Post Match Discussion - Round 17

[Coq au vin 755]

Grimes must never be picked again. He is useless and a turnover Queen.

[chook fowler 19,429]

Dawes' first 3 kicks were all unbelievably putrid. He dribbled a pass towards a leading Hogan, then he went across half forward and kicked it to the opposition instead of going towards goal, then he runs into goal and dribbles it wide from less than 20m. I always cringe when we recruit players from other sides dating back to the Ben Hollands of this world. Clubs usually dress up their trades and we get lumped with them.

Ben Holland could at least take a mark and could be played down back. Dawes is a poor mans version - it doesn't get much worse than that.

I was disgusted with his performance today.

[samcantstandya 1,041]

Anybody see a shepherd.

Anybody see anger.

Anybody see heart.

Anybody see our blood.

I am also sick of our players tackling and then falling to the ground and it's in the back & when we throw a hand out and give them an around the neck, or we are near the boundary and we toe pock it for a free. We must rate as either the dumbest players in the league or we don't practice our tackling.

[Coq au vin 755]

Sorry about your multi, Song....

Hogan will leave ASAP. He's no David Schwarz anyway.

[chook fowler 19,429]

Grimes must never be picked again. He is useless and a turnover Queen.

I must have missed something - thought he was one of our best.

[Coq au vin 755]

You obviously weren't at the MCG. He was terrible.

[Coq au vin 755]

At least we wont have to worry about anymore annoying 'we can still make the finals' threads.

LOL

[Wiseblood 24,637]

I'd like the boys to win more games so the posters who love wallowing in their own filth have nothing to say and we don't have to wade through their muck within these threads.

Cheers to those who provide a measured opinion. You are like gold around here.

[Forest Demon 4,681]

You obviously weren't at the MCG. He was terrible.

I think you will find you might be in the minority there. He was one of the better of a very bad lot today.

[Earl Hood 6,068]

Grimes must never be picked again. He is useless and a turnover Queen.

30 odd possessions at 80% efficiency. Yes he struggled at times but tell who would not when we don't work as a unit. Today was Everyman for himself but Grimes had a go, he tried, yes he failed at times but he kept presenting from what I saw on TV. There are others who don't present when needed as is so evident by our static play.

[Coq au vin 755]

The umpires were dog vomit standard.

[JV7 2,349]

In the scheme of things it's one game of football, a few things went wrong and some horrible umpring didn't help our cause. The result has no bearing on September.

However,

To attract players and members over the off-season (and thus give ourselves a genuine chance to improve), we need to show marked improvement on the field. For mine, that's 7-8 wins. We can't afford to be dropping the winnable ones especially in this fashion. Therefore, we must now beat Carlton (obviously) but also *pinch* a game against one of Collingwood, Bulldogs, Giants or North. Can't see it happening.

Very disappointing.

Im usually have the optimistic view of "oh well what does it matter, we aren't going to play finals anyway" but no F%#K it I've had enough of that, you know what it does fuking matter... It matters to all us supporters who go week in week out and put our hard earned towards memberships for the club and they dish this [censored] up week in week out. 12 months ago, we sat through games like this and thought "it's all part of the process, in time we will be better off" we are no better of then when Roos took over 18 months ago. I am really at the end with this football club, they show us nothing.

I have a feeling Roos has given Goodwin the opportunity to add in an attacking flare and the players are now caught in between wanting to move the ball quickly and wanting to defend but are doing neither and we don't have the smarts or skill to move it quick.. Our players idea of moving it quick is to flick a handball to the closest person to them (usually stationary) and with an opponent on their tail. What happened to the attacking style we saw earlier in the year against GC then Queens birthday against collingwood and when we beat Geelong... I don't know where we go to from here

Edited July 26, 2015 by JV7

[Demon Jack 6,836]

I've gone to see the Dees at the MCG over the last three weeks and all games have been extremely disappointing. Even the win against Brisbane left me wanting more. I love the club I've already agreed to see my friends football team play next Saturday over the Dees. However knowing my luck, Hogan will kick 8 and we'll smash the Pies by 10 goals.

[Nasher 33,607]

Grimes must never be picked again. He is useless and a turnover Queen.

There's always one.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,216]

I've gone to see the Dees at the MCG over the last three weeks and all games have been extremely disappointing. Even the win against Brisbane left me wanting more. I love the club I've already agreed to see my friends football team play next Saturday over the Dees. However knowing my luck, Hogan will kick 8 and we'll smash the Pies by 10 goals.

I doubt it Jack!

[Coq au vin 755]

There's always one.

Were you at the MCG?

[P-man 13,366]

However knowing my luck, Hogan will kick 8 and we'll smash the Pies by 10 goals.

There's a better chance of Roosy giving you a call during the week and asking you to strap on the boots.

You'd probably do a better job than half of them out there today so here's hoping.

[Moonshadow 17,672]

Im sick of people even mentioning the umpiring after an effort like today. Thats like someone p1ss1ng in your mouth and your pointing out that your Tshirt is getting wet.

FFS, there is so much more to be concerned about after today than some [censored] umpiring decisions.

Wait until we are matching it with other sides and the results come down to umpiring decisions THEN we can discuss it. Until then it is just pointless noise

Your analogy made me spit out my beer in laughter!

[Ethan Tremblay 30,778]

Just got off the ground from playing my own game.

Rushes to phone to get score.

[censored] this football club.

Weak was urine.

Who do you play for?

I'm done for the year. You're a better man than me if you make the trip to Subi!

[monoccular 17,400]

I've asked this question quite a few times now and no one has been able to answer me: why will/would Jesse hogan stay with us? Someone convince me?

Sadly, seriously, I did get the impression today that he was starting to lose interest in this inept team (using the term 'team' very loosely, as a team is a group of people with similar interests working together towards a common goal - clearly MFC are not a team. They are not working towards a common purpose as they appear to have no aims or purpose at all.)

His departure would be the final nail in the rapidly filling coffin into which thus club Isabel to quickly descending. We may fluke one more win this season but there really has been little progress.

One needs to kick goals to have any chance of winning. 7,8,5 goals against ordinary teams the past rounds is never going to win, and never ever going to attract or retain membership, or perhaps more importantly, decent players.

[thedirtydog24 18]

Until Garland, Grimes, Bail, Terlich, M.Jones, McKenzie go, were aren't going to improve. All 25+ and are list cloggers.

Edited July 26, 2015 by thedirtydog24

[Coq au vin 755]

Until Garland, Grimes, Bail, Terlich, M.Jones, McKenzie go, were aren't going to improve. All 25+ and are list cloggers.

Spuds and duds most of the team. We don't have the cattle.

[Coq au vin 755]

Max Gawn was our best today. I've changed my opinion of him. However he must stop tapping the ball directly to the opposition at centre bounces.

[jnrmac 20,040]

How about " it's not good enough. I share your frustration"

That'll help.

[Adam The God 29,950]

I must have missed something - thought he was one of our best.

His hospital handballs that consistently put team mates under pressure and his inability to win crucial one-on-ones put a large cross next to him. Think that'll be his last game.