Training - Wednesday 11th December, 2013

[Demon_Tingles 211]

Although these photos may be distorted. The bottom photo makes Jack Viney look like an absolute dwarf

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

At a bar less than two weeks ago one of his teammates stated "Toumpas plays like a girl". Perhaps he's trying to shed this image.

Congratulations BH, a perfect example of why clubs hate forums

[Hannibal 5,814]

I gathered that. There are 2 points though.

You perceive players as being "soft" when it's not warranted.

And you take pleasure in potting them when that's the case.

I find it obnoxious, especially when it's a kid that has little chance to disprove your strong opinion.

Would you bother potting a myriad of other players that perform the very same or similar roles at other clubs with aplomb, and by your definition would still be termed soft? Brad or Stephen Hill? Lewis Jetta? Isaac Smith? Essentially any outside runner?

Surely you understand the importance of having these players in a side.

It's great when they are tough as nails and win contested footy too, but how often does that happen?

You're potting Toumpas for his impact in his first season.

You know he was coming off surgery on both hips.

And he solidly outperformed your lovechild Hanneberry in their respective first seasons, regardless of what excuses you'd like to make for him.

It was but one example, chosen due to your incessant boy-crush commentary.

I doubt it.

No, I perceive players are soft when it is warranted and you'll also note that I haven't labelled Toumpas soft. He was surprisingly out of his depth for a highly performed junior mid, especially one that had performed well in senior company in the SANFL, but I have not labelled him soft. Perhaps you can highlight where I have ? Yes, yes, you'll say I've inferred it. But no, no, you simply have poor comprehension skills. By all means trawl over posts.

I call players soft that are soft. Not all predominantly outside players are soft. Who has said they are ? I don't equate lightly framed receivers as being soft UNLESS they are. Some are, some aren't and there are degrees in between. Once again, you read what you want to read and not what is said. You guess.

I'm not potting Toumpas for his "impact" in his first season. I didn't expect "impact", although it's always nice. I'm merely commenting on what I saw, and he was surprisingly out of his depth and very low on confidence. He didn't believe he belonged. He didn't believe he was ready. He was right. I look forward to 2014 and rate his prospects highly. I defend him to my Brother, because it will take years before he can be properly evaluated.

Show posts where I fawn over Hannebery. I rate his hardness, but have also stated that he's not elite in one area of the game outside of endurance. Once again, you guess.

I'm surprised your logic and thinking is as blunt as it appears.

Edited December 12, 2013 by Ben-Hur

[What 18,810]

Photo gallery: Wednesday 11 December

Have a look at Toump. Gee he impresses me, seems to have added bulk in his upper body. Can't wait to see him tear the opposition a new one this year.

Very generous of the OFFICAL MFC website to upload a whopping 9 pics for the fans

What a bunch of lazy pricks

[Machsy 2,858]

It was inferred, whether you like it or not.

[Moonshadow 17,558]

You take a third hand quote from someone said in private questioning a players courage and choose to insult that player in a public forum where there is a good chance his parents and friends will see it while all the time hiding behind an internet name.

The hypocrisy is astounding particularly from someone calling themselves "Ben-Hur" and having as little sex kitten as his avatar!

I think I know who is the girl is in this affair.

Ouch, that's gotta hurt.

[Undeeterred 3,045]

Toumpas will be fine - who cares how he plays, as long as he is picking up lots of possies and sending them in the right direction.

[dazzledavey36 52,923]

That photo of Cross is freakish..

[Hannibal 5,814]

It was inferred, whether you like it or not.

Where ?

[Roost It 1,434]

The softest thing on this site is Ben Hur

Have you ever heard anyone so keen on the sound of their own opinion

He's now quoting his cousin who is clearly sharing the same family trait of covering their glaring weaknesses by pointing out others issues

He's the guy who bullied the wimpy kids at school until one finally hit him

He now hides out as the local bully on Internet forums

Edited December 12, 2013 by Roost It

[bing181 9,007]

Training discussion anyone?

