Jesse Hogan - back injury

[What 18,810]

it sucks that we will likely be missing our big 3 main tall forward targets

But we still have the luxury of having two pretty handy players in Howe and Fitzy as the targets inside 50

Its nice to have some depth and talent for once

[dbj1983 138]

SEN just reported that the MFC have said results will be back and the club will confirm status at 2:00pm today.

[CHAMP 347]

I wonder if Roos will think about swinging Watts forward.

If we had Garland, we could've swung him forward, we can't even do that.

St Kilda will firm in this week, I don't see where our goals will come from.

Dees still solid at $1.55 on Sportsbet.

Saints have recently shaded GWS for Spoon favouritism.

Edited March 6, 2014 by CHAMP

[Gorgoroth 12,697]

Not for long Champ.

[Bedraggled Dee 336]

I just love that this came from Barrett. Yet again our club is too spineless to properly report injuries

Really???? Dont now why the club would wait till they were properly informed to report things to you. I am surprised JP and Roosy dont have you on speed dial. I am sure you have all the answers.

[DemonOX 8,692]

Who's the fart head that kneed him in the back???????????????

[ManDee 7,124]

I think ill take up drinking

What's up-drinking? Should you really be taking it at this time when we have no forward line? I need a Jack.

[Bedraggled Dee 336]

Yeah it makes you wonder if much has changed personally I would be surprised if it has and letting supporters find that out by a [censored] that we all despise is really disappointing but should be expected.

Hah ha ha ha ha, The self mportance of people on this forum is a laugh. The club dont have a office full of people employed purely to tell members things that 1, they can do nothing about and 2, will generate negative reactions based on a limited understanding.

I think Burgo and the media department do a good job given the obvious financial and marketing limitations. They will release information when they have confirmed the situation with the medical department and the football department is comfortable with the release. Whats the point in reporting that Hogan has a sore back that may or may not be a problem in he is undergoing scans.

How about instead of bagging the Club you are all meant to love you point your finger at the the pond muck in the media that feel the need to release guess work in guise of breaking news just to get it our first. It may be the the info that the slime released on the footy show is right but as evidenced by his passed history he is wrong just as often.

[mjt 640]

Really???? Dont now why the club would wait till they were properly informed to report things to you. I am surprised JP and Roosy dont have you on speed dial. I am sure you have all the answers.

As a paid up member I would've preferred to read it on the club website than hear it from some weasel that takes pleasure out of announcing it on the FS, I dont think its to much to ask for. Edited March 6, 2014 by mjt

[Hannibal 5,814]

As a paid up member I would've preferred to read it on the club website than hear it from some weasel that takes pleasure out of announcing it on the FS, I dont think its to much to ask for.

Sook.

[mjt 640]

Sook.

That hurts coming from the biggest gutless sook on this forum.

[DeeZee 7,296]

I think we just have to wait until we hear from the club this afternoon.

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

If he was running laps on tuesday it must be fairly minor. Anything more serious and he would be imobilized for at least a few days.

Might still have a valium though washed down with a G &T.

We just do not have any luck rolling....YET.

[Jaded No More 67,609]

Lets wait until 2pm and see. Maybe it's minor bruising or a slight fracture that will heal and be fine by Round 2 or 3.

As much as I'd like to automatically proceed to the panic station, it could be OK.

At least we are playing "softer" opponents first up. Doesn't mean we take them lightly, or that we're going to win, but at least we are a chance.

Our draw starts to get very difficult from Round 4 onwards, and I'm hoping we can have 2 of Hogan, Dawes or Clark back by that time. And maybe Garland.

[hardtack 10,400]

It's interesting that still there is nothing on Real Footy and nothing on the MFC site... so far, apart from a few tweets, the only article I have seen is on the AFL website and that was from the "pen" of Damian Barrett.

[Machsy 2,858]

I doubt DB has sources within the medical dept of every club.

Much more likely his source for this sort of thing are low level employees at the facilities where scans are done.

More than likely ones that aren't fully informed but are able to give him enough info to postulate.

E.g. "Hogan has come in for scans on his back"

The rest is DB adding mayo so it sounds like he knows what he is talking about to the everyday mongoloid reading the article while their brain is on autopilot.

It probably will be 8 weeks, but I'm ok with that.

Players get injuries. That's football.

[nutbean 8,838]

As a paid up member I would've preferred to read it on the club website than hear it from some weasel that takes pleasure out of announcing it on the FS, I dont think its to much to ask for.

SOP for all clubs - journo's always get a sniff and unlike the clubs who wait to get the full medico advice before publishing, the journo's will quickly report 10% fact and basically make up the rest.

You see it for every club - how many times have I read in the papers journo's quickly report that "this player" has suspected "that injury" and is out for 6,10,12 or "potentially season/career ending" only to have the club report 2 days later that the player will be out for a couple of weeks.

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

It's interesting that still there is nothing on Real Footy and nothing on the MFC site... so far, apart from a few tweets, the only article I have seen is on the AFL website and that was from the "pen" of Damian Barrett.

i agree. The club has been fairly quick on player welfare lately so i hold out some hope.

[praha 11,100]

Roos said he won't play according to Channel 7 journo Nick McCallum (who I trust a lot more than Barrett...)

http://twitter.com/nickmccallum7/status/441538136632328192

[Vipercrunch 2,820]

Anyone recall him coming off during the game on Friday night after a solid knock? I'm planning to have a look at the Geelong game again on the weekend I will be paying very close attention to any hits to his back.

[Sir Why You Little 36,587]

Roos said he won't play according to Channel 7 journo Nick McCallum (who I trust a lot more than Barrett...)

http://twitter.com/nickmccallum7/status/441538136632328192

Well that is a lot more promising than the Footy Show.

A major reason why i don't rush home to watch it.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,320]

At least we are playing "softer" opponents first up. Doesn't mean we take them lightly, or that we're going to win, but at least we are a chance.

Except for West Coast in round 2. They're going to be amazing this year.

[nutbean 8,838]

So what. Do you think the official AFL website will just publish anything and everything without any kind of approval process?

Grow up guys. It's not a conspiracy, it's really happening.

For the record - Yes - the "official AFL website" has editorial freedom from the AFL and does not need or get approval.

If you go back to the Voldermort thread ( Scully ) I took exception with an opinion piece on AFL.com from Jason Phelan and contacted the editor Geoff Slattery. I suggested that I would like to respond but it would be very uncomplimentary of Andrew D and I said they wouldn't publish. Not only did they publish but Slattery also went on the front foot on AFL.com and spoke about their independence and would publish without fear or favour as long as it was not offensive and it is not entirely fabricated.

So I would suggest that AFL.com would purely accept DB's "credentials" and just publish.

[sue 9,000]

As a paid up member I would've preferred to read it on the club website than hear it from some weasel that takes pleasure out of announcing it on the FS, I dont think its to much to ask for.

It is too much to ask. If you don't want to hear news from unofficial sources which upsets you, perhaps you'd better stop watching those sorts of shows. Either that or get yourself a job within the medical department of the club.

Otherwise you will regularly see and read a mixture of half-baked news, speculative circulation-raising 'news' and occasionally spot-on information before it is on the MFC web site. But it's not a peculiar failing of the MFC - it's true for almost anything, business, politics etc.

[Nasher 33,607]

Looks like Pedo and Fitzy are our key forwards this year.

If that's the case you can kiss Chip goodbye.

Get a frigging grip. A few injuries to key forwards = all our key forwards out for the whole year = Frawley gone. I worry about the condition of minds that automatically infer the worst possible scenario on a slither of information.