My 3 word end of season player analysis

[joeboy 3,171]

Jones - always the warrior ( 8 )

Viney - injuries cruelled year ( 6 )

Hogan - year from hell ( 3 )

Salem - only occasional glimpses ( 5 )

Watts - impressive first half ( 6 )

Petracca - teased and underperformed ( 5 )

Lewis - performed as expected ( 7.5 )

Trengove - cannot be retained ( 3 )

Brayshaw - understandably limited output ( 4 )

Gawn - disappointing and underwhelming ( 5 )

Tyson - lacking basic skills ( 5 )

Oliver - talented and consistent ( 8.5 )

Hibberd - decade-best recruit ( 8.5 )

Stretch - has gone backwards ( 3 )

Kent - little to commend ( 3 )

Frost - fine first half ( 6.5 )

Melksham - a surprise packet ( 6.5)

Hannan - made an impression ( 6 )

Pedersen - rough but capable ( 7 )

Vince - slowing and mistakeridden ( 5 )

Kennedy-Harris - not Goodwin's favourite ( 3 )

T.McDonald - highs and lows ( 6.5 )

Weideman - far from ready ( 3 )

O.McDonald - coming of age ( 7.5 )

Hunt - exciting but tired ( 7 )

Neal-Bullen - break out year ( 6 )

Bugg - tried but limited ( 5 )

Spencer - little to assess ( 3 )

Garlett - exciting but restricted ( 6.5 )

Jetta - slow but cunning ( 7 )

White - didn't show enough ( 3 )

Wagner - rarely imbued confidence ( 4 )

Harmes - occasionally stood out ( 5.5 )

 

[Bimbo 943]

Well done Joeboy.  I may not agree with the number ratings for all but I think you have given a very sound 3 word assessment of the list.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

Melksham was my surprise packet this year - 7

[DubDee 26,200]

not bad JB

although harsh on T mac IMO, aside from his last couple of weeks he was very good all year.  especially out of position up front

it is hard to think past Saturday though.  WTF was he doing!?

[Redleg 41,785]

Would give Jetta a 9 and probably a 6.5 to Trac but pretty good on rest.  

[DSP 1,488]

Pretty good.

Too generous for Oscar. Had one standout game for the season. Rest were good to shizen. Wasnt even close to Jetta or Hibbo.

[Gorgoroth 13,144]

I love Petracca but I keep getting this in my head.

Petracca - our new Sylvia...

[old dee 23,929]

12 minutes ago, Gorgoroth said:

I love Petracca but I keep getting this in my head.

Petracca - our new Sylvia...

Glad you said it first Gorgoroth. Because I have been thinking similar.

However he is still a kid so let's give him another couple of years.

He has had games where he has been very good.

There a number of others that have never shown much above VFL standard that have cost us dearly.

[Jibroni 5,035]

59 minutes ago, DSP said:

Pretty good.

Too generous for Oscar. Had one standout game for the season. Rest were good to shizen. Wasnt even close to Jetta or Hibbo.

I agree with OMac. His year was 6.5 at best.

But great overall analysis JB.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Good effort Joe. I'd have a couple of tweaks but can't really argue.

Good work on your weekly assessments also. I don't always agree but you are prepared to put it out there.

Well done.

[Adzman 2,154]

2 hours ago, joeboy said:

Jones - always the warrior ( 8 )

Viney - injuries cruelled year ( 6 )

Hogan - year from hell ( 3 )

Salem - only occasional glimpses ( 5 )

Watts - impressive first half ( 6 )

Petracca - teased and underperformed ( 5 )

Lewis - performed as expected ( 7.5 )

Trengove - cannot be retained ( 3 )

Brayshaw - understandably limited output ( 4 )

Gawn - disappointing and underwhelming ( 5 )

Tyson - lacking basic skills ( 5 )

Oliver - talented and consistent ( 8.5 )

Hibberd - decade-best recruit ( 8.5 )

