Adam Treloar

[blue and red in the head 95]

I think treloar should be our no1 target. Pay him what he wants 800k/900k the kid is an absolute jet. Our first pick and Howe would have to beat anything the pies are offering. Get it done. Also what ever happened to sipposs from the Saint from memory he had a good kick on him. Big wraps on him a couple of years ago

[Watts Jurrah Dunn? 735]

Has anyone got any mail on why we haven't even been mentioned in the same sentence as Treloar by the media?

The talk is Collingwood is almost a done deal, and that North Melbourne and Richmond are also really involved with big offers.

Did Treloar tell us he's not interested and not to waste our time?

We must have so much money. I'm really surprised not to have heard we've made a big offer.

[boydie 655]

Has anyone got any mail on why we haven't even been mentioned in the same sentence as Treloar by the media?

The talk is Collingwood is almost a done deal, and that North Melbourne and Richmond are also really involved with big offers.

Did Treloar tell us he's not interested and not to waste our time?

We must have so much money. I'm really surprised not to have heard we've made a big offer.

Because we're irrelevant...

[DeeZee 7,393]

Because we're irrelevant...

Bullcrap!

We have more upside than North or Richmond.

Just ask Brayshaw Petracca and Gawn, three youngsters who have extended their contracts.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I don't know why players are keen to join the filth. They are treading water and other clubs will be on the up quicker than them.

They've taken a hit in recent years by trading away some decent players but what they got in return will see them back up the ladder in no time.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,176]

Couldn't agree less. Have done a substantial rebuild yet nobody has realized. Have a gun coach. Why wouldn't you want to join them.

I would take our list over theirs if I was Treloar.

Swan 31

Cloke 28

Pendles 27

Sidebottom is an excellent 3rd/4th mid, Frost will be a very good defender, Adams is good DeGoey could be good. But really what else do they have aside from small flankers?

[Ethan Tremblay 30,858]

I thought I'd read that because of salary cap problems that a few hadn't had contracts extended.

Correct me if I'm wrong.

He signed an extension last year until end of 2017.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

He signed an extension last year until end of 2017.

Don't forget the pact......Tomlinson is in it.

[Mach5 4,767]

In the past a mid 2nd rounder would be worth little to GWS as they might not even use it, or for another team its a roll of the dice that someone you rate as a first rounder slips through.

Now it has serious value for GWS and some others (this year at least) because it might significantly reduce the ongoing cost of an academy player even though there's no players you actually really like at that stage of the draft anyway (this year at least).

So Tomlinson for our 2nd rounder most years would be a carp offer, but this year it would look very appealing to GWS.

So in that way, the northern academies can really work in our favour, if we're smart.

Just saying.

Love the idea of Tomlinson btw.

[ChaserJ 5,096]

Don't forget the pact......Tomlinson is in it.

What about Treloar?

[jumbo returns 6,741]

What about Treloar?

Yep.

[Thrice 216]

Added to that, managers love linking their clients to Collingwood, apparently just a mention of the "wealthiest" may raise the value or asking price. At least thats on theory, no clue if it holds any merit... >.<

Close: The Herald Sun put the Pies (and the Tiges) in the article for every player on the move. Click bait for the website and an extra 10,000 copies sold. Fact.

That said, the Pies do seem to be genuinely in the race for Treloar. Aish, no chance.

[SaberFang 7,151]

Treloar, Pies, yes. Aish, no.

[Slartibartfast 17,273]

I would take our list over theirs if I was Treloar.

Swan 31

Cloke 28

Pendles 27

Sidebottom is an excellent 3rd/4th mid, Frost will be a very good defender, Adams is good DeGoey could be good. But really what else do they have aside from small flankers?

Adams, DeGoey, Broomhead, Crisp, Elliott, Freeman, Grundy, Kennedy, Langdon, Marsh, Maynard, Moore, Scharenberg, Willams.

I reckon they have a lot to work with. Each to their own. And that doesn't address the 9 years of "rebuilds" we've had and Treloar would have every right to doubt this one. Plus Collingwood is a much better brand than MFC and playing in front of 60,000+ at the G most weeks would have it's attractions.

I know if it was my son who'd I'd suggest if I was impartial.

[Chris 2,892]

In the past a mid 2nd rounder would be worth little to GWS as they might not even use it, or for another team its a roll of the dice that someone you rate as a first rounder slips through.

Now it has serious value for GWS and some others (this year at least) because it might significantly reduce the ongoing cost of an academy player even though there's no players you actually really like at that stage of the draft anyway (this year at least).

So Tomlinson for our 2nd rounder most years would be a carp offer, but this year it would look very appealing to GWS.

So in that way, the northern academies can really work in our favour, if we're smart.

Just saying.

Love the idea of Tomlinson btw.

I gather the offer of a bad tasting fish is not a good one

[Whispering_Jack 30,101]

Wondering if Collingwood is ahead of the game in the quest to bolster its midfield ~ Collingwood to trade future picks in bid to secure Treloar and Aish

[What 18,810]

Wondering if Collingwood is ahead of the game in the quest to bolster its midfield ~ Collingwood to trade future picks in bid to secure Treloar and Aish

I can see the Pies regretting that big time in October 2016 when Aish has spudded it up iand they have no first rounder to use

[Forest Demon 4,681]

I can see the Pies regretting that big time in October 2016 when Aish has spudded it up iand they have no first rounder to use

Yep, Treloar is a gun but I would be very hesitant on compromising future drafts for Aish.

[Little Richard 6,262]

Bullcrap!

We have more upside than North or Richmond.

Just ask Brayshaw Petracca and Gawn, three youngsters who have extended their contracts.

Upside means nothing until we start winning more games. North and Richmond are competitive and beating top four sides. We aren't.

[Ted Lasso 19,516]

I dont think aish is going to get to collingwood, simply because brisbane will demand overs to make a point after the beams thing

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,394]

SEN reporting he's chosen the Tigers.

If true sucked in to anyone associated with the Collingwood football club in any capacity.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,394]

To be fair KB is going with it.

[Demon Jack 6,909]

Big get for Richmond if true. Can't believe we were never identified as a possible club who were interested.

[deeko 952]

Big get for Richmond if true. Can't believe we were never identified as a possible club who were interested.

Having no idea at all personally, I would say we definitely would have enquired and enquired hard about Adam.

I'd rather us being stealth about these sort of things rather than public about it as the last thing we want is to hear "the dees are in to player x, player y and player z" and then get none of them. Doesn't sound great.

I still have faith we will jag a big fish from somewhere.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,394]

If nothing else I've just unloaded about 25 text messages to 3 of my mates. 2 Collingwood and 1 Richmond. A as Dees member I get so much joy out of the little things.