Then there's Jack Viney.

[Port Demons 131]

options for our draft prospects in the 30's could get us like Ryley Stoddart and Oskar Baker 

[Diamond_Jim 12,686]

Apparently these were the most popular names in 1999 .... the chances of a "jack" look high

Joshua, var. Joshuah▼, .. 8 more2.Jack, var. Jacky, .. 7 more3.Lachlan4.▲2Thomas, var. Tomas▼, .. 23 more5.▲2James, var. Jaimie, .. 27 more6.▼2Matthew, var. Mathew▼, Mathieu▼, .. 32 more7.▼2Daniel, var. Danial▼, .. 19 more8.newNicholas, var. Nicholaus new, .. 60 more9.▲1William, var. Willem▼, .. 33 more10.▼1Benjamin,
Read more at http://www.thinkbabynames.com/popular/1/australia/1999#Uwz1C2pyAYJsaCLl.99

[Wadda We Sing 10,685]

Backup ruckman.........oh yeah and another Jack.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

On 18/11/2017 at 9:09 AM, Elwood 3184 said:

Brings back memories of that tv show Petrocelli about a big shot lawyer who practiced in a small town in the USA. I'm sure Petruccelle the footballer isn't as bland.

After losing Trengove and Watts we really do need some Jacks up our sleeve.

Hard to be the fastest guy in the draft wearing those boots

 

[Whispering_Jack 31,129]

Not bad - Spargo (who 12 months ago and before his shoulder injury would have been top 10) and Fritsch who we developed through Casey and is now the third graduate from the ranks of our VFL affiliate to be drafted over the past 12 months.

[spirit of norm smith 16,615]

Yes and Houlahan was there for the pick. I rated Houlahan at 20-25 so amazed he lasted longer than our selections.  Wanted Houlahan at 36.

[Tony Tea 2,814]

On 19/11/2017 at 11:55 AM, Moonshadow said:

Hard to be the fastest guy in the draft wearing those boots

 

"I should now like to recreate the night of the crime."

[Moonshadow 17,678]

I thought Constable was a monty for about 15-18. We passed him twice. Did I miss something about him that let him slip well past the predictions of many? 

[Willmoy1947 4,198]

I'd have to stop myself from yelling out his name every time he took a screamer.

[Mach5 4,768]

33 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

I thought Constable was a monty for about 15-18. We passed him twice. Did I miss something about him that let him slip well past the predictions of many? 

He has a tank the size of a tesla.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

1 hour ago, Mach5 said:

He has a tank the size of a tesla.

OK, but a tank can be worked on with application. Is he lazy or unmotivated? I was surprised, however I'm no draft expert 

[demonmerv 92]

by not selecting a player like Sam Hayes we may have missed the opportunity to find a replacement for Pedersen in 2019. Someone who would compliment Gawn and give us that tall to monster opposition backs.

[Mach5 4,768]

14 minutes ago, demonmerv said:

by not selecting a player like Sam Hayes we may have missed the opportunity to find a replacement for Pedersen in 2019. Someone who would compliment Gawn and give us that tall to monster opposition backs.

Do we need one?

Mitch King & Filipovic are developing true ruckmen.

Frost & T-Mac are capable of giving brief periods of in-game relief. I'd expect O-Mac & Weideman to be developed to be capable of this also.

[demonmerv 92]

2 minutes ago, Mach5 said:

Do we need one?

Mitch King & Filipovic are developing true ruckmen.

Frost & T-Mac are capable of giving brief periods of in-game relief. I'd expect O-Mac & Weideman to be developed to be capable of this also.

you have more confidence than me Mach5. King and Filipovic at best are back up ruckmen for Gawn. OMac may prove to be a good forward, Weideman may make it but will never be a back up ruckman. Someone mobile like Hayes could develop into a taller forward/ruckman for when Pedo retires, and play in the same side as Gawn. I really think this is an area where we are lacking. We still do not have much size over 195cm, as a lot of sides have. Ben Brown, two metre Peter and others still cause us problems . I would love to have a good tall floating forward that would give us that same pressure.