Adelaide v Melbourne POST MATCH DISCUSSION - ROUND 3

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Jack Squatts.

[Moonshadow 16,619]

I miss Jeff White, we need more than a war horse tap ruckman, we need a ruckman that gets some ball round the ground

Yes, the Crow mids read his taps easily. It was almost as if he was tapping to their advantage. You'd think he came from Sth Aust......... oh, wait....

[jumbo returns 6,619]

Rename this discussion the Watts/Dawes hen peckin' party.

[RickyJ45 392]

where's TMac contract at ? lock him in for another 8

[Canplay 575]

Watts needs to play and improve. Terrible conditions today but we need his skills if we are to win.

Dawes offering nothing, I'd rather Pederson or Gawn.

Dyson has got to stop butchering it. Bradshaw and hogan will be stars but hogan has been poor set shot kick since kid, and needs real remedial work. Cross tries guts out but his kick into forward 50 consistently isn't good enough. Howe looks like he's going through motions (perhaps already agreed terms with GWS) but thought garland battled really well.

Umpiring was shocking.

[Eelesie 216]

[Pedersen] for Watts next week.

This is actually an idea... Dawes or watts...

Has he done much in the two's?

[Moonshadow 16,619]

Crows converted well while Dees missed too many gimmes

[Emerald 1,743]

J.Watts -3 votes.... Ha!

According to his mum

[Roger Mellie 3,668]

I think you should give Watts a break. It's very difficult to take a clean mark when your hands get continually tangled up in your frock.

[Redleg 38,585]

20 players tried their guts out.

Poor kicking for goal.

Disgraceful home town umpiring.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Don't understand the hate on Dawes. Bloke had a dislocated finger and looked like the English Patient for most of the second half, and the moment Frost was injured he was asked to do some rucking around the ground. Plus it [censored] with rain for the second half. We are so quick to bag him but he gives a contest each and every week.

Terrific effort from the boys today. Adelaide are a side that have looked sensational two weeks running and we went with them all day. Apart for some poor kicking for goal we matched them in all areas.

Watts deserves a bit of harsh criticism today. That dropped mark led to 2 goals in 30 seconds in the first term - if we hold them we go into the first term break 2 goals up.

All in all though we were fantastic and I can't fault the effort for one second. McDonald awesome, Hogan and Brayshaw are the future and we are a better side all round. Bring on the Tigers.

[Demonsone 1,741]

This effort needs to be std.... Understand were the list & some great signs in Hogan, Bradshaw etc

But Watts 2 dropped marks cost us 2 goals ... Defenders busted thr ass to win & then to see him turn it over.. Honestly I wonder if he has the intensity to able to play at the level to win these tough games let alone finals!

[Demonsone 1,741]

This effort needs to be std.... Understand were the list & some great signs in Hogan, Bradshaw etc

But Watts 2 dropped marks cost us 2 goals ... Defenders busted thr ass to win the ball back & then to see him turn it over.. Honestly I wonder if he has the intensity to able to play at the level to win these tough games let alone finals!

Edited April 18, 2015 by Hogan2014

[highroller 112]

Watts is ok stop picking on him - Richmond are his bunnies every time and we want him playing next week. Its Dawes that has to go although if Frost is hurt he might stick around.

[Lucifers Hero 37,524]

20 players tried their guts out.

Poor kicking for goal.

Disgraceful home town umpiring.

Agree. We should all be over the moon about this 4 qtr effort.

Let the mistakes go and enjoy what they did...it bodes very well.

I'd be worried if I were the tigers!!

[Moonshadow 16,619]

Watts needs to play and improve. Terrible conditions today but we need his skills if we are to win.

Dawes offering nothing, I'd rather [Pedersen] or Gawn.

Dyson has got to stop butchering it. Bradshaw and hogan will be stars but hogan has been poor set shot kick since kid, and needs real remedial work. Cross tries guts out but his kick into forward 50 consistently isn't good enough. Howe looks like he's going through motions (perhaps already agreed terms with GWS) but thought garland battled really well.

Umpiring was shocking.

Agree 100% about Hogan's set shots. In the long run, that action needs to be rectified to get the most goals in his career. I don't GAF how many he kicks at training. Run in a straight line towards goal and keep the ball steady, follow it onto your boot. Only Buddy can now do anything different and get away with it on a regular basis. Melb needs Dunstall or someone similar to work with him to get it right while he is still very young. Other than that, he's a fantastic prospect.

[Demon3 2,541]

Watts was good first game, good first half last week, shocking this week. You can't drop him. Ridiculous. Dawes must go. Need a lot more from Kent, Howe to go Fwd, Tyson has had a slow start, need Ruck support. Good effort from most today. 84 tackles says we stayed on the game. But we let them kick 2 goals after half time before we woke up, happens way to often, and set shots really bad today. Hogan should have kicked 4, Jeffy 3.. We were not without chances.

[jumbo returns 6,619]

I think you should give Watts a break. It's very difficult to take a clean mark when your hands get continually tangled up in your frock.

Humour?

Feedback: not funny.

[Bonkers 918]

Positives:

-Attack on the ball & player when not in possession especially in the first quarter.

-Pressure on the opposition coming out of their backline & creating goals from turnovers in the first quarter.

-The game was faught out over four quarters

Negatives:

-Intensity drop off & loss of momentum after Watts dropped two marks.

-Goals against from clearances

-Ball movement down the boundary at times was terrible. Almost like watching a team coached by Neeld.

-Losing possession of the ball in transition through failing to switch, lack of numbers providing options, poor work rate, poor disposal etc

[Deestroy All 14,262]

I'm happy with Dawes' effort. He frustrates me but if Pedo isn't in form I'll keep him as 2nd ruck if Frosty goes out.

He and Watts like Richmond, that's all I have to hold on to.

Has Betts ever touched the ball on Never Jetta?

Nev will have a trophy room with flashy forwards mounted heads on the wall when he's done. Betts and Wingard the first 2 inductees.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Humour?

Feedback: not funny.

I just ignore these now. He certainly deserves some criticism today but every second post is some peanut trying to be clever about it and failing miserably.

[jacey 333]

Jeff Garlett brings a lot but 3 weeks in a row, he has missed gimmes.

That's not good enough. Same with Kent. Misses way too many gimmes.

Watts. We're passed that stage. Just disappointed now.

on the positives. Jetta and McDonald are beasting.

[Demonsone 1,741]

Watts is ok stop picking on him - Richmond are his bunnies every time and we want him playing next week. Its Dawes that has to go although if Frost is hurt he might stick around.

All players drop marks.. But dropped 1 with no pressure & caused d a 2 goal turnaround late in the 1st qtr.. The gap between his worst & best is too wide!

Edited April 18, 2015 by Hogan2014

[Ted Lasso 17,318]

Umpiring was awful.

Danger takes three Melbourne players out of play with an unrealistic marking attempt that got nowhere near the ball, and he didn't even put his hands up to mark resulting directly in a tex goal, apparently that sort of thing is within the rules.

Watts dropped mark was huge, he marks that and it may have saved 3 Crows goals at an important time, maybe the crowd shuts up a bit and jesse and jeff aren't as put off by the crowd

[jumbo returns 6,619]

Col Garland was good today.

Will Howe's mark win a Jeep?

Edited April 18, 2015 by jumbo returns