Stretch - has gone backwards ( 3 )

Kent - little to commend ( 3 )

Frost - fine first half ( 6.5 )

Melksham - a surprise packet ( 6.5)

Hannan - made an impression ( 6 )

Pedersen - rough but capable ( 7 )

Vince - slowing and mistakeridden ( 5 )

Kennedy-Harris - not Goodwin's favourite ( 3 )

T.McDonald - highs and lows ( 6.5 )

Weideman - far from ready ( 3 )

O.McDonald - coming of age ( 7.5 )

Hunt - exciting but tired ( 7 )

Neal-Bullen - break out year ( 6 )

Bugg - tried but limited ( 5 )

Spencer - little to assess ( 3 )

Garlett - exciting but restricted ( 6.5 )

Jetta - slow but cunning ( 7 )

White - didn't show enough ( 3 )

Wagner - rarely imbued confidence ( 4 )

Harmes - occasionally stood out ( 5.5 )

 

Pretty much spot on mate. Garland didn't make the list given he didn't play, I wonder if he will go on and play the final year of his contract. Seems like the forgotten man.

 

[jumbo returns 6,741]

1 hour ago, Gorgoroth said:

I love Petracca but I keep getting this in my head.

Petracca - our new Sylvia...

Whoa....please, god, no!

[Yze_13 297]

46 minutes ago, old dee said:

Glad you said it first Gorgoroth. Because I have been thinking similar.

However he is still a kid so let's give him another couple of years.

He has had games where he has been very good.

There a number of others that have never shown much above VFL standard that have cost us dearly.

I think the problem is that his best is so good and so explosive that the "ordinary" stuff doesn't really register.

With another full preseason he should take the next step next year.

 

[Gorgoroth 13,144]

49 minutes ago, old dee said:

Glad you said it first Gorgoroth. Because I have been thinking similar.

However he is still a kid so let's give him another couple of years.

He has had games where he has been very good.

There a number of others that have never shown much above VFL standard that have cost us dearly.

 

3 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Whoa....please, god, no!

I hope no, but all we see are glimpses at the moment, I'm not saying he will become Sylvia but I keep getting this nagging feeling and I thought Sylvia would come good too.

Next year should give an indication.

[old dee 23,929]

Just now, Gorgoroth said:

 

I hope no, but all we see are glimpses at the moment, I'm not saying he will become Sylvia but I keep getting this nagging feeling and I thought Sylvia would come good too.

Next year should give an indication.

A classic Sylvia line G! 

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

2 minutes ago, old dee said:

A classic Sylvia line G! 

Not quite od.

Col was always a "pre season" short of brilliance!

[beelzebub 23,388]

interesting as roughly a score of 18/33

consider that....hmmm...interesting

[spirit of norm smith 16,596]

3 words 

thank you Joeboy

enjoy the summer

better in 2018

go might demons

go get Lever

[Billy 2,556]

1 hour ago, Gorgoroth said:

I love Petracca but I keep getting this in my head.

Petracca - our new Sylvia...

Poor comment

[jumbo returns 6,741]

29 minutes ago, Gorgoroth said:

 

I hope no, but all we see are glimpses at the moment, I'm not saying he will become Sylvia but I keep getting this nagging feeling and I thought Sylvia would come good too.

Next year should give an indication.

Needs to build a tank - that's his challenge

[old dee 23,929]

11 minutes ago, jumbo returns said:

Needs to build a tank - that's his challenge

Only one good pre season away jr?

[Lord Byron 32]

Harsh on Jetta. Will feature in the Bluey. 8.5+

[Pottsydee 153]

Fair summary.

Well done Joeboy, looked forward to the analysis every week. 

[Gorgoroth 13,144]

1 hour ago, Billy said:

Poor comment

Why? For voicing a thought?

[Coq au vin 755]

3 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

I love Petracca but I keep getting this in my head.

Petracca - our new Sylvia...

Nonsense. Sylvia couldn't even lick his boots.