2009 draft - six years after

[Satan 2,915]

Overall set us back years.

Scully, Gysberts, Tapscott and Fitzpatrick gone.

Trengove injured last 2 years

Gawn finally established himself after a couple of ACL's.

Missed out on Martin, Fyfe from first 20 picks when we had 4 picks.

Unluckly on injured players, Scully enough said, 11 and 18 killed us.

[dazzledavey36 55,983]

Lol i remember saying that in 6 years time we'll win a premiership with Trengove, Scully, Tapscott and Gysberts in it... yuk..

[dino rover 714]

Lest we forget

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Lest we forget

I'd prefer to forget Dino!

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

And last year was the 2014 draft -

Brayshaw
Petracca
Stretch
ANB
O Mac
White and
vandenBerg

Let's talk about this one

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

Take solace in the fact that out of Tom Scully we got Jesse Hogan, so perhaps (at a bit of a stretch) we could call the 2009 draft a win.

[jnrmac 20,298]

Overall set us back years

Scully , tapscott , gysbert Fitzpatrick gone

Trengove injured last 2 years

Gawn finally established himself after A couple of acls

Missed out on martin , fyfe from first 20 picks when we had 4 picks

Unluckly on injured players , scully enough said , 11 and 18 killed us

Everyone missed out on Fyffe at least once. Ce la vie.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

And last year was the 2014 draft -

Brayshaw

Petracca

Stretch

ANB

O Mac

White and

vandenBerg

Let's talk about this one

None of those players have reached their full potential and that draft is already a win.

Damn that's a nice list.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

None of those players have reached their full potential and that draft is already a win.

Damn that's a nice list.

After year one we were all pretty happy with Scully & Trengove, Gysberts had shown he could win a lot of the ball at AFL level and most were very optimistic about Tapscott. Gawn had also earned a senior appearance and held his own. The fact that the players all stagnated or went backwards is the depressing thing.

I'll show myself out now.

[Ted Lasso 19,564]

I think we would have looked at this draft in a vastly different way had they been drafted say 2 years ago under Roos and no pressure been put on them,

i don't rate Scully but i think he's still be in our 22 and Trengove i think could still be an A grader if he gets his body right.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

After year one we were all pretty happy with Scully & Trengove, Gysberts had shown he could win a lot of the ball at AFL level and most were very optimistic about Tapscott. Gawn had also earned a senior appearance and held his own. The fact that the players all stagnated or went backwards is the depressing thing.

I'll show myself out now.

[What 18,810]

Trengove was the right pick at pick 2

Cant help injuries, the kid was well on the way to stardom after his second season

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Jim Carrey certainly makes for great gif material.

I knew we butchered a couple of drafts around this time, but I had forgotten we had 4 picks inside the top 20!!! Hopefully Gawn continues and Trengove gets back so we can at least salvage something.

[Chook 15,023]

The dangers of placing all our hope in unknown teenagers.

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

Scully got us Hogan.

It was a great draft

[Ted Lasso 19,564]

Still have alot of faith Trenners will be back, and will shut alot of doubters up in 2016, he's as good a young player as we have and fully fit, look out.

[whatwhat say what 23,613]

i keep deliberately putting the fear of god in my carlton-supporting mates, equating their 2015 draft haul with our 2009 collection.

i personally doubt that trenners can make it back personally due to the sheer amount of football he's missed, which is a damn shame, so gawn is the only 'winner' here.

i really thought the gys was going to be something special.

[btdemon 482]

It's true that our previous recruiting teams have had some shockers and we are now beginning to see how good recruiters do it. People forget that before injury Trengove was definitely a plus. Gawn is a 209 cm ruck man who's is now beginning to be very effective . You can't predict injury. I agree that we would probably not pick a 'Gysberts' type under the new regime, but Tapscott appeared to all of us to tick all of the boxes - tough, big body, good kick etc. Unfortunately he just wasn't that good. He couldn't find the footy enough.

Geelong and hawthorn have obviously led the way in recruiting techniques and they have been models for the other teams. Our mob seem to be doing alright atm.

Scully had the same appeal as Parish. He ran all day and got the footy a lot. This is another reason I'm kind of happy we went with Oliver instead. Scully wasn't big enough to impose himself in the middle and I'm not sure if Parish will be. I think he is a cut above Sully though.

Edited November 26, 2015 by btdemon

[Redleg 42,039]

Scully got us Hogan.

It was a great draft

No, Sheedy got us Hogan, with his greed and revenge, on the club that overlooked him.

[Wrecker45 3,378]

Tough footballers win premierships.

The best teams of the modern era Brisbane, Geelong and Hawthorn have all had a staple of tough footballers.

Barassi, Whitten & Matthews are widely regarded as the best to have played the game do you notice a pattern? Abblett senior went toe to toe with Lester Ellis and gave as good as he got.

It is not rocket science.

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Tough footballers win premierships.

The best teams of the modern era Brisbane, Geelong and Hawthorn have all had a staple of tough footballers.

Barassi, Whitten & Matthews are widely regarded as the best to have played the game do you notice a pattern? Abblett senior went toe to toe with Lester Ellis and gave as good as he got.

It is not rocket science.

It's nearly 2016. Catch up please

[Biffen 12,949]

But the Red and Blueprint said it would work.

[Middymalt 244]

No, Sheedy got us Hogan, with his greed and revenge, on the club that overlooked him.

Yeah but we waited an extra 4 years for the pick in that time continually lost and went broke again there was no winners in the Scully deal except the AFL

[Little Goffy 14,791]

Given the trade value we got for Scully, the apparent emergence of Gawn as a premium quality ruck, and the impending [most glorious and illustrious] return of Trengove, in the end it might not be so bad.

But I'm not sure there's much merit in raking over these old bones.

[monoccular 17,697]

And last year was the 2014 draft -

Brayshaw

Petracca

Stretch

ANB

O Mac

White and

vandenBerg

Let's talk about this one

I agree, but there are some people who just can't resist wallowing in the past.

The past has passed; the future is ahead.

Go Demons