[Hannibal 5,814]

The softest thing on this site is Ben Hur

He's the guy who bullied the wimpy kids at school until one finally hit him

He now hides out as the local bully on Internet forums

Show me an example of any bullying and I'll gladly apologise. I abhor the practice.

Maybe robust debate is now considered bullying.

Anyway, back up your statement with examples.

[PaulRB 6,297]

That photo of Cross is freakish..

Amazing definition.

No fat on that...

[P-man 13,366]

Cross is a beast. So wrapped we picked him up.

[monoccular 17,340]

Well said Hardtack.

Players putting each other down in public and demonlanders posting said put-downs here promotes the opposite mind set to the all for one, one for all team spirit that successful teams have and that Roos especially encourages.

Unfortunately, and as usual, this thread is beginning to degenerate into "he said, she said" on a very much off topic issue. Can we stop it right here and now? Please?

Why should I determine what needs to be censored on Demonland. It's a trivial aside by one player that was silly enough to say it. But it's also relevant. I doubt he's the only player that thinks it and I for one have rarely seen such a highly ranked junior so out of his depth at AFL level. But I also don't condemn his future over it as I have great faith he'll adjust and work it out with good coaching and development.

The player was silly to say it and you can please yourself as to the merits of the comment or otherwise.

I won't be silly enough to name the player, as it's irrelevant to the statement.

Do we really know for certain that a player did actually say that - I mean just because a poster here said he heard that it was said by a third party in a bar, does that make it true?

I would think, as Shakespeare put it, much ado about nothing.

[dazzledavey36 52,923]

For anyone down tomorrlw Dom Tyson is baxk in full training. Would love a good report on him

[rjay 24,616]

Cross is a beast. So wrapped we picked him up.

He will prove to be a good get.

[Courtney_Fish 183]

Just when I was thinking of giving odds on who had the last say, everyone stopped!

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

I reckon Toumpas will be a gun. Very happy we picked him.

I also enjoy BH's contributions, and don't see why it's so offensive that he posted something he heard as to a player's apparent assessment of another player's hardness at the ball.

It's relevant, even if it might be inaccurate/unreliable.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

For anyone down tomorrlw Dom Tyson is baxk in full training. Would love a good report on him

I would also appreciate a report on Aiden Riley. This guy could be a smokey. From all accounts, there's absolutely no way he plays like a girl.

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

I would also appreciate a report on Aiden Riley. This guy could be a smokey. From all accounts, there's absolutely no way he plays like a girl.

Would also love to hear about Kent and McKenzie. Have barely heard a thing about either all preseason.

[PaulRB 6,297]

I'd love it if some of our players played with the aggression of a Serena or Venus Williams, Lauren Jackson,... ...

I know is a "footy forum" so misogyny is expected... but in my book misogyny is far more tedious and offensive than the who said it about whoever...

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

Unfortunately, and as usual, this thread is beginning to degenerate into "he said, she said" on a very much off topic issue. Can we stop it right here and now? Please?

LIKE

[Swooper 255]

Boys were out on the track early this morning - warming up from before 9am.

I didn't stick around for much. I was just on my way past but in order of importance:

- The Toump does NOT have a new tattoo so hopefully Mrs Toump won't be demanding him back to Adelaide any time soon, although on the flip side he may still see the thread content continue as above debating his manliness. For what it is worth, I think he'll be a rippa.

- Reilly, Dawes, Kent all doing stationary kicking with Miller. Kent left pretty early so don't think you'll get much a report on him

And that is about it! Looking forward to reading the more detailed reports later.

[rpfc 28,052]

I reckon Toumpas will be a gun. Very happy we picked him.

I also enjoy BH's contributions, and don't see why it's so offensive that he posted something he heard as to a player's apparent assessment of another player's hardness at the ball.

It's relevant, even if it might be inaccurate/unreliable.

I'd say it is more relevant than Toumpas being labelled soft.

I am more keen to know who thinks it is ok to judge a rookie like that and forward that opinion to a fan.